Smile Loyalty vs Joy Loyalty: Which loyalty app is better?
I installed Smile and Joy on the same test store. Below, you'll find what each one costs as of November 2026, how they differ and which one I'd pick at each store size.
I have also compared a 3rd app along with Smile and Joy, Love Loyalty, which came out as the best loyalty app for Shopify in my research of 23 loyalty apps.
TL;DR:
- Pick Smile when you want the lowest entry price, Shopify POS on every plan or the same app on BigCommerce. It costs $15/month for up to 500 orders and $79/month for up to 1,000, against $29 and $104 on Joy. However, its VIP tiers start on a $199 plan, while Joy's start on a $129 plan.
- Pick Joy when your customers shop in Spanish, French, Japanese or another of its 8 storefront languages, or when you use Omnisend, Loox or Chatty. It offers VIP tiers, paid memberships, wallet passes and POS on its $129 Advanced plan, which costs $70 less than Smile's VIP plan at 2,000 orders.
- Pick Love Loyalty when you want a native all-in-one loyalty app with points, referrals, VIP tiers, paid memberships, wallet passes and POS in one plan, which offers up to 2,000 orders for only $79/month and unlimited orders for only $399/month.
The quick verdict:
- Do you want the lowest entry plan, POS on every plan or a second platform on BigCommerce? Choose Smile.
- Do you want a storefront in 8 languages, plus VIP tiers, paid memberships and POS on one $129 plan? Choose Joy.
- Do you want VIP tiers, paid memberships and POS in one plan for $79/month? Choose Love Loyalty.
How I compared Smile and Joy
I ran every app through the same checks, so each section below compares like with like:
- Test store: one Shopify test store and one theme, with no custom CSS in Smile or Joy
- Programme: the same points, VIP tiers and referral setup in Smile and Joy
- Prices: each app's plans at 500, 1,000, 2,000 and 5,000 orders a month and unlimited orders, on monthly billing, as of November 2026
- Reviews: every review where customers shared a problem with Smile (152) and Joy (31), the 20 newest 5-star reviews of each, and the 427 Love Loyalty reviews
- What decided most sections: the plan each app needs for VIP tiers and POS, and the storefront languages
Smile vs Joy pricing: what will you pay as your orders grow?
Smile costs less than Joy at 500 and 1,000 orders, Joy costs less at 2,000 and 5,000, and Love Loyalty costs the same or less than both. At 2,000 orders a month, Joy's $129 Advanced plan comes to about $3,096 over 2 years, while Smile's $199 Growth plan comes to about $4,776, and both include VIP tiers.
When I compared their pricing plans at 5 order volumes, this is what each app costs a month:
| Orders a month | Smile | Joy | Love Loyalty |
|---|---|---|---|
| 500 | $15 on its Essential plan, without VIP tiers | $29 on its Essential plan, without VIP tiers | $12 on its Professional plan, without VIP tiers |
| 1,000 | $79 on its Standard plan, without VIP tiers | $104 on its Essential plan, without VIP tiers | $79 on its Growth plan |
| 2,000 | $199 on its Growth plan | $129 on its Advanced plan | $79 on its Growth plan |
| 5,000 | $999 on its Plus plan, billed for 12 months at once | $499 on its Ultimate plan | $399 on its Plus plan |
| Unlimited orders | A custom quote on its Enterprise plan | A custom quote on its Custom plan | $399 on its Plus plan |
Prices as of November 2026. Developers change them, so check each app before you choose.
Smile's $15 and $79 plans pause your programme at their order limit until you upgrade. Its $199 Growth plan includes 2,500 orders, then adds $20 for every 100, and its $999 Plus plan includes 7,500 orders, then adds $5 for every 100.
Joy's $29 Essential plan includes 500 orders, then adds $15 for every 100, so 1,000 orders cost $104/month without VIP tiers. Its VIP tiers start on the $129 Advanced plan, which includes 2,000 orders, then adds $10 for every 100. Its $499 Ultimate plan includes 7,000 orders, then adds $5 for every 100, and every Shopify Plus brand gets a custom quote on its Custom plan.
At 1,000 orders, Smile and Love Loyalty both cost $79/month, but the plans differ. Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan includes VIP tiers, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes for up to 2,000 orders, then adds $15 for every 100. Smile's $79 Standard plan includes none of them, and I didn't find paid memberships or wallet passes in any Smile plan.
Say you stay at 2,000 orders. Over 2 years, Love Loyalty costs about $1,896, Joy about $3,096 and Smile about $4,776. Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan offers unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume.
Winner: Love Loyalty, because its $79 Growth plan with VIP tiers costs $50 less than Joy's $129 plan and $120 less than Smile's $199 at 2,000 orders, and its $399 Plus plan costs $100 less than Joy's $499 at 5,000. It also costs $3 less than Smile at 500 orders. Between the other two, Smile costs less at 500 and 1,000 orders and Joy at 2,000 and 5,000.
Quick comparison of Smile and Joy
Smile's main strength is its entry price, POS on every plan and BigCommerce. Joy's is language, integrations and what its $129 plan includes, and Love Loyalty's is what its first plans include.
This is how Smile, Joy and Love Loyalty compare at a glance:
| Smile | Joy | Love Loyalty | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Stores wanting a low entry plan, POS or BigCommerce | Stores selling in several languages | Shopify stores wanting more features per dollar |
| Price at 2,000 orders | $199 on its Growth plan | $129 on its Advanced plan | $79 on its Growth plan |
| VIP tiers from | $199 Growth plan | $129 Advanced plan | $79 Growth plan |
| Main on-site element | Floating loyalty button, every plan | Loyalty widget and nudge pop-ups, every plan | Points in the cart, from $12 Professional plan |
| Shopify POS | From $15 Essential plan | From $129 Advanced plan | From $12 Professional plan |
| Paid memberships | I didn't find them | From $129 Advanced plan | From $79 Growth plan |
| Wallet passes | I didn't find them | From $129 Advanced plan | From $79 Growth plan |
| Storefront languages | 9 | 8 | English only |
| Other platforms | BigCommerce | The pages I read name no other platform | Shopify only |
| Migration | CSV import, help on $999 Plus plan | Free, by its team, from Smile and other apps | Free, from $79 Growth plan |
| Setup time in my test | 18 minutes | 20 minutes | 15 minutes |
| Shopify App Store rating | 4.9 from 4,673 reviews | 4.9 from 1,789 reviews | 5.0 from 428 reviews |
| Free trial | 14 days on paid plans | 14 days on $29 and $129 plans, 30 days on $499 plan | 14 days on paid plans |
Smile's strengths:
- Lowest entry price: $15/month for 500 orders, against $29 on Joy and $12 on Love Loyalty.
- POS on every plan, while Joy keeps it for its $129 Advanced plan.
- Works on BigCommerce too, with 9 storefront languages.
Joy's strengths:
- VIP tiers from $129/month, against $199 on Smile, plus paid memberships and wallet passes.
- Omnisend, Loox and Chatty integrations from its $29 Essential plan.
- 8 storefront languages, with automatic translation on its $129 Advanced plan.
Love Loyalty's strengths:
- Paid memberships, B2B loyalty and wallet passes from $79/month, against $129 on Joy, and I didn't find them in Smile's plans.
- Redemption inside the cart from the $12 Professional plan, while Joy's cart drawer needs its $129 plan.
- POS from $12/month, against $15 on Smile and $129 on Joy.
Smile vs Joy features: which one offers more?
Joy offers more of the advanced features on a lower plan, and Smile offers POS on a lower plan. Love Loyalty offers both sets for the least. I set up the same points and VIP programme in Smile and Joy, then checked which plan each feature needs in all three apps.
This is the plan and price where each feature starts:
- Referrals: Smile on its $15 Essential plan, Joy on its $29 Essential plan with up to 100 referrals, Love Loyalty on its $12 Professional plan
- POS: Smile on its $15 Essential plan, Joy on its $129 Advanced plan, Love Loyalty on its $12 Professional plan
- Points expiry: Smile on its $199 Growth plan, Joy on its $29 Essential plan, Love Loyalty on its $12 Professional plan
- Bonus campaigns: Smile on its $79 Standard plan, Joy on its $129 Advanced plan, Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan
- VIP tiers: Smile on its $199 Growth plan, Joy on its $129 Advanced plan, Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan
- Redeem points in the cart: Joy in the cart drawer on its $129 Advanced plan, Love Loyalty on its $12 Professional plan, and Smile through its floating loyalty button
- Redeem points at checkout: Smile on its $199 Growth plan for Shopify Plus stores, Joy through checkout extensions on its $499 Ultimate plan for Shopify Plus stores, Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan
- Paid memberships, wallet passes and B2B loyalty: I didn't find them in Smile's plans, Joy on its $129 Advanced plan, Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan
Joy's $129 Advanced plan also rewards Instagram comments and story mentions automatically. One reviewer on Smile, WHITE COAT, warned in October 2025 against using it for B2B transactions.
On AI, Joy and Love Loyalty both draft a programme for you. Joy's AI copilot starts on its $29 Essential plan and Love Loyalty's on its $79 Growth plan. I didn't find AI features in Smile's plans.
Winner: Love Loyalty, because its $79 Growth plan includes VIP tiers, paid memberships, wallet passes and B2B loyalty, and its POS starts at $12. Joy needs its $129 plan for that set and for POS, and Smile needs $199 for VIP tiers. Of those two, Joy offers more advanced features and Smile offers POS from $15.
Smile vs Joy platforms and languages: where can you use each one?
Smile works on more platforms and in one more language. Love Loyalty is narrower than Smile on both counts: it's for Shopify and Shopify Plus stores, and its storefront is English only.
Smile works on Shopify and BigCommerce, so a brand that sells on both can keep one app. The pages I read name no other platform for Joy.
Smile offers 9 storefront languages and Joy offers 8. They share 7, including French, German, Japanese and Spanish. Smile adds Portuguese (Brazil) and Dutch, and Joy adds Indonesian.
Joy's manual translation starts on its $29 Essential plan, and its $129 Advanced plan translates automatically. In October 2025, BOUTIQUE SOVIST said Joy's French translation was poor, and Joy replied the next day and had fixed it by 2 November. 5 of the Smile reviews I read, from 2019 to 2024, said they couldn't translate emails and other customer-facing text.
Neither language gap matters for a store that sells in English only. For Portuguese or Dutch, Smile is the only one of the three I'd shortlist, and for Indonesian it's Joy.
Winner: Smile, because it works on Shopify and BigCommerce and offers 9 storefront languages against Joy's 8, and the pages I read name no other platform for Joy. Joy translates automatically from $129. Love Loyalty is Shopify only and its storefront is English only.
Smile vs Joy integrations: which one works with your other apps?
Joy connects to more of the tools merchants use from its first paid plan, and Smile's difference is Mailchimp and Gorgias. I checked the integrations in each app's settings.
These are the tools each app connects to:
- Email and SMS: Smile works with Klaviyo and Mailchimp, Joy with Klaviyo and Omnisend, Love Loyalty with Klaviyo
- Reviews: Smile works with Judge.me and Loox, Joy with Judge.me and Loox, Love Loyalty with Judge.me and other review apps
- Live chat: Joy works with Chatty
- Helpdesk: Smile works with Gorgias
- Subscriptions: all three work with Recharge
- Shopify Flow and customer accounts: all three
Smile limits how many it connects by plan: 1 integration on its $15 Essential plan, 2 on its $79 Standard plan and unlimited on its $199 Growth plan. Joy's 30+ integrations start on its $29 Essential plan. Love Loyalty offers Klaviyo, Shopify Flow and 30+ other integrations from its $12 Professional plan.
Winner: Joy, because it connects to Omnisend, Loox, Chatty and 30+ other tools from its $29 plan, while Smile connects 1 on its $15 plan and 2 on its $79 plan. Love Loyalty also offers 30+ integrations from $12 but doesn't connect to those three. Choose Smile when you rely on Mailchimp or Gorgias.
Smile vs Joy design: how does each one look on your store?
Both apps matched my theme without changes, but Joy offers more placements on its lower plans. I installed both on the same theme and looked at the product page, cart, loyalty page and customer account.
Smile showed a floating loyalty button by default, on every plan, and it matched my branding without changes. Its loyalty page starts on the $15 Essential plan, points on product pages on the $79 Standard plan and the Loyalty Hub in customer accounts on the $199 Growth plan.

Joy showed its programme through a loyalty widget and on-site nudge pop-ups on every plan, and the widget fit my theme without changes. Its loyalty page, built for Online Store 2.0, and custom CSS start on the $29 Essential plan. Redemption in the cart drawer and the Loyalty Hub inside Shopify's customer account start on the $129 Advanced plan.

Love Loyalty takes a different approach from both widgets: customers can redeem earned loyalty points directly in the cart, with no pop-up or floating button. It offers 20+ placements and unlimited customisation from its $12 Professional plan.

In the reviews I read, Bins and Boxes said in November 2025 that Smile's floating button didn't stay where they placed it, and Mamma Latte said in March 2025 that Joy's widget doesn't always load. Joy replied 2 days later. Of the 427 Love Loyalty reviews I read, 36 mention the cart.
Winner: Joy and Love Loyalty, because Joy's loyalty page and custom CSS start on its $29 plan and Love Loyalty offers 20+ placements and unlimited customisation from its $12 plan. Joy's widget matched my theme and so did Smile's, whose floating button stays its main way in until the $199 Growth plan, and Joy's cart-drawer redemption needs $129 while Love Loyalty's cart redemption starts at $12.
Smile vs Joy setup: how long does each one take?
Love Loyalty took me 15 minutes, Smile 18 and Joy 20. I timed each app from install to a working points and VIP programme.
In Smile, VIP tiers, referrals, points expiry and POS each needed their own settings. In Joy, VIP and B2B tiers, the rule engine, wallet passes and paid memberships all sit on the $129 Advanced plan, and setting up each one took most of the time. In Love Loyalty, most of it went on choosing from its 20+ placements.
Winner: Love Loyalty, at 15 minutes against Smile's 18 and Joy's 20. A couple of minutes shouldn't decide the choice.
Smile vs Joy customer support: who helps you faster?
Joy offers more support on its lower plans, mostly because its 24/7 live chat is on every plan and Smile's chat starts with an AI assistant, according to Dream Nu in October 2025. I read every review where customers shared a problem with either app.
Smile offers live chat on every plan and priority support on its $999 Plus plan. In May 2026, Moehair USA waited 2 to 3 days for replies. Of the 152 Smile reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 43 mention support, and Smile replied to 112 of the 152, often with the same wording.
Joy offers 24/7 live chat on every plan, a dedicated account manager from its $129 plan and priority support with an SLA on its $499 plan. In September 2025, Forbidden13 said they bought a plan on chat's advice, then heard they needed one 10 times the price, and Joy's co-founder replied 10 days later. Of the 31 Joy reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 10 mention support, and Joy replied to 19 of the 31, usually within 1 to 2 days.
Love Loyalty offers live chat on every plan, and its $399 Plus plan adds founder-led onboarding. Of the 427 reviews I read, 198 mention support, almost all as praise.
Winner: Joy, because its 24/7 live chat is on every plan and a dedicated account manager starts on $129. Love Loyalty is the closest, with live chat on every plan that answers within minutes and 198 of 427 reviews mentioning support, but its founder-led onboarding needs the $399 plan. Smile's priority support needs its $999 Plus plan.
Smile vs Joy reviews: what do merchants say?
Smile has 4.9 stars from 4,673 reviews on the Shopify App Store, Joy has 4.9 from 1,789 and Love Loyalty has 5.0 from 428. Beyond support, I looked at what recent reviewers praise and what problems repeat.
Recent Smile reviewers praise a quick launch and helpful onboarding. Of the 152 reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 40 mention price, many pointing at the $199/month plan.
Recent Joy reviewers praise its support and setup, and several name the staff member who helped them. Of the 31 reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 4 mention price, and 4 describe the app changing store data at scale after an update or import. In April 2024, EcigZoo said an update awarded 1.2 million points for 19,866 old orders.
In the Love Loyalty reviews I read, I found 1 where a customer shared a problem, and 44 mention its price or value.
Winner: A tie on rating, since Smile and Joy hold 4.9 stars and Love Loyalty 5.0, within 0.1. Smile has the largest base at 4,673 reviews, and Love Loyalty had 1 problem review among the 427 I read, against about 1.7% for Joy and about 3% for Smile.
What breaks when you switch between Smile and Joy?
Points balances move across in either direction, but VIP tiers, referral links and theme blocks are the parts to check. Joy's team migrates points, tiers and reward history from Smile for free, while Smile imports balances by CSV and keeps hands-on migration help for its $999 Plus plan. I didn't run a full migration on my test store, so this list comes from what each app offers.
Before you switch, check these 5 things in order:
- Points balances: ask the app you're leaving for a file of your members and their points. Joy lists loyalty data exports on its $499 Ultimate plan, so on a lower plan, ask its support for the file.
- VIP tiers: set up the same tier names and thresholds in the new app first, and ask its team whether members keep their current tier. Smile's VIP tiers sit on its $199 Growth plan and Joy's on its $129 Advanced plan.
- Referral links: ask the new app's team whether your referral links carry over, and tell your top referrers if theirs changes.
- Theme blocks and widgets: remove the old app's floating button, widget, nudge pop-ups and app blocks, so customers don't see two programmes and two balances.
- Emails and POS: pause the old app's loyalty emails in Klaviyo, Mailchimp or Omnisend, then reconnect your flows and POS to the new app before it goes live.
Joy offers a full refund in the first 30 days of a paid plan.
Love Loyalty offers free migration from its $79 Growth plan, and 7 of the Love Loyalty reviews I read say the merchant moved from Smile. Keep the old app installed until you've checked a few members' balances in the new one.
Winner: Joy and Love Loyalty both offer free migration, Joy's team moving points, tiers and reward history from Smile and Love Loyalty's from its $79 Growth plan, where 7 reviews say the merchant moved from Smile. Joy adds a full refund in the first 30 days. Smile only imports balances by CSV and keeps hands-on help for its $999 Plus plan.
Smile vs Joy: which one should you pick at your store size?
For a Shopify store that sells in English and wants VIP tiers, I'd pick Love Loyalty, because its $79 plan includes VIP tiers, paid memberships and POS, against $129 on Joy and $199 on Smile. Joy makes more sense when your storefront needs 8 languages, and Smile for a small store that wants points and POS from $15 or one that also sells on BigCommerce. I matched the plan each app charges at 4 store sizes, so each pick is on the same order volume.
Which plan fits a store that just launched?
Smile's $15 Essential plan:
- Monthly cost: $15/month
- Orders included: 500
- Above the limit: the programme pauses until you upgrade
- Must-have features: points, without VIP tiers
- Support: live chat
Joy's $29 Essential plan:
- Monthly cost: $29/month
- Orders included: 500
- Above the limit: $15 per 100 orders
- Must-have features: points, without VIP tiers
- Support: 24/7 live chat
Love Loyalty's $12 Professional plan:
- Monthly cost: $12/month
- Orders included: 500
- Above the limit: no overage, so you upgrade to the Growth plan
- Must-have features: points, without VIP tiers
- Support: live chat
My pick: Love Loyalty, because its $12 plan costs $3 less than Smile's $15 and $17 less than Joy's $29, and it includes POS and points expiry. Smile keeps points expiry for its $199 plan and Joy's $29 plan doesn't include POS. You'd upgrade to its $79 plan above 500 orders, with no overage. Joy's 30+ integrations and manual translation make it the pick for a store selling in several languages.
Which plan fits a growing brand?
Smile's $199 Growth plan:
- Monthly cost: $199/month
- Orders included: 2,500
- Above the limit: $20 per 100 orders
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: live chat
Joy's $129 Advanced plan:
- Monthly cost: $129/month
- Orders included: 2,000
- Above the limit: $10 per 100 orders
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: 24/7 live chat and a dedicated account manager
Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan:
- Monthly cost: $79/month
- Orders included: 2,000
- Above the limit: $15 per 100 orders
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: live chat and free migration
My pick: Love Loyalty, because its $79 plan includes VIP tiers, B2B tiers, paid memberships, wallet passes and POS for $50 less than Joy's $129 and $120 less than Smile's $199. You'd give up Joy's automatic translation and 8 languages, and Smile's 500 extra included orders and BigCommerce.
Which plan fits a scaling store?
Smile's $999 Plus plan:
- Monthly cost: $999/month, and Smile charges for 12 months at once
- Orders included: 7,500
- Above the limit: $5 per 100 orders
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: priority support, a launch plan and migration help
Joy's $499 Ultimate plan:
- Monthly cost: $499/month
- Orders included: 7,000
- Above the limit: $5 per 100 orders
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: 24/7 live chat, a dedicated account manager, priority support with an SLA and white-glove onboarding
Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan:
- Monthly cost: $399/month
- Orders included: unlimited
- Above the limit: no limit, so the price doesn't change
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: live chat, founder-led onboarding and performance audits
My pick: Love Loyalty, because its $399 Plus plan costs $100 less than Joy's $499 and $600 less than Smile's $999, includes unlimited orders, checkout extensions and API access, and doesn't charge by order volume. Joy's Ultimate plan bills monthly and adds priority support with an SLA and white-glove onboarding, and Smile's Plus plan includes 7,500 orders.
Which plan fits a Shopify Plus store?
Smile's Enterprise plan, a custom quote:
- Monthly cost: a custom quote, billed for 12 months at once
- Orders included: unlimited
- Above the limit: not applicable
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: an account manager
Joy's Custom plan, a custom quote:
- Monthly cost: a custom quote
- Orders included: set in your quote
- Above the limit: set in your quote
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: set in your quote
Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan:
- Monthly cost: $399/month
- Orders included: unlimited
- Above the limit: no limit, so the price doesn't change
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: live chat, founder-led onboarding and performance audits
My pick: Smile, because its $199 Growth plan redeems points at checkout for Shopify Plus stores and costs $200 less than Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan, though it includes 2,500 orders. Love Loyalty makes more sense when you want unlimited orders, checkout extensions and API access at a fixed price, and Joy for a Plus brand that sells in several languages.
Smile and Love Loyalty offer a 14-day trial on paid plans. Joy offers 14 days on its $29 and $129 plans and 30 on its $499 plan.
Smile vs Joy: key takeaways at a glance
At the table volumes, Love Loyalty costs the same or less than both, Smile costs less than Joy at 500 and 1,000 orders, and Joy costs less than Smile at 2,000 and 5,000. Two jobs the rest of this article doesn't settle:
- For points at checkout: Smile includes it on its $199 Growth plan for Shopify Plus stores only, Joy through checkout extensions on its $499 Ultimate plan for Shopify Plus stores only, and Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan.
- For POS: Smile offers it from $15/month and Love Loyalty from $12/month, while Joy needs its $129 Advanced plan.
The short verdict
For a Shopify store that sells in English, I'd pick Love Loyalty, because it offers VIP tiers, paid memberships and POS together for $79/month, against $129 on Joy and $199 on Smile. Joy makes more sense for several languages or Omnisend, Loox and Chatty, and Smile for BigCommerce or points and POS from $15.
Smile
What I liked:
- $15/month for 500 orders and $79/month for 1,000, against $29 and $104 on Joy
- Shopify POS on every plan, and 9 storefront languages
- Matched my theme's branding without changes, and it also works on BigCommerce
What to know:
- VIP tiers only on its $199 Growth plan, against $129 on Joy
- I didn't find paid memberships, B2B loyalty or wallet passes in its plans
- Its $15 and $79 plans pause the programme at their order limit
Pick Smile if:
- You want points, referrals and POS from $15/month.
- You also sell on BigCommerce, or want Portuguese or Dutch on your storefront.
Joy
What I liked:
- VIP tiers, B2B tiers, paid memberships, wallet passes and POS on its $129 Advanced plan
- 8 storefront languages, with automatic translation on its $129 Advanced plan
- Omnisend, Loox and Chatty integrations from its $29 Essential plan
What to know:
- POS only on its $129 Advanced plan, while Smile offers it from $15
- Checkout redemption only through checkout extensions on its $499 Ultimate plan, for Shopify Plus stores
- 4 of the 31 problem reviews I read describe the app changing store data at scale
Pick Joy if:
- You sell to customers who shop in Spanish, French, Japanese or Joy's other languages.
- You use Omnisend, Loox or Chatty and want your loyalty programme connected.
- You want VIP tiers on a $129 plan rather than Smile's $199 one.
Love Loyalty
What I liked:
- Points, VIP tiers, referrals and POS for up to 2,000 orders for only $79/month
- Paid memberships, B2B loyalty and wallet passes from $79/month
- Unlimited orders on its $399 Plus plan, so the price doesn't grow with orders
What to know:
- Shopify only, while Smile also works on BigCommerce
- English storefront only, while Joy offers 8 languages
Pick Love Loyalty if:
- You want VIP tiers, paid memberships or B2B loyalty in the same app as your points.
- You want shoppers to spend their points inside the cart, with no pop-up.
- You want POS rewards at your till from $12/month.
At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty costs $79, Joy costs $129 and Smile costs $199. All three offer a free trial, so set up the same programme on a copy of your theme and compare them on your phone.
For more on each app, read my Smile review, Joy review and Love Loyalty review.
See Smile on the Shopify App Store, Joy on the Shopify App Store, or Love Loyalty on the Shopify App Store.
What do merchants often ask about Smile vs Joy?
Is Smile cheaper than Joy?
At 500 and 1,000 orders, yes: $15 against Joy's $29, and $79 against $104, with neither including VIP tiers. At 2,000 and 5,000 orders, Joy costs less: $129 against $199, and $499 against $999. For unlimited orders, both need a custom quote. Love Loyalty costs $12, $79, $79, $399 and $399 at the same volumes.
Is Smile or Joy better for a small store?
Smile. At 500 orders a month, it costs $15/month and includes POS, while Joy costs $29/month and needs its $129 plan for POS. Love Loyalty costs $12/month and adds points expiry, which needs Smile's $199 plan, so it's the lowest price of the three at this size.
Do Smile and Joy both offer VIP tiers?
Yes. Joy includes them from its $129 Advanced plan and Smile from its $199 Growth plan. Love Loyalty includes them from its $79 Growth plan, for up to 2,000 orders.
Do Smile and Joy offer paid memberships?
Joy does, from its $129 Advanced plan. I didn't find paid memberships in Smile's plans. Love Loyalty offers them from its $79 Growth plan, and it also offers B2B loyalty and Apple and Google Wallet passes there.
Is Smile or Joy better for Shopify Plus?
Smile, for most Plus stores, because its $199 Growth plan includes points at checkout, while Joy prices every Shopify Plus brand by quote. Joy makes more sense when your customers shop in several languages. Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan offers unlimited orders and checkout extensions.
Which has better support, Smile or Joy?
Joy, from what the plans show. It offers 24/7 live chat on every plan and a dedicated account manager from $129, while Smile's priority support needs its $999 Plus plan. Love Loyalty is the closest, with live chat on every plan. Of the problem reviews I read, 10 of Joy's 31 and 43 of Smile's 152 mention support.
Do Smile and Joy work with Shopify POS?
Yes, but on different plans. Smile includes POS from its $15 plan, Love Loyalty from its $12 plan, and Joy from its $129 plan.
Is Love Loyalty a better fit than Smile or Joy?
For a Shopify store that sells in English, yes. It offers VIP tiers, paid memberships and POS for up to 2,000 orders for $79/month, and unlimited orders for $399/month. It's Shopify only, so Smile makes more sense for BigCommerce, and Joy for a storefront in several languages.
Can you use Smile and Joy at the same time?
You can install both, but customers would see two programmes and two points balances. Keep one live at a time, or test the second app on a copy of your theme.
Will Smile or Joy slow down your store?
I don't give speed scores, because they depend on your theme and your other apps. Sedona Apotheca said in 2022 that Smile slowed their loading, and Mamma Latte said in March 2025 that Joy's widget doesn't always load. Test any app on your own store before and after you install it.
Which other loyalty app comparisons should you read?
These articles compare Smile and Joy with the rest of the category: