Best Love Loyalty alternatives reviewed in 2027
Short answer: Most stores don't need to leave Love Loyalty. It came out on top in my research of 23 loyalty apps, and none of the 6 alternatives below costs less at 2,000 orders a month.
Love Loyalty is a fast-growing app, launched in October 2024, and it already holds 5.0 stars from 428 reviews. It offers VIP tiers, POS, bonus campaigns and paid memberships for up to 2,000 orders at $79/month, and unlimited orders at $399/month.
So I installed 6 Love Loyalty alternatives on a test store. Below, you'll find what each one is built for, what it costs as of November 2026 and what you'd give up by moving.
Why do merchants look for a Love Loyalty alternative?
From the reviews I read, very few merchants do. Of Love Loyalty's 428 reviews, 421 give 5 stars, and I didn't find one where a merchant says they left. The reasons I did find come from 2 reviews and from plan details.
In June 2026, Ten Twelve gave 3 stars because referrals don't tell new customers from existing ones, and because the app changed with too little notice. In October 2026, Northern Bead gave 4 stars and wanted points used automatically once a customer reaches a reward tier. Neither review has a public reply. I didn't test the alternatives for either problem, so ask each developer how it checks for existing customers before it pays a referral reward.
Language is the plan-based reason. Love Loyalty's storefront is English only. Growave offers 16 languages and Loyoly 4, so those are the two to look at for a store that sells in several languages.
The third reason is the platform and the tools around it. Smile and Yotpo both work on BigCommerce, and Yotpo also works on Adobe Commerce, Salesforce Commerce Cloud and WooCommerce. Growave collects reviews and runs a wishlist in the same app, where Love Loyalty connects to Judge.me and other review apps.
These come from 2 of Love Loyalty's 428 reviews and from the plans I checked, so most merchants don't report them.
Which Love Loyalty alternatives made my shortlist?
I selected apps that do the same job as Love Loyalty, with a rating of 4.7 or higher and a live app in November 2026. These 6 alternatives made my shortlist:
- Smile: stores that also sell on BigCommerce
- Growave: loyalty, product reviews and a wishlist in one app
- LoyaltyLion: RFM reports and a connection to Claude and Sidekick
- Yotpo: stores that already use Yotpo for reviews
- Rivo: brands that may add cashback or customer accounts later
- Loyoly: European brands that sell in several languages
I've put each app's rating, starting price and how it charges in this table, with Love Loyalty first as the baseline:
| App | Rating | Starting price | Charges by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Love Loyalty | 5.0 from 428 reviews | Free, then $12/month | Monthly orders, with unlimited orders on its $399 Plus plan |
| Smile | 4.9 from 4,673 reviews | Free, then $15/month | Orders, with $20 per 100 extra on its $199 Growth plan |
| Growave | 4.8 from 1,287 reviews | Free, then $15/month | Orders, with $10 to $20 per 100 extra |
| LoyaltyLion | 4.7 from 550 reviews | Free, then $199/month | Average monthly orders |
| Yotpo | 4.7 from 966 reviews | Free, then $199/month | Orders, with $0.20 per extra order on its $199 Pro plan |
| Rivo | 4.7 from 1,441 reviews | Free, then $15/month | Orders, with $20 per 100 extra on its $49 Scale plan |
| Loyoly | 5.0 from 118 reviews | Free, then $99/month | Orders, with $0.30 per extra order on its $99 Lite plan |
Prices as of November 2026.
If your reason for leaving is price, none of the 6 beats Love Loyalty at 2,000 orders, so start with the one that matches the feature you're missing.
How did I review these Love Loyalty alternatives?
I installed each app on a test store, then went through every plan and what customers shared in their newest reviews. I used Love Loyalty as the baseline for each comparison.
I looked at these details for each app:
- VIP tiers: which plan includes them and what that plan costs at 2,000 orders
- Paid memberships: whether a standard plan offers them
- Shopify POS: whether customers can earn and redeem in store, and from which plan
- Order limits: what happens past a plan's limit, such as a pause or an overage fee
- Languages: how many storefront languages each app offers
- AI features: what AI does in each app
- Setup: how long each app took me to get a points programme live
- Design: how it looked on my test store and whether it matched my theme's fonts
- Pricing: how each app charges and what each plan includes
- Reviews: what customers shared in their newest reviews, including about support
- Moving: what you can bring across from Love Loyalty
Love Loyalty costs only $79/month at 2,000 orders, which is less than every alternative here. Among the 6 alternatives, Smile comes first because it costs the least at that volume, $199/month, and has the most reviews, with 4,673. The order of the other 5 isn't a ranking.
I don't give speed scores, because they depend on your theme and your other apps. Your own store is the better test, and all 6 apps have a free plan or trial.
What did I find when I compared them with Love Loyalty?
These alternatives fall into 2 groups. Smile, LoyaltyLion, Rivo and Loyoly focus on the core loyalty experience: points, VIP tiers, referrals and rewards. Growave and Yotpo spread across other features, such as product reviews, wishlists or SMS.
I liked the first group more. You aren't paying for reviews, wishlist or SMS tools that many stores already use in other apps. Growave and Yotpo make sense only when you'd drop a separate reviews app. On my test store, LoyaltyLion and Rivo looked native like Love Loyalty, while Smile, Loyoly, Yotpo and Growave used a widget or sticky bar.
I found 5 main differences from Love Loyalty. The apps differ on which ones they include, so check which you need before you compare prices:
- How the bill grows: Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan includes up to 2,000 orders, and its $399 Plus plan includes unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume. Smile adds $20 per 100 above 2,500 orders on its $199 Growth plan. Growave adds $10 to $20 per 100, Rivo $20 per 100 on its $49 Scale plan, Yotpo $0.20 per order on its $199 Pro plan and Loyoly $0.30 per order on its $99 Lite plan. LoyaltyLion charges by average monthly orders.
- Price at 2,000 orders: Love Loyalty charges $79 on its Growth plan. Smile charges $199 on its Growth plan, Growave $274 on its Growth plan, LoyaltyLion $349 on its Classic plan, Rivo $499 on its Plus plan and Loyoly $999 on its Enterprise plan. Yotpo is a custom quote on its Premium plan.
- Where VIP tiers start: Love Loyalty includes them on its $79 Growth plan. Rivo starts them on its $49 Scale plan and Loyoly on its $99 Lite plan, but both charge extra for every order above the plan's limit. Smile and Growave start them on their $199 Growth plans. LoyaltyLion sells them as an add-on on its Classic plan, and Yotpo keeps them on its Premium plan.
- Paid memberships: Love Loyalty offers them on its $79 Growth plan with a 1.8% fee. None of the 6 offers them on a standard plan, and Rivo includes them only on its custom plan.
- Free plans: LoyaltyLion's includes 400 orders, Smile's, Rivo's and Growave's 200, Love Loyalty's 150 and Yotpo's fewer than 100. Loyoly's doesn't state a limit.
I also found these differences in how the apps work:
- AI features: Love Loyalty suggests a loyalty programme for your store with AI on its $79 Growth plan. LoyaltyLion offers a Claude and Sidekick connection on every plan, and Growave adds AI review summaries on its $199 Growth plan. I found none in Smile, Yotpo, Rivo or Loyoly.
- Languages: Love Loyalty's storefront is English only. Growave offers 16 languages and Loyoly 4.
- Setup: each app took me 15 to 20 minutes, against Love Loyalty's 15. Smile and Loyoly took 18, Yotpo and Rivo 19, and LoyaltyLion and Growave 20.
- Design: Love Loyalty, Smile and Loyoly matched my theme's fonts without extra work. Yotpo, LoyaltyLion, Rivo and Growave needed CSS or a higher plan before their fonts matched.
- Speed: the total number of apps on your store matters more than one app.
What are the best Love Loyalty alternatives?
I'd call none of these a replacement for Love Loyalty, but each one adds something it doesn't offer. Smile is the closest on price and features, because its $199 Growth plan includes VIP tiers, POS and benchmark reports at 2,000 orders.
Growave comes next for stores that want loyalty, product reviews and a wishlist in one app. The other 4 suit stores that sell on BigCommerce (Smile), teams that rely on RFM reports (LoyaltyLion), Yotpo Reviews users (Yotpo), brands that may add cashback or accounts (Rivo) and European brands that sell in several languages (Loyoly). But they all cost more. At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs $79, while Smile costs $199, Growave $274, LoyaltyLion $349, Rivo $499 and Loyoly $999.
1. Smile: Best for stores that also sell on BigCommerce

Smile is one of the longest-running loyalty apps on Shopify, and it also works on BigCommerce. Choose it when you run a second store on BigCommerce and want one loyalty app on both.
Why I like this app: The branding stood out most. Full branding comes on every plan, and on my test store the widget matched my fonts without CSS. POS also works on every plan, including the free one. Setup took me 18 minutes, because VIP tiers, referrals and points expiry each needed their own pass.
Compared with Love Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, Smile costs $199/month on its Growth plan and offers VIP tiers, points expiry, POS, benchmark reports and a Loyalty Hub in customer accounts. Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs $79 at that volume and offers benchmark reports too, so moving to Smile raises your bill by $120 a month. On my test store, Smile showed a floating loyalty button where Love Loyalty placed points on the product page and in the theme. You'd give up paid memberships, which Smile doesn't offer, and VIP tiers below $199.
Features:
- Points, referrals, 15+ ways to earn and POS on the free plan, up to 200 orders a month
- A loyalty page and free-product rewards on the $15 Essential plan
- Bonus events and points on product pages on the $79 Standard plan
- VIP tiers, points expiry, benchmark reports and unlimited integrations on the $199 Growth plan
- Redemption at checkout on the $199 Growth plan, for Shopify Plus stores only
- Integrations with Klaviyo, Judge.me, Loox, Mailchimp and Recharge
I didn't find any AI features in it.
Pricing: Smile charges by monthly orders:
- Free: 200 orders a month
- Essential: $15/month, 500 orders
- Standard: $79/month, 1,000 orders
- Growth: $199/month, 2,500 orders, then $20 per 100
- Smile Plus: $999/month, billed yearly, 7,500 orders, then $5 per 100
- Trial: 14 days
Reviews: Smile has 4.9 stars from 4,673 reviews on the Shopify App Store. But of the 152 reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 40 mention price. In May 2026, Einstein's Attic Madison said it felt forced to pay $199 a month, and the developer followed up in July 2026.
Best for: Stores that also sell on BigCommerce and want one loyalty app on both platforms.
I wouldn't choose it if: You want product reviews in the same app as your loyalty programme. Smile works with Judge.me and Loox but doesn't collect reviews. Growave includes photo reviews and a wishlist.
My Smile review covers its setup, support and verdict.
See Smile on the Shopify App Store.
2. Growave: Best for loyalty, reviews and a wishlist in one app

Growave is a retention suite with loyalty, referrals, product reviews and a wishlist. Choose it when you pay for a loyalty app and a separate reviews app and would rather have one bill.
Why I like this app: I liked how much the $15 Entry plan includes. It offers points, referrals, photo reviews, a wishlist and Shopify POS. Its $199 Growth plan adds VIP tiers, a dedicated loyalty page and wallet passes. Setup took me 20 minutes, because each module needed its own settings.
Compared with Love Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, Growave costs $274/month on its Growth plan and offers VIP tiers, photo and video reviews, a wishlist, store credit and wallet passes. Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs $79 at that volume and also includes wallet passes, so moving to Growave raises your bill by $195 a month, but it can replace a separate reviews app. On my test store, Growave's loyalty and wishlist widgets needed adjusting to sit well with my theme. You'd give up paid memberships, which Growave doesn't offer.
Features:
- Points, a wishlist and product reviews on the free plan, up to 200 orders a month
- Points, referrals, photo reviews and POS on the $15 Entry plan
- VIP tiers, store credit and points expiry on the $199 Growth plan
- Wallet passes and a dedicated loyalty page on the $199 Growth plan
- AI review summaries on the $199 Growth plan
- 16 languages, plus Klaviyo, Attentive, Gorgias, Recharge and TikTok Shop
Pricing: Growave charges by monthly orders:
- Free: 200 orders a month
- Entry: $15/month, 500 orders, then $20 per 100
- Growth: $199/month, 1,500 orders, then $15 per 100
- Plus: $499/month, 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100
- Unlimited: $999/month, unlimited orders
- Trial: 14 days
Reviews: Growave has 4.8 stars from 1,287 reviews on the Shopify App Store, and it replied to 48 of the 50 reviews I read where customers shared a problem. In June 2024, The Anime Supply said custom code broke its buy now button.
Best for: Stores that want loyalty, product reviews and a wishlist on one subscription, with storefronts in several languages.
I wouldn't choose it if: You only need loyalty with VIP tiers. Growave's $199 Growth plan reaches $274 at 2,000 orders, while Smile's $199 Growth plan includes VIP tiers for up to 2,500 orders.
See my full Growave review for its pros, cons and pricing.
See Growave on the Shopify App Store.
3. LoyaltyLion: Best for RFM reports and a Claude and Sidekick connection

LoyaltyLion is a London loyalty platform that sells mostly through sales calls. I'd choose it when your team works from RFM segments and wants to reach loyalty data from Claude or Sidekick.
Why I like this app: The RFM reports impressed me most. They sort customers into segments such as lapsed and at risk, on every paid plan. On my test store, the loyalty page also sat inside the storefront instead of floating over it, and points and VIP status showed inside the customer account.
Compared with Love Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, LoyaltyLion costs $349/month on its Classic plan and offers points, referrals, CLV and RFM reports, a loyalty page, one POS location and a Claude and Sidekick connection. Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs $79 at that volume and includes VIP tiers, so moving to LoyaltyLion raises your bill by $270 a month before its VIP add-on. On my test store, both apps looked native, but LoyaltyLion's components needed CSS to match my fonts, while Love Loyalty's matched without it. You'd give up paid memberships, which LoyaltyLion doesn't offer.
Features:
- RFM, CLV and referral reports on every paid plan
- A Claude and Sidekick connection through MCP on every plan
- A loyalty page and one POS location on the Classic plan ($199 to $549/month)
- VIP tiers on the Advanced plan, a custom quote
- AI campaigns on the Plus plan, a custom quote
- Integrations with Klaviyo, Gorgias, Attentive, Tapcart and ReCharge
Pricing: LoyaltyLion charges by average monthly orders:
- Free: 400 orders a month
- Classic: $199/month at 500 orders, rising to $549 at 4,000
- Advanced and Plus: custom quote
- Trial: 14 days, through the App Store
Reviews: LoyaltyLion has 4.7 stars from 550 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise strategic support. In September 2025, Fendrihan said custom plans rise 20% to 30% a year.
Best for: Mid-sized brands whose retention team works from RFM segments and an AI assistant connection.
I wouldn't choose it if: You want VIP tiers in the plan price. LoyaltyLion sells them as an add-on on its Classic plan, while Smile includes them on its $199 Growth plan.
For its plans and merchant feedback in full, read my LoyaltyLion review.
See LoyaltyLion on the Shopify App Store.
4. Yotpo: Best for stores already on Yotpo Reviews

Yotpo Loyalty, formerly Swell Rewards, is the loyalty and referral part of Yotpo's reviews and SMS suite. Choose it when you already use Yotpo Reviews, or when you run stores on platforms besides Shopify.
Why I like this app: I liked the 20+ ready-made campaigns, such as goal spend, punch cards and points for photo reviews. Setup took me 19 minutes. Yotpo also works on BigCommerce, Adobe Commerce, Salesforce Commerce Cloud and WooCommerce, and its Reviews and Loyalty bundle starts at $199/month.
Compared with Love Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, Yotpo is a custom quote on its Premium plan, which is where its VIP tiers and POS sit. Its $199 Pro plan starts at 500 orders and includes neither, while Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs $79 and offers both. On my test store, Yotpo showed a rewards sticky bar, and matching my fonts needed the Advanced CSS editor on its Premium plan. You'd give up VIP tiers and POS at a published price, and paid memberships, which Yotpo doesn't offer.
Features:
- Points for purchases, referrals and a rewards sticky bar on the free plan
- Referral fraud prevention and ROI dashboards on the free plan
- Points expiry and any-amount discounts on the Pro plan, from $199/month
- Shopify POS and VIP tiers on the Premium plan, a custom quote
- A cross-brand programme on the Enterprise plan, a custom quote
- Klaviyo, Recharge and Yotpo Reviews integrations
I didn't find any AI features in it.
Pricing: Yotpo charges by monthly orders:
- Free: fewer than 100 orders a month
- Pro: from $199/month, 500 orders, then $0.20 per order
- Premium: custom quote, from 2,500 orders
- Trial: none listed
Reviews: Yotpo has 4.7 stars from 966 reviews on the Shopify App Store. In October 2026, A. Taylor Intimates said it took 8 attempts to reach support.
Best for: Brands already paying for Yotpo Reviews, or running several platforms, that want loyalty in the same suite.
I wouldn't choose it if: You need VIP tiers or POS at 2,000 orders. Yotpo keeps both on its Premium plan, a custom quote, while Smile includes both on its $199 Growth plan.
The Yotpo review goes through every plan and what merchants say.
See Yotpo on the Shopify App Store.
5. Rivo: Best for adding cashback or customer accounts later

Rivo is a loyalty, referral and VIP app for direct-to-consumer brands, and its developer also sells Cashback and Accounts as separate apps. Choose it when you expect to add store credit or customer accounts later and want them from the same developer.
Why I like this app: Its $15 Essential plan stood out. On my test store, theme extensions put points on the product page, and POS comes with the plan. VIP tiers and bonus campaigns start on the $49 Scale plan. The Accounts app, from $499, adds wishlists, wallet passes and passwordless login.
Compared with Love Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, Rivo costs $499/month on its Plus plan and offers VIP tiers, bonus campaigns, POS, advanced analytics and checkout extensions. Its $49 Scale plan includes only 400 orders, so at 2,000 orders the bill moves up to Plus. Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs $79 at that volume, so moving to Rivo raises your bill by $420 a month. On my test store, both apps looked native, but my fonts only lined up in Rivo after I used its custom CSS and fonts setting. You'd give up paid memberships, which Rivo includes only on its custom plan.
Features:
- Points and referrals on the free plan, up to 200 orders a month
- Product-page points and Shopify POS on the $15 Essential plan
- VIP tiers, bonus campaigns, points expiry and custom CSS on the $49 Scale plan
- A developer toolkit and checkout extensions on the $499 Plus plan
- Cashback from $199/month and Accounts from $499/month, sold separately
- Klaviyo, Attentive, Postscript and Fuego
I didn't find any AI features in it.
Pricing: Rivo charges by monthly orders:
- Free: 200 orders a month
- Essential: $15/month, 500 orders
- Scale: $49/month, 400 orders, then $20 per 100, up to 2,500 orders
- Plus: $499/month, up to 2,500 orders, then a custom quote
- Trial: 14 days
Reviews: Rivo has 4.7 stars from 1,441 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise hands-on support. In October 2026, Madison + Mallory couldn't exclude TikTok Shop orders and went back to Smile.
Best for: Stores under 1,000 orders that want VIP tiers on the $49 Scale plan, with cashback or customer accounts as a later step.
I wouldn't choose it if: Your volume is heading past 1,200 orders. From there, Rivo's $49 Scale plan costs more than Smile's $199 Growth plan, and at 2,000 orders it moves to the $499 Plus plan.
Want more detail first? Read the Rivo review.
See Rivo on the Shopify App Store.
6. Loyoly: Best for European brands that sell in several languages

Loyoly is a French loyalty, referral and content app with a storefront in French, English, Spanish and German. Choose it when you sell mostly in Europe and want a team that onboards you by hand.
Why I like this app: I liked the 40+ missions, which reward sign-ups, Instagram posts and Google reviews. VIP tiers, points expiry and translation come on every paid plan, including the $99 Lite plan. On my test store, its no-code branding matched my fonts. Setup took me 18 minutes.
Compared with Love Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, Loyoly costs $999/month on its Enterprise plan with unlimited orders, because its $99 Lite plan includes 500 orders and charges $0.30 for each extra one. Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs $79 at that volume, so moving to Loyoly raises your bill by $920 a month. On my test store, Loyoly used a widget where Love Loyalty looked native, and its product page, account and checkout extensions only come on the $449 Premium plan. You'd give up paid memberships, which Loyoly doesn't offer, and a lower bill at higher volume.
Features:
- Points for purchases, sign-ups, content and reviews on the $99 Lite plan
- VIP tiers, points expiry and a loyalty page on the $99 Lite plan
- Apple and Google Wallet passes on every plan
- Store credit, cashback and account, product page and checkout extensions on the $449 Premium plan
- A developer toolkit on the $999 Enterprise plan
- Integrations with Klaviyo, Gorgias, Judge.me, Recharge and TikTok
I didn't find any AI features in it.
Pricing: Loyoly charges by monthly orders:
- Free: order limit not stated
- Lite: $99/month, 500 orders, then $0.30 per order
- Premium: $449/month, 500 orders, then $0.30 per order
- Enterprise: $999/month, unlimited orders
- Trial: 7 days
Reviews: Loyoly has 5.0 stars from 118 reviews on the Shopify App Store, with none below 4 stars. In 2026, For.me praised its onboarding with a named team member.
Best for: French and European D2C brands under 1,000 orders that sell in French, English, Spanish or German.
I wouldn't choose it if: Your volume is above 1,500 orders. At 1,500, Lite already costs $399, and at 2,000 the bill moves to the $999 Enterprise plan. Smile's $199 Growth plan includes VIP tiers for up to 2,500 orders.
My Loyoly review covers its setup, support and verdict.
See Loyoly on the Shopify App Store.
Why does Love Loyalty still come out on top in my research?
Love Loyalty came out on top in my research because it offers the most features for the lowest price, and it's the fastest app to set up. It offers VIP tiers, POS, bonus campaigns, paid memberships, B2B loyalty and wallet passes for up to 2,000 orders at $79/month. For Shopify Plus brands, it offers unlimited orders at $399/month, so your price stays the same as your orders grow.
Setup took me 15 minutes, against 16 to 20 for the other 22 apps I installed. Most of that time went on choosing from 20+ placements, and live chat answered within minutes. On my test store, Love Loyalty was the most native result in the whole test. Points showed on the product page, the loyalty page sat inside my theme, and every placement picked up my theme's fonts and colours with no CSS.
It also keeps your data in Shopify. Love Loyalty stores customers' loyalty data in Shopify metafields, so it stays in your Shopify admin and loads quickly. Merchants who left reviews say the same about support. It's the part reviews mention most, in 198 of 427 reviews.
I wouldn't choose Love Loyalty in 3 cases. Choose Growave when you want reviews and a wishlist in the same app or a storefront in more than English. Choose Smile when you also sell on BigCommerce. Choose LoyaltyLion when your team works from RFM reports.
How do you choose between Love Loyalty and these alternatives?
Name the feature you're missing, then confirm that the new app adds it at a price you can pay. These 5 questions will shorten the list.
For most stores, nothing is missing, so compare what each finalist charges at next month's volume. Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs $79 at 2,000 orders, which is below every alternative here.
List the Love Loyalty features you use. Stores that use paid memberships, wallet passes or B2B loyalty will find none of these 6 apps offers all three on a standard plan.
Preview each loyalty page on a copy of your theme, and check where customers redeem and whether the fonts match without CSS.
Check that your email, review and subscription apps appear in its integrations. Then read what customers recently shared about support, and check whether the developer replied.
Choose Love Loyalty when you want one native loyalty app with VIP tiers, POS and paid memberships at the lowest price I found. Choose Growave if you want reviews and a wishlist in the same app, and Smile if you also sell on BigCommerce. Stay on Love Loyalty when none of those applies.
Will a Love Loyalty alternative cost you less?
No. At 2,000 orders a month, none of the 6 alternatives costs less than Love Loyalty. When I compared their pricing plans, I counted extra orders up to 1,000 above what each plan includes, and I used the next plan up beyond that.
Love Loyalty charges $79 on its Growth plan for up to 2,000 orders, then $399 on its Plus plan with unlimited orders. The alternatives all charge by orders on at least one plan, and each price below is for the plan each app charges at 2,000 orders.
Say you run 2,000 orders a month. Love Loyalty costs $79/month on its Growth plan. These alternatives cost:
- Smile: $199/month on its Growth plan
- Growave: $274/month on its Growth plan, with product reviews
- LoyaltyLion: $349/month on its Classic plan, before its VIP add-on
- Rivo: $499/month on its Plus plan
- Loyoly: $999/month on its Enterprise plan
- Yotpo: a custom quote on its Premium plan
At 500 orders, the gap is smaller. Love Loyalty's Professional plan costs $12, while Smile's Essential, Growave's Entry and Rivo's Essential plans cost $15. At 1,000 orders, Smile's Standard plan costs $79 like Love Loyalty's Growth plan, but Smile keeps VIP tiers for its $199 Growth plan.
At 5,000 orders, Love Loyalty's Plus plan costs $399 with unlimited orders. Smile Plus costs $999 a month, paid yearly, Growave's Unlimited plan $999 and Loyoly's Enterprise plan $999, while LoyaltyLion, Yotpo and Rivo are custom quotes.
Over 2 years at 2,000 orders, Love Loyalty costs about $1,896 on monthly billing. Smile costs about $4,776 over the same 2 years, and Growave about $6,576.
Ask each developer what counts as an order before you compare prices.
Can you keep paid memberships when you leave Love Loyalty?
No. None of these 6 alternatives offers paid memberships on a standard plan.
Love Loyalty includes them on its $79 Growth plan with a 1.8% transaction fee, and on its $399 Plus plan at 0.8%. Rivo includes paid memberships only on its custom plan, and Smile, Growave, LoyaltyLion, Yotpo and Loyoly don't offer them. Loyoly adds Apple and Google Wallet passes on every plan, but those show a balance, not a paid tier.
Before you leave, write down your membership prices, benefits and billing periods, then ask the new developer in writing what replaces them.
When does it make sense to leave Love Loyalty?
I'd leave Love Loyalty if you need reviews and a wishlist in the same app, a storefront in more than English or a loyalty app on BigCommerce.
Each of those has an answer on this list. Growave offers reviews, a wishlist and 16 languages. Smile and Yotpo work on BigCommerce. LoyaltyLion offers RFM reports and a Claude and Sidekick connection, so it makes sense when your team lives in those reports.
If none of those applies, I'd stay. Love Loyalty holds 5.0 stars from 428 reviews and has the Built for Shopify badge. Its free plan covers 150 orders, and its $12 Professional plan adds POS, a loyalty page and 20+ placements. See Love Loyalty on the Shopify App Store.
Before you leave, test the missing feature on the new app's free plan, because the bill rises at every volume I checked.
How do you move from Love Loyalty to another app?
Several of these apps migrate your data. Loyoly offers free migration on every plan, Yotpo's team migrates member data and point balances, and Smile imports points balances by CSV. Growave offers a CSV import or assisted migration, and LoyaltyLion helps import existing customer data once your account is set up. Your customers, orders and discount codes stay in Shopify.
Love Loyalty stores customers' loyalty data in Shopify metafields, so it sits in your Shopify admin instead of on another platform. Ask its live chat for an export of balances and tiers before you leave.
I'd save these from Love Loyalty before you change anything:
- Every earning rule and reward, with point values and expiry settings
- Each member's points balance and VIP tier
- Paid membership plans, prices and benefits
- Your loyalty page and wallet passes, as screenshots
Use these steps with any of the apps:
- Export your members and write down every rule and reward.
- Install the new app on its free plan or trial, and set it up on a copy of your theme.
- Import your members, then check a few customer balances by hand.
- Set up the same rewards you have on Love Loyalty, so you're comparing like with like, then check them on your phone.
- Upgrade only if it does the job, then publish the theme.
- Remove Love Loyalty, its app embed and any placements you added to your theme, before your next billing date.
Setup took me 15 to 20 minutes per app on my test store. In the reviews I read for Rivo, imported historical orders counted towards the usage bill, so ask each developer about that first.
Export everything first, and keep your notes for a year.
What changes in unusual situations?
Most differences show up at high volume and in several markets.
Above 2,000 orders, Love Loyalty's Growth plan stops, and its Plus plan costs $399 with unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume. Smile's Growth plan adds $20 per 100 above 2,500 orders, and Loyoly's Lite plan adds $0.30 per order above 500. Rivo, LoyaltyLion and Yotpo move to custom quotes at higher volumes.
For several markets, Love Loyalty's storefront is English only. Growave offers 16 languages and Loyoly 4, so check each language you sell in before you pay.
For physical stores, Love Loyalty adds Apple and Google Wallet passes on its $79 Growth plan, Growave on its $199 Growth plan and Loyoly on every plan. LoyaltyLion's Classic plan ($199 to $549/month) includes one POS location.
Which Love Loyalty alternative would I start with?
I'd start with Love Loyalty, because none of the 6 alternatives costs less at 2,000 orders. If you need something it doesn't offer, I'd choose Growave for reviews, a wishlist and more languages, and Smile for BigCommerce. LoyaltyLion makes sense when your team works from RFM reports.
Install 2 finalists on a copy of your theme and compare them on your phone.
My guide to the best Shopify loyalty apps compares the wider category.
What do merchants often ask about Love Loyalty alternatives?
Which Love Loyalty alternative is best for reviews and a wishlist?
Growave is the closest match. It offers points, photo reviews and a wishlist from its $15 Entry plan, and VIP tiers on its $199 Growth plan. Yotpo suits stores that already use Yotpo Reviews.
Is there a free alternative to Love Loyalty?
Yes. LoyaltyLion's free plan is the largest, with 400 orders a month. Smile's, Rivo's and Growave's include 200, while Love Loyalty's includes 150 and Yotpo's fewer than 100.
How much does Love Loyalty cost in 2026?
Love Loyalty starts free for 150 orders a month. Its Professional plan costs $12 for 500 orders, its Growth plan $79 for 2,000 orders and its Plus plan $399 with unlimited orders. Paid plans come with a 14-day trial.
Is Love Loyalty a good app?
Yes, with 5.0 stars from 428 reviews and the fastest setup of the 23 apps I installed. An alternative makes more sense when you need reviews in the same app, a storefront in more than English or BigCommerce support.
Can you move your points from Love Loyalty to another app?
Yes. Smile, Yotpo, Growave, LoyaltyLion and Loyoly all import points balances. Ask Love Loyalty's live chat for an export first.
Do Love Loyalty alternatives slow down a store?
The total number of apps matters more than one app. Test any app on your own store before and after you install it.

