Skip to content

Best BLOY Loyalty alternatives reviewed in 2027

Short answer: When pricing is the problem, choose Love Loyalty, because it offers a points programme, VIP tiers, POS, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes for up to 2,000 orders at $79/month, and unlimited orders for $399/month. Stay on BLOY when you're under 1,500 orders a month, so its order limits don't affect you.

BLOY does a lot on its lower plans. AI onboarding drafts rewards, tiers and branding from your store data, and merchants praise its free migration and its $10/month plan with POS. But its top self-serve plan, called Unlimited, includes only 3,000 orders a month, and redeeming points at checkout needs both that $129/month plan and Shopify Plus.

So I installed 7 BLOY alternatives on a test store. Below, you'll find what each one is built for, what it costs as of November 2026 and what you'd give up by moving.

Why do merchants look for a BLOY alternative?

From what customers shared in the reviews I read, most merchants leave BLOY over the order limit on its plan called Unlimited and the Shopify Plus gate on checkout redemption. A few also question how BLOY asks for reviews.

When I priced its plans, BLOY's Unlimited plan cost $129/month for 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100. Above 4,500 orders, every store moves to a custom quote, and BLOY counts every Shopify order. BON, Love Loyalty and Joy publish a price at that volume.

Checkout redemption is the second complaint. In March 2026, Bilge Brew found that customers couldn't apply points at checkout without Shopify Plus and said they felt "misled". BLOY replied later that month. Love Loyalty includes redemption in the cart instead, on every plan.

Some customers also shared that review requests came with help. In August 2026, Still I Run said support asked for a review each time they needed help, so I'd read BLOY's near-perfect rating with some care.

These come from 5 of BLOY's 845 reviews, so most merchants don't report them.

Which BLOY alternatives made my shortlist?

I picked apps that do the same job as BLOY, with ratings from 4.4 to 5.0. These 7 alternatives made my shortlist:

  • Love Loyalty: an all-in-one native loyalty app with fixed pricing
  • Joy: paid memberships and wallet passes on one plan
  • BON: unlimited orders at a flat $129/month
  • CWILL: a loyalty app that pairs with CWILL's reviews and helpdesk tools
  • Otter: every feature on both plans, online only
  • S Loyalty: a long-running points app without VIP or built-in referrals
  • Gameball: spin the wheel, streaks and leaderboards

I've put each app's rating, starting price and how it charges in this table, with BLOY first as the baseline:

App Rating Starting price Charges by
BLOY 5.0 from 845 reviews Free, then $10/month All Shopify orders, with overage
Love Loyalty 5.0 from 428 reviews Free, then $12/month Monthly orders
Joy 4.9 from 1,789 reviews Free, then $29/month Orders, with overage
BON 5.0 from 1,987 reviews Free, then $15/month Features, with order caps below $129/month
CWILL 4.9 from 800 reviews Free, then $19/month Orders, with overage
Otter 4.6 from 22 reviews Free, then $15/month Orders, with overage on both plans
S Loyalty 4.4 from 235 reviews Free, then $19.99/month Order bands, averaged over 12 months
Gameball 4.7 from 149 reviews Free, then $34/month Monthly rewarded customers

Prices as of November 2026.

When the order cap is your reason for leaving, compare BON, Love Loyalty and Joy first.

How did I review these BLOY alternatives?

I installed each app on a test store, then went through every plan and what customers shared in their newest reviews. I used BLOY as the baseline for each comparison.

I looked at these details for each app:

  • Points and redemption: where customers redeem
  • VIP tiers and Shopify POS: which plan includes them
  • AI features: what AI does in each app
  • Integrations: Klaviyo, Judge.me, Shopify Flow and similar tools
  • Setup: how long each app took me to get a points programme live
  • Design: how it looked on my test store and whether it matched my theme
  • Speed: what one more app adds to a store that already has 10 to 15 of them
  • Pricing: how each app charges, what it costs at 2,000 orders a month and its plan limits
  • Reviews: what customers shared in their newest reviews, including about support
  • Moving: what you can bring across from BLOY

Love Loyalty comes first because it offers VIP tiers, bonus campaigns and paid memberships for up to 2,000 orders on its $79/month Growth plan, and it gave the best result on my test store. Its Plus plan includes unlimited orders for $399. The order of the other 6 isn't a ranking.

I don't give speed scores, because they depend on your theme and your other apps. Your own store is the better test, and all 7 apps have a free plan or trial.

What did I find when I compared them with BLOY?

These alternatives fall into 2 groups. Love Loyalty, Joy, BON, Otter and S Loyalty focus on the core loyalty experience: points, VIP tiers, referrals and rewards. CWILL and Gameball spread across other features, such as rewards tied to CWILL's own reviews app, receipt scanning and games.

I liked the first group most. You aren't paying for review or game tools that many stores already run in other apps. I've also found that when an app splits its work across all of those, the loyalty programme is the part that gets compromised. On my test store, CWILL needed custom CSS and Gameball didn't match my fonts, while Love Loyalty looked native.

I found 4 main differences from BLOY. The apps differ on which ones they include, so check which you need before you compare prices:

  • How the bill grows: BLOY charges $10 to $15 per 100 extra orders and quotes above 4,500 orders. Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan includes up to 2,000 orders, and its $399 Plus plan includes unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume. BON's $129 Growth plan also includes unlimited orders.
  • Price at 2,000 orders a month: BLOY costs $109/month on its Growth plan. Love Loyalty costs $79 on Growth, Otter $100 on Scaler, BON $129 on Growth, Joy $129 on Advanced and CWILL $169 on Pro. S Loyalty moves you to a custom quote from $199.99, and Gameball charges by rewarded customers instead.
  • Shopify POS: BLOY includes it from its $10 Launch plan. Gameball has it free, and Love Loyalty's $12/month Professional plan includes it. Joy keeps it for its $129 Advanced plan, while Otter and S Loyalty don't offer it.
  • Free plans: BLOY's includes 200 orders with no referrals. Joy's includes 250 orders with referrals, and Love Loyalty's 150.

I also found these differences in how the apps work:

  • AI features: BLOY advertises AI onboarding, BON an AI setup assistant, Love Loyalty an AI programme suggestion on its $79 Growth plan, Joy an AI copilot from its $29 Essential plan and Gameball two AI advisers on its $999 Guru plan. The others have none.
  • Setup: the apps took me 15 to 20 minutes each, against 17 for BLOY. Love Loyalty was the fastest at 15, and Joy took 20.
  • Design: Love Loyalty looked native on my test store, like BLOY, while the other 6 used widgets. Love Loyalty, Joy and Otter matched my fonts. BON, CWILL and S Loyalty needed changes, while Gameball didn't match.
  • Speed: the total number of apps matters more than one more widget.

What are the best BLOY alternatives?

Love Loyalty is my top pick when BLOY's order limits start pushing up your bill. For Shopify stores, I'd choose its $79 Growth plan, which includes referrals that reward both sides, wallet passes and B2B loyalty for up to 2,000 orders a month. For Shopify Plus brands, I'd choose its $399 Plus plan, which offers everything in Growth with unlimited orders.

Joy comes next for brands that want paid memberships and wallet passes. The other 5 suit a flat bill at any volume (BON), CWILL app users (CWILL), online-only stores (Otter), plain points programmes (S Loyalty) and gamified programmes (Gameball). But all of the order-based ones cost more. At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs $79, while Otter costs $100, BON and Joy $129, CWILL $169 and S Loyalty a custom quote from $199.99. Gameball charges by rewarded customers instead of orders.

1. Love Loyalty: Best for an all-in-one native loyalty app with fixed pricing

Love Loyalty, a BLOY alternative for Shopify

Love Loyalty is an all-in-one native loyalty app for Shopify and Shopify Plus brands. It offers points, VIP tiers, referrals and paid memberships in one app, at a published monthly price. I'd choose it when you want customers to spend points in the cart, plus the paid memberships and wallet passes BLOY doesn't offer.

Why I like this app: I liked cart redemption best. In my test, customers spent their points in the cart in 2 steps, with no pop-up widget to open. Love Loyalty includes it on the free plan, while BLOY keeps it for its $49 Growth plan.

On my test store, it also looked as native as BLOY. Points showed on the product page, and the loyalty page sat inside my theme with my fonts and colours. I didn't write any CSS, so the programme fits your store from launch.

Setup took me 15 minutes, the fastest of the 7.

Compared with BLOY: At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty costs $79/month on its Growth plan and offers a points programme, VIP tiers, POS, bonus campaigns, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes. BLOY's Growth plan costs $109 at that volume, because it adds $12 per 100 orders above 1,500, and it doesn't offer paid memberships or wallet passes. So moving to Love Loyalty lowers your bill by $30 a month.

Above 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty costs $399/month on its Plus plan and offers everything in Growth, API access and unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume. BLOY's $129 Unlimited plan includes only 3,000 orders, and stores above 4,500 orders move to a custom quote.

But below 1,500 orders a month, BLOY's $49 Growth plan costs less than Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan. Check your monthly order count before you move.

Features:

  • Points that customers redeem in one click from the cart, plus referrals, on the free plan
  • VIP tiers that upgrade customers automatically on spend or points, on the $79 Growth plan
  • B2B loyalty with separate earning and redemption rules per customer segment, on the $79 Growth plan
  • POS, a loyalty page, 20+ placements and points expiry on the $12 Professional plan
  • Klaviyo, Judge.me, Shopify Flow and 30+ other integrations on the $12 Professional plan
  • Paid memberships, rewards for activities, wallet passes, bonus campaigns and AI programme suggestions on the $79 Growth plan
  • Unlimited orders, checkout extensions and API access on the $399 Plus plan

Pricing: Love Loyalty charges by monthly orders:

  • Free: 150 orders a month
  • Professional: $12/month, 500 orders
  • Growth: $79/month, up to 2,000 orders
  • Plus: $399/month, unlimited orders
  • Trial: 14 days

Reviews: Love Loyalty has 5.0 stars from 428 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise fast live chat and help with moving from Smile.

Best for: Shopify stores that want points, VIP tiers, paid memberships and cart redemption in one native app on the $79 Growth plan, and Shopify Plus brands that want unlimited orders on the $399 Plus plan.

I wouldn't choose it if: You want games in your programme. Love Loyalty doesn't include games or gamified campaigns, while Gameball offers spin-the-wheel, streaks and leaderboards.

My Love Loyalty review covers its setup, support and verdict.

See Love Loyalty on the Shopify App Store

2. Joy: Best for Instagram-led brands that want memberships

Joy, a BLOY alternative for Shopify

Joy is a loyalty platform from Avada with paid memberships, wallet passes and an AI copilot. I'd choose it when you want paid memberships and B2B tiers in the same app as your points.

Why I like this app: The Instagram rewards impressed me most. On its $129 Advanced plan, Joy rewards comments and story mentions automatically, and the same plan adds paid memberships, wallet passes and a Loyalty Hub inside Shopify's customer account. On my test store, the loyalty widget fit my theme and matched my fonts.

Compared with BLOY: At 2,000 orders a month, Joy costs $129/month on its Advanced plan and offers VIP and B2B tiers, POS, paid memberships and wallet passes. BLOY's Growth plan costs $109 at that volume, so moving to Joy raises your bill by $20 a month. Joy also publishes prices up to 17,000 orders, where BLOY quotes above 4,500. On my test store, Joy's widget matched my fonts, but setup took me 20 minutes. You'd give up BLOY's native look and its free migration.

Features:

  • Redemption in the cart drawer on the $129 Advanced plan
  • Checkout extensions for Shopify Plus stores on the $499 Ultimate plan
  • Points and referrals with fraud prevention on the free plan
  • An AI copilot and custom CSS on the $29 Essential plan
  • VIP tiers, bonus campaigns and POS on the $129 Advanced plan
  • Klaviyo, Recharge, Loox and Shopify Flow

Pricing: Joy charges by monthly orders:

  • Starter: free, 250 orders a month
  • Essential: $29/month, 500 orders, then $15 per 100
  • Advanced: $129/month, 2,000 orders, then $10 per 100
  • Ultimate: $499/month, 7,000 orders, then $5 per 100
  • Trial: 14 days on the $29 Essential and $129 Advanced plans, 30 days on the $499 Ultimate plan

Reviews: Joy has 4.9 stars from 1,789 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise the free plan. In April 2024, Jolie Femme found 6,000 duplicate customer accounts after an update.

Best for: Brands that want paid memberships, wallet passes and B2B tiers alongside VIP tiers.

I wouldn't choose it if: You want in-store loyalty without the $129 plan. Joy's POS extension starts on its $129 Advanced plan. CWILL includes Shopify POS on its $19/month Essential plan.

See my full Joy review for its pros, cons and pricing.

See Joy on the Shopify App Store

3. BON: Best for a flat bill at high volume

BON, a BLOY alternative for Shopify

BON Loyalty is a Canadian app with flat plans and no overage. I'd choose it when your order count keeps climbing.

Why I like this app: Its $129 Growth plan caught my eye first. It includes unlimited orders, VIP tiers, B2B tiers and points on product pages. Setup took me 17 minutes, the same as BLOY. Points also showed on the customer account pages on every plan, including Free.

Compared with BLOY: At 2,000 orders a month, BON costs $129/month on its Growth plan and offers VIP and B2B tiers, points on product pages and unlimited orders. BLOY's Growth plan costs $109 at that volume, so BON adds $20 a month. At 3,000 orders both cost $129, and above that BON stays put while BLOY adds overage and then a quote. On my test store, BON used a floating loyalty button and referral pop-up, where BLOY looked native. You'd give up that native look, and one reviewer found BON's widget blocked the mobile checkout button.

Features:

  • No order limit on the $129 Growth plan
  • Redeeming points at checkout for Shopify Plus stores on the free plan
  • VIP and B2B tiers on the $129 Growth plan
  • Shopify POS earning and redemption from the $29 Basic plan
  • An AI setup assistant that suggests a points strategy on every plan
  • Klaviyo, Judge.me and Shopify Flow

Pricing: BON charges by features, with order caps on the lower plans:

  • Free: 150 orders a month
  • Starter: $15/month, 300 orders
  • Basic: $29/month, 500 orders
  • Growth: $129/month, unlimited orders ($103/month on annual billing)
  • Plus: custom quote
  • Trial: 7 days, and one trial per store

Reviews: BON has 5.0 stars from 1,987 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise the free plan. In February 2024, William Glen said Amazon orders count toward the order limit, and BON replied.

Best for: Stores above 3,000 orders a month that want VIP and B2B tiers at a fixed price.

I wouldn't choose it if: You sell in person and want POS on an entry plan. BON starts POS on Basic ($29/month), while Gameball includes it on every plan, including Free.

For its plans and merchant feedback in full, read my BON review.

See BON on the Shopify App Store

4. CWILL: Best for stores already using CWILL apps

CWILL, a BLOY alternative for Shopify

CWILL Loyalty & Referrals, once called Loloyal, comes from a vendor that also sells product reviews and a helpdesk called Willdesk. Choose it when you already use CWILL tools.

Why I like this app: The language list stood out. CWILL names 20 languages, the same count as BLOY, and its $19/month Essential plan includes multi-language support and POS. Setup took me 17 minutes.

Compared with BLOY: At 2,000 orders a month, CWILL costs $169/month on its Pro plan and offers VIP tiers, review-based rewards, receipt scanning, POS and multi-language support. BLOY's Growth plan costs $109 at that volume, so moving to CWILL raises your bill by $60 a month. On my test store, it used a loyalty widget, where BLOY looked native, and I used the custom CSS that comes with every plan to line it up with my store. You'd give up BLOY's free migration.

Features:

  • Points labels on product pages on the free plan
  • A loyalty page and pop-ups on the $19 Essential plan
  • A customer account extension and VIP tiers on the Pro plan, from $69/month
  • Shopify POS and multi-language support on the $19 Essential plan
  • Klaviyo and Omnisend on the Pro plan, from $69/month

I didn't find any AI features in its loyalty plans.

Pricing: CWILL charges by monthly orders on a slider:

  • Free: 200 orders a month
  • Essential: $19/month for 200 orders or $29/month for 500, then $20 per 100 orders
  • Pro: $69/month for 500 orders, $169/month for 2,000 and $229/month for 3,000
  • Enterprise: custom quote, required above 3,000 orders
  • Trial: 14 days

Reviews: CWILL has 4.9 stars from 800 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise setup help and translations. In November 2025, Dope Skin Co said it took 2 days to get answers, and CWILL replied to that review.

Best for: Stores that already use CWILL Product Reviews or Willdesk.

I wouldn't choose it if: You sell more than 3,000 orders a month. CWILL moves you to a custom quote there, so BON, with unlimited orders at $129/month, is the safer price.

The CWILL review goes through every plan and what merchants say.

See CWILL on the Shopify App Store

5. Otter: Best for online-only stores that want every feature on one plan

Otter, a BLOY alternative for Shopify

Otter Loyalty offers every feature on both of its plans. I'd choose it when you sell online only and don't want to compare plan tables.

Why I like this app: Otter doesn't split features by plan. VIP tiers, memberships and points on product pages all come with the free Starter plan. Setup took me 16 minutes. On my test store, its widget and rewards page fit my store and matched my fonts.

Compared with BLOY: At 2,000 orders a month, Otter costs $100/month on its Scaler plan and offers points, referrals, VIP tiers, memberships and points on product pages. BLOY's Growth plan costs $109 at that volume, so Otter lowers your bill by $9 a month, and it includes VIP tiers even on its free plan. On my test store, it used a widget with nudges, where BLOY looked native. You'd give up Shopify POS, Shopify Flow and live support, because Otter answers by email within 1 business day.

Features:

  • Percentage and fixed discounts, free shipping and free products as rewards
  • Minimum cart requirements and product eligibility rules
  • Points on product pages and reminder nudges
  • VIP tiers, referrals and memberships on every plan
  • Integrations with Judge.me and Klaviyo

I didn't find any AI features in it.

Pricing: Otter charges by monthly orders, with overage on both plans:

  • Starter: free, 100 orders a month, then $10 per 100 orders
  • Scaler: $15/month, 300 orders, then $5 per 100 orders
  • Trial: none, but Starter is free

Reviews: Otter has 4.6 stars from 22 reviews on the Shopify App Store, and the newest dates from May 2025. In October 2024, Fashion Hub Club said the app sent 20 emails in 10 minutes, and the new owners replied.

Best for: Small online-only stores that want VIP tiers for free.

I wouldn't choose it if: You sell in person. Otter has no POS feature, so Love Loyalty's $12/month Professional plan, which includes POS, fits better.

See Otter on the Shopify App Store

6. S Loyalty: Best for a plain points programme

S Loyalty, a BLOY alternative for Shopify

S Loyalty is a points app with bonus campaigns and no VIP tiers. Choose it when you want points for purchases and nothing more.

Why I like this app: Its rewards include the basics. Customers can pay with points, get free shipping or take a fixed or percentage discount. Setup took me 16 minutes, and points and rewards were simple to set up.

Compared with BLOY: At 2,000 orders a month, S Loyalty moves you to its Higher Volume plan, a custom quote from $199.99/month, and offers points, bonus campaigns and pay-with-points rewards. BLOY's Growth plan costs $109 at that volume, so moving to S Loyalty raises your bill by at least $91 a month. It prices by a 12-month order average, so one busy month doesn't push you up a plan. On my test store, it showed a rewards tab, where BLOY looked native, and the embedded widget only arrives on its $39.99 Standard plan. You'd give up BLOY's VIP tiers, POS and built-in referrals, because S Loyalty sends referrals to ReferralCandy.

Features:

  • Pay with points, free shipping and percentage rewards from the $19.99 Basic plan
  • 2x and 3x bonus point campaigns on the $19.99 Basic plan
  • Points for past orders on the $69.99 Pro plan
  • Purchase and redemption history with data export
  • Referrals through the ReferralCandy integration

I didn't find any AI features in it.

Pricing: S Loyalty charges by order bands, using your average over the last 12 months:

  • Free: 100 orders a month, 3 fixed-amount rewards
  • Basic: $19.99/month, 50 orders
  • Standard: $39.99/month, 200 orders
  • Pro: $69.99/month, 350 orders
  • Premium: $119.99/month, up to 1,000 orders
  • Higher Volume: custom quote from $199.99/month
  • Trial: 14 days

Reviews: S Loyalty has 4.4 stars from 235 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Long-term users who left reviews praise its stability. In May 2026, GREAT DOG CO., a user for 11 years, said nobody answered 3 support requests in a week.

Best for: Stores that want points for purchases and no tiers.

I wouldn't choose it if: You want referrals inside the same app. S Loyalty sends them to ReferralCandy, while Joy includes referrals with fraud prevention on its free plan.

See S Loyalty on the Shopify App Store

7. Gameball: Best for gamified loyalty

Gameball, a BLOY alternative for Shopify

Gameball builds loyalty around games such as streaks, spin the wheel and leaderboards. I'd choose it when you want customers to come back for the game.

Why I like this app: The campaign tools stood out. Streak, spin-the-wheel and points-multiplier campaigns all start on the $34/month Starter plan, alongside 5 VIP tiers. Shopify POS comes on every plan, including Free. Setup took me 18 minutes, because the games and VIP tiers each needed configuring.

Compared with BLOY: Gameball charges by customers who earn rewards each month, not by orders. Its $34 Starter plan offers streaks, spin the wheel and 5 VIP tiers for up to 300 rewarded customers, and its $159 Pro plan includes 1,000. BLOY's Growth plan costs $109 at 2,000 orders, so Gameball costs less while few customers earn rewards each month. On my test store, its points widget and game pop-ups didn't match my fonts, because the widget font only changes on its $159 Pro plan. You'd give up BLOY's native look and its free migration.

Features:

  • Plans priced by monthly rewarded customers rather than orders
  • Points wallet, referrals and seasonal campaigns on the free plan
  • Streaks, spin the wheel and 5 VIP tiers on the $34 Starter plan
  • Two AI loyalty experts for setup and campaigns on the $999 Guru plan
  • Klaviyo, Judge.me, Recharge and Zapier

Pricing: Gameball charges by monthly rewarded customers:

  • Free: 100 rewarded customers a month
  • Starter: $34/month, 300 rewarded customers
  • Pro: $159/month, 1,000 rewarded customers, with API access for $199/month extra
  • Guru: $999/month, 10,000 rewarded customers
  • Trial: 7 days on the $34 Starter and $159 Pro plans

Reviews: Gameball has 4.7 stars from 149 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise flexible missions. In October 2025, Petfast.shop said support kept sending the same copy-paste steps for a domain error.

Best for: Brands that want to reward repeat visits with games, streaks and leaderboards.

I wouldn't choose it if: You want a fixed price as you grow. Gameball jumps from $159/month to $999/month, so BON at a flat $129/month is easier to plan for.

Want more detail first? Read the Gameball review.

See Gameball on the Shopify App Store

How do you choose between BLOY and these alternatives?

Name the reason you're leaving, then confirm that the new app fixes it at a price you can pay. These 5 questions will shorten the list.

Start with the problem that made you look. A cap at 3,000 orders points to BON. A Shopify Plus gate on redemption points to Love Loyalty, which includes cart redemption on every plan.

Then list the BLOY features you use. Paid memberships and wallet passes point to Love Loyalty or Joy, and review-based rewards to CWILL.

Next, check each app against your theme. On my test store, only Love Loyalty looked native and matched my fonts without CSS. Joy and Otter matched my fonts through widgets.

Look at the rest of your store too. A till rules out Otter and S Loyalty.

Finally, read the last 3 months of reviews for support. In the recent reviews I read, merchants praise support at Joy, BON and Love Loyalty, while S Loyalty and Gameball draw complaints.

Choose Love Loyalty when BLOY's extra order charges are what's sending you elsewhere. At 2,000 orders a month, it costs only $79/month on its Growth plan and offers 1-click points redemption in the cart, VIP tiers that upgrade automatically on spend or points, POS and paid memberships. BLOY's $49 Growth plan comes to $109 at that volume. Its $399 Plus plan suits stores that want unlimited orders, so the price doesn't rise as order volume grows.

Choose BON for more than 3,000 orders a month at a flat $129. Stay on BLOY when you're under 1,500 orders a month, so its order limits don't affect you.

Will a BLOY alternative cost you less?

Some do. When I priced each app at 2,000 orders a month, BLOY's Growth plan cost $109, and Love Loyalty and Otter cost less, while BON, Joy, CWILL and S Loyalty cost more.

BLOY charges by every Shopify order, like most of these apps. Of the two that cost less, Otter has no POS, while Love Loyalty's Growth plan includes it.

Say your store takes 2,000 orders a month. BLOY costs $109/month on its Growth plan. These alternatives cost:

  • Love Loyalty: $79/month on Growth
  • Otter: $100/month on Scaler
  • BON: $129/month on Growth
  • Joy: $129/month on Advanced
  • CWILL: $169/month on Pro
  • S Loyalty: a custom quote from $199.99/month on Higher Volume

Gameball charges by rewarded customers instead. Its $34 Starter plan includes 300 a month and its $159 Pro plan 1,000, so its price depends on how many customers earn rewards.

Over 2 years at that level, BLOY costs about $2,616 on monthly billing. Love Loyalty costs about $1,896 over the same 2 years.

At 5,000 orders the answer shifts further. BLOY moves to a custom quote, while BON stays at $129/month and Love Loyalty's Plus plan costs $399/month with unlimited orders.

Before you compare, ask each developer which orders count toward the limit.

Can you keep redeeming points in the cart when you leave BLOY?

Yes. When I checked the plans, Love Loyalty's free plan included cart redemption, and Joy's $129 Advanced plan included it in the cart drawer. BLOY needs its $49/month Growth plan for it.

On my test store, Love Loyalty customers redeemed in the cart with no pop-up.

Before you leave, screenshot your cart widget settings and note any minimum cart rules.

When does it make sense to stay on BLOY?

I'd stay on BLOY if you're under 1,500 orders a month, because its order limits won't affect you and its $49 Growth plan includes VIP tiers and 20+ storefront languages.

BLOY has 5.0 stars from 845 reviews and includes POS, Shopify Flow and all integrations from $10/month. On my test store, setup took 17 minutes while AI onboarding drafted rewards, tiers and branding, and the result looked native and matched my fonts. But the free plan's watermark can't be removed.

At the low end, BLOY's Free plan includes 200 orders and every paid plan has a 14-day trial. See BLOY on the Shopify App Store.

Before you leave, check your real monthly order count against 3,000 and 4,500.

My full BLOY Loyalty review covers its plans, support and what merchants say before you decide.

How do you move from BLOY to another app?

No app on this list advertises a direct BLOY import, but Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan includes free migration, and CWILL's team helps with complex moves. Your customers, orders and discount codes stay in Shopify whichever app you use.

I'd save these from BLOY before you change anything:

  • Every earning rule, reward and VIP tier
  • Your widget and loyalty page styling, as screenshots
  • Point balances and tier status, as a CSV export
  • Klaviyo flows that use BLOY events

Use these steps with any of the apps:

  1. Export your points balances and write down your setup.
  2. Install the new app on its free plan or trial, and set it up on a copy of your theme.
  3. Import balances, then check a few customer accounts by hand.
  4. Set up the same rewards and tiers you have on BLOY, so you're comparing like with like, then check them on your phone.
  5. Upgrade only if it does the job, then publish the theme.
  6. Remove BLOY, its app embed and any theme blocks, before your next billing date.

In November 2025, Melt Me Candle Co. said Joy had no way to bring existing customers across, so ask the new team to confirm the import before you switch BLOY off.

After you uninstall, check customer metafields for leftover BLOY data, and keep your export for at least a year.

What changes in unusual situations?

Seasonal volume and several markets change the answer most.

Seasonal peaks matter with BLOY, because it quotes above 4,500 orders. When I checked plan limits, BON's $129 Growth plan and Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan included unlimited orders, while CWILL pauses the programme 3 days after you pass a limit.

Several markets favour CWILL, with 20 supported languages, or BON, with 250+ displayed languages from $29/month.

Which BLOY alternative would I start with?

I'd start with Love Loyalty, because it offers VIP tiers, bonus campaigns and paid memberships for up to 2,000 orders on its $79/month Growth plan, and unlimited orders on its $399 Plus plan. Choose BON when you're above 3,000 orders. Stay on BLOY if you're under 1,500 orders and its order limits don't affect you.

Install 2 finalists, set up the same rewards on a copy of your theme and compare them.

My guide to the best Shopify loyalty apps compares the wider category.

What do merchants often ask about BLOY alternatives?

Which BLOY alternative is best for a points and VIP programme?

Love Loyalty is the closest match, with VIP tiers and cart redemption on its $79/month Growth plan for up to 2,000 orders, and unlimited orders on its $399 Plus plan. Otter suits a smaller store, with VIP tiers on its free plan.

Is there a free alternative to BLOY?

Yes. Love Loyalty's free plan includes 150 orders a month with cart redemption. Joy's includes 250 orders with referrals, and Otter's includes 100 orders with VIP tiers.

How much does BLOY cost in 2026?

BLOY is free for 200 orders a month. Launch costs $10/month, Growth $49/month and Unlimited $129/month for 3,000 orders, each with overage.

Is BLOY a good app?

Yes. It has 5.0 stars from 845 reviews and POS from $10/month. But an alternative makes more sense above 3,000 orders.

Can you move your points from BLOY to another app?

Yes. Export balances as a CSV, then import them. Love Loyalty offers free migration on its $79 Growth plan.

Do BLOY alternatives slow down a store?

The total number of apps matters more than one widget. So test any app on your own store before and after you install it.

A
Written by

Alan