Smile Loyalty vs OneLoyalty: Which loyalty app is better?
I installed Smile and OneLoyalty on the same test store. Below, you'll find what each one costs as of November 2026, how they differ and which one I'd pick at each store size.
I have also compared a 3rd app along with Smile and OneLoyalty, Love Loyalty, which came out as the best loyalty app for Shopify in my research of 23 loyalty apps.
TL;DR:
- Pick Smile when you want a low entry plan, a widget that matches your theme or a storefront in 9 languages: $15/month for up to 500 orders and $79/month for up to 1,000. It also works on BigCommerce. However, its VIP tiers start on the $199 Growth plan.
- Pick OneLoyalty when you want built-in email sends and games such as spin-the-wheel in your loyalty app: $49/month includes up to 1,000 orders. However, its VIP tiers and paid memberships start on the $199 Premium plan, and its widget fonts didn't match my theme.
- Pick Love Loyalty when you want a native all-in-one loyalty app with points, VIP tiers, referrals, paid memberships, POS and B2B loyalty, offered for up to 2,000 orders for only $79/month and for unlimited orders for only $399/month.
The quick verdict:
- Do you want a low entry plan and a widget that matches your theme without CSS? Choose Smile.
- Do you want emails and games inside your loyalty app, or paid memberships next to VIP tiers on one plan? Choose OneLoyalty.
- Do you want VIP tiers, paid memberships and POS in one plan for $79/month? Choose Love Loyalty.
How I compared Smile and OneLoyalty
I ran every app through the same checks, so each section below compares like with like:
- Test store: one Shopify test store and one theme, with no custom CSS in Smile or OneLoyalty
- Programme: the same points, VIP tiers and referral setup in Smile and OneLoyalty
- Prices: each app's plans at 500, 1,000, 2,000 and 5,000 orders a month and unlimited orders, on monthly billing, as of November 2026
- Reviews: every review where customers shared a problem with Smile (152) and OneLoyalty (11), the 20 newest 5-star reviews of each, OneLoyalty's 2 four-star reviews, and the 427 Love Loyalty reviews
- What decided most sections: the plan each app needs for VIP tiers and paid memberships, and what each one adds around points, such as emails, games and languages
Smile vs OneLoyalty pricing: what will you pay as your orders grow?
Smile costs less than OneLoyalty at 500 orders, OneLoyalty costs less at 1,000 and they cost the same at 2,000, where Love Loyalty costs less than both. At 1,000 orders a month, OneLoyalty's $49 Growth plan comes to about $1,176 over 2 years, while Smile's $79 Standard plan comes to about $1,896, and neither includes VIP tiers.
When I compared their pricing plans at 5 order volumes, this is what each app costs a month:
| Orders a month | Smile | OneLoyalty | Love Loyalty |
|---|---|---|---|
| 500 | $15 on its Essential plan, without VIP tiers | $49 on its Growth plan, without VIP tiers | $12 on its Professional plan, without VIP tiers |
| 1,000 | $79 on its Standard plan, without VIP tiers | $49 on its Growth plan, without VIP tiers | $79 on its Growth plan |
| 2,000 | $199 on its Growth plan | $199 on its Premium plan | $79 on its Growth plan |
| 5,000 | $999 on its Plus plan, billed for 12 months at once | A custom quote on its Enterprise plan | $399 on its Plus plan |
| Unlimited orders | A custom quote on its Enterprise plan | A custom quote on its Enterprise plan | $399 on its Plus plan |
Prices as of November 2026. Developers change them, so check each app before you choose.
Smile's $15 and $79 plans pause your programme at their order limit until you upgrade. Its $199 Growth plan includes 2,500 orders, then adds $20 for every 100, and its $999 Plus plan includes 7,500 orders, then adds $5 for every 100.
OneLoyalty counts orders and its built-in emails together. Its $49 Growth plan includes 1,000 orders and 2,000 emails, then adds $0.15 per extra order, up to a $299 monthly cap. Its $199 Premium plan includes VIP tiers, 3,000 orders and 10,000 emails, then adds $0.10 per extra order, up to a $999 cap. Extra emails are billed on top, and the Enterprise plan is a custom quote.
At 2,000 orders, Smile and OneLoyalty both cost $199/month, but the plans differ. OneLoyalty's Premium plan includes VIP tiers, paid memberships, API access and 10,000 email sends. Smile's Growth plan includes VIP tiers, points expiry, the Loyalty Hub in customer accounts and unlimited integrations, and I didn't find paid memberships in any Smile plan.
At 1,000 orders, Smile and Love Loyalty both cost $79/month, but only Love Loyalty's Growth plan includes VIP tiers, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes, for up to 2,000 orders, then $15 for every 100. Smile's $79 plan and OneLoyalty's $49 plan include none of them.
Say you stay at 2,000 orders. Over 2 years, Smile and OneLoyalty each cost about $4,776, while Love Loyalty costs about $1,896. Its $399 Plus plan offers unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume.
Winner: Love Loyalty, because it costs $12 at 500 orders, $79 at 2,000 and $399 at 5,000, against $199 for both others at 2,000 and $999 on Smile at 5,000. OneLoyalty's $49 plan costs less at 1,000 orders, but it has no VIP tiers, which Love Loyalty's $79 plan includes.
Quick comparison of Smile and OneLoyalty
Smile's main strength is a low entry plan with a matching widget, OneLoyalty's is emails and games, and Love Loyalty's is what its lower plans include.
This is how Smile, OneLoyalty and Love Loyalty compare at a glance:
| Smile | OneLoyalty | Love Loyalty | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Stores wanting a low entry plan and a matching widget | Stores wanting emails and games in the loyalty app | Shopify stores wanting VIP tiers and memberships on one plan |
| Price at 2,000 orders | $199 on its Growth plan | $199 on its Premium plan | $79 on its Growth plan |
| VIP tiers from | $199 Growth plan | $199 Premium plan | $79 Growth plan |
| Main on-site element | Floating loyalty button, every plan | Widget, with pop-up games from $49 Growth plan | Points in the cart, from $12 Professional plan |
| Shopify POS | From $15 Essential plan | From $49 Growth plan | From $12 Professional plan |
| Paid memberships | I didn't find them | From $199 Premium plan | From $79 Growth plan |
| Wallet passes | I didn't find them | Virtual loyalty card, from $99 Professional plan | From $79 Growth plan |
| Built-in email sends | Through Klaviyo | 2,000 a month from $49 Growth plan | Not offered, works with Klaviyo |
| Storefront languages | 9 | 8 | English only |
| Other platforms | BigCommerce | None named | Shopify only |
| Migration | CSV import, help on $999 Plus plan | Member import and export | Free, from $79 Growth plan |
| Setup time in my test | 18 minutes | 18 minutes | 15 minutes |
| Shopify App Store rating | 4.9 from 4,673 reviews | 4.5 from 112 reviews | 5.0 from 428 reviews |
| Free trial | 14 days on paid plans | 14 days on paid plans | 14 days on paid plans |
Smile's strengths:
- Lowest entry price: $15/month for 500 orders, against $49 on OneLoyalty and $12 on Love Loyalty.
- Matched my theme's fonts and colours without changes, while OneLoyalty's widget fonts didn't match.
- Works on BigCommerce too, with 9 storefront languages on every plan.
OneLoyalty's strengths:
- Built-in email sends: 2,000 a month on its $49 Growth plan and 10,000 on its $199 Premium plan, so you can email members without a separate email app.
- Games such as spin-the-wheel on its $49 Growth plan, so you can give members a reason to come back.
- Paid memberships and API access on its $199 Premium plan, while Smile's API starts at $999.
Love Loyalty's strengths:
- Paid memberships, B2B loyalty and wallet passes from $79/month, so you can sell a members' club and reward wholesale buyers in the same app. OneLoyalty's paid memberships start at $199/month, and I didn't find B2B loyalty in either app's plans.
- Loyalty data stored in Shopify metafields, so it stays in Shopify and loads quickly. Smile syncs VIP tiers to metafields only from its $199 Growth plan.
Smile vs OneLoyalty features: which one offers more?
OneLoyalty offers more than Smile once you reach $199/month, and Love Loyalty includes VIP tiers and paid memberships on a lower plan than both. I set up the same points and VIP programme in Smile and OneLoyalty, then checked which plan each feature needs in all three apps.
This is the plan and price where each feature starts:
- POS: Smile on its $15 Essential plan, OneLoyalty on its $49 Growth plan, Love Loyalty on its $12 Professional plan
- Points expiry: Smile on its $199 Growth plan, OneLoyalty on its $99 Professional plan, Love Loyalty on its $12 Professional plan
- VIP tiers: Smile on its $199 Growth plan, OneLoyalty on its $199 Premium plan, Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan
- Paid memberships: I didn't find them in Smile's plans, OneLoyalty on its $199 Premium plan, Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan
- Wallet passes: I didn't find them in Smile's plans, OneLoyalty offers a virtual loyalty card on its $99 Professional plan, Love Loyalty offers Apple and Google Wallet passes on its $79 Growth plan
- Games and built-in email sends: OneLoyalty on its $49 Growth plan, Love Loyalty not offered
- API access: Smile on its $999 Plus plan, OneLoyalty on its $199 Premium plan, Love Loyalty on its $399 Plus plan
- Checkout extensions, Shopify Plus only: Love Loyalty on its $399 Plus plan
Of the three, only OneLoyalty names games such as spin-the-wheel and its own email sends in its plans. Love Loyalty is the only one where I found B2B loyalty, with separate earning rules for each customer segment. One reviewer on Smile, WHITE COAT, warned in October 2025 against using it for B2B transactions.
On AI, Love Loyalty's Growth plan suggests a programme for your store, so you don't start from an empty page. OneLoyalty's AI analytics start on its $49 Growth plan, but they need order history, which my test store didn't have. I didn't find AI features in Smile's plans.
Winner: OneLoyalty and Love Loyalty, for different features. Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan includes VIP tiers, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes, which OneLoyalty offers from its $199 Premium plan, while OneLoyalty adds games and built-in email sends from $49/month, which Love Loyalty doesn't offer. I didn't find paid memberships in Smile's plans.
Smile vs OneLoyalty platforms and languages: where can you use each one?
Smile works on more platforms and in one more language. Love Loyalty is the narrowest of the three, because it's for Shopify and Shopify Plus stores and its storefront is English only.
Smile works on Shopify and BigCommerce, so a brand that sells on both can keep one loyalty app. The OneLoyalty pages I read name no other platform.
Smile offers 9 storefront languages on every plan, including French, German, Japanese, Italian, Dutch and Spanish. OneLoyalty offers 8, including Chinese, Turkish and Brazilian Portuguese. Love Loyalty shows English only. Be careful with Smile: 5 of the reviews I read, from 2019 to 2024, said they couldn't translate customer-facing text such as emails.
Neither gap matters for a store that sells in English only. For Turkish, only OneLoyalty offers it, and for Italian or Dutch, only Smile.
Winner: Smile for platforms, because it also works on BigCommerce. Smile for languages too, by 1: it offers 9 against OneLoyalty's 8. Love Loyalty is Shopify only and English only, so it comes last on both.
Smile vs OneLoyalty integrations: which one works with your other apps?
Smile connects to more of the tools merchants use, and OneLoyalty's difference is that it sends loyalty emails itself. I checked the integrations in each app's settings.
These are the tools each app connects to:
- Email: Smile works with Klaviyo and Mailchimp, OneLoyalty sends its own emails, Love Loyalty works with Klaviyo
- Reviews: Smile works with Judge.me and Loox, OneLoyalty with Judge.me and Yotpo, Love Loyalty with Judge.me and other review apps
- Subscriptions: Smile and Love Loyalty work with Recharge
- Helpdesk: Smile works with Gorgias
- Ads: OneLoyalty works with Meta and Google Ads on its $99 Professional plan
- Shopify Flow and customer accounts: all three
- Shopify POS: Smile and Love Loyalty from $15 and $12, OneLoyalty from $49
Smile limits how many it connects by plan: 1 integration on its $15 Essential plan, 2 on its $79 Standard plan and unlimited on its $199 Growth plan. OneLoyalty sends 2,000 emails a month from its $49 Growth plan and 10,000 on its $199 Premium plan. Love Loyalty offers Klaviyo, Shopify Flow and 30+ other integrations from its $12 Professional plan.
Winner: Smile, because it connects to Klaviyo, Mailchimp, Judge.me, Loox, Recharge and Gorgias from its $199 plan. Love Loyalty connects to Klaviyo, Recharge, Shopify Flow and 30+ other integrations from $12/month, and OneLoyalty makes more sense when you have no email app yet.
Smile vs OneLoyalty design: how does each one look on your store?
Smile matched my theme without changes, and OneLoyalty needed more work than I'd want. I installed both apps on the same theme and looked at the product page, cart, loyalty page and customer account.
Smile showed a floating loyalty button by default, on every plan. Its loyalty page starts on the $15 Essential plan, points on product pages on the $79 Standard plan and the Loyalty Hub in customer accounts on the $199 Growth plan.

OneLoyalty showed a loyalty page and a widget, with pop-up games such as spin-the-wheel on top. The widget's text and look were hard to bring in line with my store, and its fonts didn't match my theme. Its customer account page isn't a focus of the app.

Love Loyalty takes a different approach from both widgets: customers can redeem earned loyalty points directly in the cart, with no pop-up or floating button. Its points on the product page and its loyalty page picked up my fonts and colours without CSS.

In the reviews I read, Bins and Boxes said in November 2025 that Smile's floating button didn't stay where they placed it. Cantabria Labs said in October 2024 that changing OneLoyalty's widget text needed a $399 plan at the time, and NBM said in June 2025 that the app added a page to their store, without approval. Of the 427 Love Loyalty reviews I read, 36 mention the cart.
Winner: Smile and Love Loyalty both matched my theme's fonts and colours without changes, while OneLoyalty's widget didn't. Smile adds a floating loyalty button on every plan, and Love Loyalty adds points on the product page and a loyalty page that picked up my styling without CSS.
Smile vs OneLoyalty setup: how long does each one take?
Love Loyalty took me 15 minutes, while Smile and OneLoyalty each took 18. I timed each app from install to a working points and VIP programme.
In Smile, VIP tiers, referrals, points expiry and POS each needed their own settings. In OneLoyalty, the games, campaigns and built-in emails took most of the time after the basic points went live. In Love Loyalty, most of it went on choosing from its 20+ placements and setting up VIP tiers, paid memberships and wallet passes.
Winner: Love Loyalty, because it took 15 minutes, against 18 for both Smile and OneLoyalty. The gap is small, and each app's time went on different settings.
Smile vs OneLoyalty customer support: who helps you faster?
OneLoyalty answers more reliably in public, because it replied to 10 of the 11 reviews where customers shared a problem. I read every such review for either app.
Smile offers live chat on every plan and priority support on its $999 Plus plan. In May 2026, Moehair USA waited 2 to 3 days for replies. Of the 152 Smile reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 43 mention support, and Smile replied to 112, often with the same wording.
OneLoyalty offers priority support from its $49 Growth plan, through the OneMobile team at its developer, FireGroup, and its custom-quote Enterprise plan adds a dedicated success manager. Of the 11 OneLoyalty reviews I read where customers shared a problem, it replied to 10, each time with a named person. In November 2025, EXprimi Beauty Kenya said OneLoyalty switched off its account without notice, and the team replied 2 days later.
Love Loyalty offers live chat on every plan, and its $399 Plus plan adds founder-led onboarding. Of the 427 reviews I read, 198 mention support, almost all as praise.
Winner: OneLoyalty, because it replied to 10 of its 11 problem reviews, each time with a named person, and offers priority support from its $49 Growth plan. Love Loyalty offers live chat on every plan and 198 of the 427 reviews I read mention support, almost all as praise, and Smile's chat starts on its $15 Essential plan, though 43 of its 152 problem reviews mention support.
Smile vs OneLoyalty reviews: what do merchants say?
Smile has 4.9 stars from 4,673 reviews on the Shopify App Store, OneLoyalty has 4.5 from 112 and Love Loyalty has 5.0 from 428. Beyond the reviews I read for support, I looked at what recent reviewers praise and what problems repeat.
Recent Smile reviewers praise a quick launch and helpful onboarding. Of the 152 reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 40 mention price, and many point at the $199/month plan. In May 2026, Einstein's Attic said they felt pushed onto it.
Recent OneLoyalty reviewers praise an easy setup and fast help. Of the 11 reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 7 are about pricing changes, mostly from October to December 2024, when the free app moved to paid plans. In December 2025, Flowers Gold Coast called the old monthly active users charge "predatory". OneLoyalty now bills by orders and emails.
In the Love Loyalty reviews I read, I found 1 where a customer shared a problem: in June 2026, Ten Twelve said referrals didn't tell new customers from existing ones. Another 44 mention its price or value.
Winner: Love Loyalty and Smile, because their ratings are 0.1 apart, 5.0 from 428 reviews and 4.9 from 4,673. Smile's rating rests on far more reviews, and OneLoyalty's 4.5 from 112 is lower.
What breaks when you switch between Smile and OneLoyalty?
Points balances move across in either direction, but VIP tiers, memberships, referral links and theme blocks are the parts to check. Smile imports balances by CSV and keeps hands-on migration help for its $999 Plus plan, and OneLoyalty offers member import and export on every plan. I didn't run a full migration, so this list comes from what each app offers.
Before you switch, check these 5 things in order:
- Points balances: ask the app you're leaving for a file of your members and their points, using OneLoyalty's member export or Smile's support, then import it into the new app.
- VIP tiers and memberships: set up the same tier names and thresholds in the new app first, and ask its team whether members keep their tier. I didn't find paid memberships in Smile's plans, so check how you'd keep active members before you leave OneLoyalty's Premium plan.
- Referral links: ask the new app's team whether your existing referral links carry over, and tell your top referrers if their link changes.
- Theme blocks, widget and added pages: remove Smile's floating button and app blocks, or OneLoyalty's widget and pop-up games, and check your store's pages for any the old app added.
- Emails and POS: Smile's loyalty emails go through Klaviyo and OneLoyalty sends its own, so pause the old app's emails, rebuild your points reminders in the new one, then reconnect POS.
Love Loyalty offers free migration from its $79 Growth plan, and 7 of its reviews I read say the merchant moved from Smile. Keep the old app installed until you've checked a few members' balances in the new one.
Winner: Love Loyalty and Smile, because Love Loyalty offers free migration from its $79 Growth plan, and 7 of its reviews I read say the merchant moved from Smile, while Smile keeps hands-on migration help for its $999 Plus plan. OneLoyalty offers member import and export and leaves the file work to you.
Smile vs OneLoyalty: which one should you pick at your store size?
I'd pick Love Loyalty for a store that just launched and for a growing brand, because its plans cost less than Smile's and OneLoyalty's with the same must-haves, and it includes VIP tiers, paid memberships and POS together for $79/month. At the scaling and Shopify Plus sizes, Love Loyalty, OneLoyalty and Smile each fit different needs, and Smile is the one that also works on BigCommerce. I matched the plan each app charges at 4 store sizes, so each pick is on the same order volume.
Which plan fits a store that just launched?
Smile's $15 Essential plan:
- Monthly cost: $15/month
- Orders included: 500
- Above the limit: the programme pauses until you upgrade
- Must-have features: points, without VIP tiers
- Support: live chat
OneLoyalty's $49 Growth plan:
- Monthly cost: $49/month
- Orders included: 1,000
- Above the limit: $0.15 per order, capped at $299/month
- Must-have features: points, without VIP tiers
- Support: priority support
Love Loyalty's $12 Professional plan:
- Monthly cost: $12/month
- Orders included: 500
- Above the limit: no overage, so you upgrade to the Growth plan
- Must-have features: points, without VIP tiers
- Support: live chat
My pick: Love Loyalty, because its $12 plan costs $3 less than Smile's and adds points on product pages and points expiry, which Smile keeps for its $79 and $199 plans. Smile makes more sense when you want 9 storefront languages, and OneLoyalty's $49 Growth plan when you have no email app and want games and 2,000 email sends.
Which plan fits a growing brand?
Smile's $199 Growth plan:
- Monthly cost: $199/month
- Orders included: 2,500
- Above the limit: $20 per 100 orders
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: live chat
OneLoyalty's $199 Premium plan:
- Monthly cost: $199/month
- Orders included: 3,000
- Above the limit: $0.10 per order, capped at $999/month
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: priority support
Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan:
- Monthly cost: $79/month
- Orders included: 2,000
- Above the limit: $15 per 100 orders
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: live chat and free migration
My pick: Love Loyalty, because its $79 plan includes VIP tiers, paid memberships, B2B loyalty and wallet passes for $120 less than both others' $199 plans. You'd give up OneLoyalty's 10,000 email sends and API access at that price, and Smile's 9 storefront languages and Loyalty Hub in customer accounts.
Which plan fits a scaling store?
Smile's $999 Plus plan:
- Monthly cost: $999/month, and Smile charges for 12 months at once
- Orders included: 7,500
- Above the limit: $5 per 100 orders
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: priority support, a launch plan and migration help
OneLoyalty's Enterprise plan, a custom quote:
- Monthly cost: a custom quote
- Orders included: 10,000+
- Above the limit: $0.05 per order, capped at $1,999/month
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: priority support and a dedicated success manager
Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan:
- Monthly cost: $399/month
- Orders included: unlimited
- Above the limit: no limit, so the price doesn't change
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: live chat, founder-led onboarding and performance audits
My pick: Love Loyalty and OneLoyalty, for different needs. Love Loyalty's $399 plan offers unlimited orders, API access, founder-led onboarding and checkout extensions at a fixed price, which is $600 less each month than Smile's $999 plan. OneLoyalty makes more sense when you want 20,000 email sends, custom game development and a dedicated success manager, and Smile when you want its launch plan, though you'd pay for 12 months at once.
Which plan fits a Shopify Plus store?
Smile's Enterprise plan, a custom quote:
- Monthly cost: a custom quote, billed for 12 months at once
- Orders included: unlimited
- Above the limit: not applicable
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: an account manager
OneLoyalty's Enterprise plan, a custom quote:
- Monthly cost: a custom quote
- Orders included: 10,000+
- Above the limit: $0.05 per order, capped at $1,999/month
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: priority support and a dedicated success manager
Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan:
- Monthly cost: $399/month
- Orders included: unlimited
- Above the limit: no limit, so the price doesn't change
- Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
- Support: live chat, founder-led onboarding and performance audits
My pick: Smile and Love Loyalty, for different needs. Smile's custom-quote Enterprise plan offers unlimited orders, an account manager, custom API rate limits, data warehouse sync and BigCommerce, while Love Loyalty's $399 plan offers unlimited orders, checkout extensions and API access with founder-led onboarding at a stated price, if you're on Shopify only and sell in English. OneLoyalty makes more sense for multi-level referral commission and custom games.
All three offer a 14-day trial on paid plans, and OneLoyalty adds a 30-day satisfaction guarantee on its $49 Growth plan.
Smile vs OneLoyalty: key takeaways at a glance
Smile costs less at 500 orders, OneLoyalty at 1,000, they cost the same at 2,000, and Love Loyalty costs less than both at 500 and 2,000 orders. Two jobs the rest of this article doesn't settle:
- For API access: OneLoyalty offers it on its $199 Premium plan, Love Loyalty on its $399 Plus plan and Smile on its $999 Plus plan.
- For POS: Smile offers it from $15/month and Love Loyalty from $12/month, while OneLoyalty starts at $49/month.
The short verdict
I'd pick Love Loyalty for a small store and a growing brand, because it costs $12 at 500 orders and $79 at 2,000 and includes VIP tiers and paid memberships at $79. Smile makes more sense when you need BigCommerce or 9 storefront languages, and OneLoyalty when you want built-in emails and games.
Smile
What I liked:
- $15/month for 500 orders, with POS and referrals
- Matched my theme's fonts and colours without changes
- Also works on BigCommerce, with 9 storefront languages
What to know:
- VIP tiers and points expiry only on its $199 Growth plan
- I didn't find paid memberships, B2B loyalty or wallet passes in its plans
- Its $15 and $79 plans pause the programme at their order limit
Pick Smile if:
- You want the lowest entry price for points, referrals and POS.
- You also sell on BigCommerce.
- You want a widget that matches your theme without CSS.
OneLoyalty
What I liked:
- 2,000 built-in email sends a month from $49/month
- Games such as spin-the-wheel on its $49 Growth plan
- VIP tiers, paid memberships and API access on its $199 plan
What to know:
- VIP tiers and paid memberships only on its $199 Premium plan
- The widget's fonts didn't match my theme in my test
- Extra orders and emails are billed on top, up to $999/month on Premium
Pick OneLoyalty if:
- You want to email members without paying for a separate email app.
- You want games such as spin-the-wheel in your loyalty programme.
- You want VIP tiers, paid memberships and API access on one plan.
Love Loyalty
What I liked:
- Points, VIP tiers, referrals and POS for up to 2,000 orders for only $79/month
- Paid memberships, B2B loyalty and wallet passes from $79/month
- Unlimited orders on its $399 Plus plan
What to know:
- Shopify only, while Smile also works on BigCommerce
- English storefront only and no built-in email sends or games, while OneLoyalty offers 8 languages, emails and games
Pick Love Loyalty if:
- You want VIP tiers, paid memberships or B2B loyalty in the same app as your points.
- You want a loyalty page and widgets that pick up your theme's fonts and colours with no CSS.
- You want your loyalty data stored in Shopify metafields, so it stays in Shopify.
At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty costs $79, while Smile and OneLoyalty each cost $199. Set up the same programme on a copy of your theme in each 14-day trial and compare them on your phone.
My full reviews of these apps are here: Smile review, OneLoyalty review and Love Loyalty review.
See Smile on the Shopify App Store, OneLoyalty on the Shopify App Store, or Love Loyalty on the Shopify App Store.
What do merchants often ask about Smile vs OneLoyalty?
Is Smile cheaper than OneLoyalty?
At 500 orders, yes: Smile costs $15/month against OneLoyalty's $49. At 1,000 orders, OneLoyalty costs $49 against $79, both without VIP tiers. At 2,000 orders, both cost $199. At 5,000 orders, Smile costs $999 while OneLoyalty needs a custom quote, and for unlimited orders both do. Love Loyalty costs $12, $79, $79, $399 and $399 at the same volumes.
Is Smile or OneLoyalty better for a small store?
On price, Smile costs less than OneLoyalty: at 500 orders a month it costs $15/month and OneLoyalty costs $49/month, though OneLoyalty's plan adds games and 2,000 email sends. Love Loyalty is the pick at that size, because it costs $12/month and adds points expiry, which needs Smile's $199 Growth plan or OneLoyalty's $99 Professional plan.
Do Smile and OneLoyalty both offer VIP tiers?
Yes. Smile includes them from its $199 Growth plan. OneLoyalty includes 5 VIP tiers and 1 secret tier on its $199 Premium plan. Love Loyalty includes them from its $79 Growth plan, for up to 2,000 orders.
Do Smile and OneLoyalty offer paid memberships?
OneLoyalty does, from its $199 Premium plan. I didn't find paid memberships in Smile's plans. Love Loyalty offers them from its $79 Growth plan, with a 1.8% fee on each membership sold, and it also offers B2B loyalty and Apple and Google Wallet passes there.
Is Smile or OneLoyalty better for Shopify Plus?
Smile for unlimited orders and BigCommerce, and Love Loyalty for a stated price. Smile's Enterprise plan is a custom quote, and so is OneLoyalty's, which charges $0.05 per order above 10,000. Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan offers unlimited orders and checkout extensions.
Which has better support, Smile or OneLoyalty?
OneLoyalty, in the reviews I read. It replied to 10 of the 11 reviews where customers shared a problem and offers priority support from its $49 Growth plan. Smile offers live chat on every plan, but 43 of the 152 problem reviews I read mention support, and Love Loyalty also offers live chat on every plan.
Do Smile and OneLoyalty work with Shopify POS?
Yes, but on different plans. Smile includes POS from its $15 Essential plan, Love Loyalty from its $12 Professional plan, and OneLoyalty from its $49 Growth plan.
Is Love Loyalty a better fit than Smile or OneLoyalty?
For a Shopify store that sells in English, yes. It offers VIP tiers, paid memberships and POS for up to 2,000 orders for $79/month, and unlimited orders for $399/month. It's Shopify only, so Smile makes more sense for BigCommerce, and OneLoyalty for built-in emails, games or a storefront in 8 languages.
Can you use Smile and OneLoyalty at the same time?
You can install both, but customers would see two programmes and two points balances. Keep one live at a time, or test the second app on a copy of your theme.
Will Smile or OneLoyalty slow down your store?
I don't give speed scores, because they depend on your theme and your other apps. The total number of apps on your store matters more than one loyalty app. Sedona Apotheca raised Smile's loading speed in 2022, and The Foalyard said in 2024 that OneLoyalty's widget stopped loading after a few days, which is a different problem. Love Loyalty stores loyalty data in Shopify metafields. Test any app on your own store before and after you install it.
Which other loyalty app comparisons should you read?
These articles compare Smile and OneLoyalty with the rest of the category: