Skip to content

Best OneLoyalty alternatives reviewed in 2027

Short answer: It depends on why you're leaving OneLoyalty. When pricing is the problem, choose Love Loyalty, because it offers a points programme, VIP tiers, POS, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes for up to 2,000 orders at $79/month, and unlimited orders for $399/month. Stay on OneLoyalty when games drive your programme.

OneLoyalty combines points, referrals, games and built-in loyalty emails, and every paid plan caps the monthly bill. Merchants who left reviews praise its games and quick setup help. But it moved from free to paid tiers in late 2024 without much notice, and VIP tiers now need the $199 Premium plan.

So I installed 7 OneLoyalty alternatives on a test store. Below, you'll find what each one is built for, what it costs as of November 2026 and what you'd give up by moving.

Why do merchants look for a OneLoyalty alternative?

From what customers shared in the reviews I read, the move to paid plans is behind most complaints about OneLoyalty. In October 2024, Heather Freitas called it a "giant unjustifiable price increase", and in December 2025, Flowers Gold Coast called the old active-user metric "predatory". OneLoyalty replied to both. When I priced it at 2,000 orders a month, OneLoyalty cost $174 on its Professional plan ($99/month plus overage). I found that BLOY shows fixed overage rates up front and never moves you to a higher plan automatically.

Some merchants also lost features. In December 2024, Black Lava Vape Perú said features it had set up stopped working unless it paid. When I checked its plans, OneLoyalty's free plan blocked the programme above 100 orders. Otter Loyalty includes every feature on both its plans.

Trust came up in the reviews I read too. In June 2025, NBM said the app added a page to its store, without approval, offering $20 off for downloading an app.

These come from 11 of the 112 reviews OneLoyalty had in November 2026, so most merchants don't report them.

Which OneLoyalty alternatives made my shortlist?

I picked apps with points, referrals and VIP tiers that fix the main reasons merchants leave OneLoyalty. These 7 alternatives made my shortlist:

  • Love Loyalty: an all-in-one native loyalty app with fixed pricing
  • Gameball: games, streaks and leaderboards
  • BLOY: a native look and free migration
  • Growave: loyalty, reviews and wishlists in one subscription
  • CWILL Loyalty: 20 storefront languages and POS from $19
  • Otter Loyalty: every feature on both plans
  • SC Loyalty Rewards: a 30-day trial and spending caps like OneLoyalty's

I've put each app's rating, starting price and how it charges in this table, with OneLoyalty first as the baseline:

App Rating Starting price Charges by
OneLoyalty 4.5 from 112 reviews Free, then $49/month Orders plus built-in emails, with a spending cap
Love Loyalty 5.0 from 428 reviews Free, then $12/month Monthly orders
Gameball 4.7 from 149 reviews Free, then $34/month Monthly rewarded customers
BLOY 5.0 from 845 reviews Free, then $10/month All Shopify orders
Growave 4.8 from 1,287 reviews Free, then $15/month Orders
CWILL Loyalty 4.9 from 800 reviews Free, then $19/month Orders
Otter Loyalty 4.6 from 22 reviews Free, then $15/month Orders
SC Loyalty Rewards 4.4 from 71 reviews Free, then $29/month Loyalty members, with a spending cap

Prices as of November 2026.

For the main reason merchants leave OneLoyalty, compare Love Loyalty, Otter Loyalty and BLOY first, because all 3 cost less at 2,000 orders than OneLoyalty's Professional plan, which costs $174 at that volume.

How did I review these OneLoyalty alternatives?

I installed each app on a test store, then went through every plan and what customers shared in their newest reviews. I used OneLoyalty as the baseline for each comparison.

I looked at these details for each app:

  • VIP tiers: which plan includes them and how many tiers you can set
  • Games: spin the wheel, streaks and bonus events
  • Built-in emails: whether they count towards the bill
  • Testing: whether it includes A/B testing
  • AI features: what AI does in each app
  • Integrations: which email, review and POS tools it works with
  • Setup: how long each app took me to get a loyalty programme live
  • Design: how it looked on my test store and whether it matched my theme
  • Speed: what one more app adds to a store that already has 10 to 15 of them, as many stores do
  • Pricing: how each app charges, its plan limits and what each plan includes
  • Reviews: what customers shared in their newest reviews, including about support
  • Moving: what you can bring across from OneLoyalty

Love Loyalty comes first, because it offers VIP tiers, POS, bonus campaigns and paid memberships for up to 2,000 orders at $79/month. Its $399 Plus plan includes unlimited orders. The order of the other 6 isn't a ranking.

I don't give speed scores, because they depend on your theme and your other apps. Your own store is the better test, and all 7 apps have a free plan or trial.

What did I find when I compared them with OneLoyalty?

These alternatives fall into 2 groups. Love Loyalty, BLOY, Otter Loyalty, CWILL Loyalty and SC Loyalty Rewards focus on the core loyalty experience: points, VIP tiers, referrals and rewards. Gameball and Growave spread across other features, such as games, product reviews and wishlists.

I liked the first group most. You aren't paying for games, reviews or wishlist tools that many stores already run in other apps. I've also found that when an app splits its work across all of those, the loyalty programme is the part that gets compromised. Love Loyalty and BLOY were the two apps that looked native on my test store.

I found 6 main differences from OneLoyalty. The apps differ on which ones they include, so check which you need before you compare prices:

  • How the bill grows: OneLoyalty charges for orders and emails, with a cap. Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan includes up to 2,000 orders, and its $399 Plus plan includes unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume. BLOY, Otter Loyalty, Growave and CWILL Loyalty charge uncapped overage, while Gameball and SC Loyalty count customers.
  • Price at 2,000 orders: OneLoyalty costs $174 on its Professional plan ($99/month plus overage). Love Loyalty costs $79 on its Growth plan, Otter Loyalty $100 on its Scaler plan, BLOY $109 on its Growth plan, CWILL Loyalty $169 on its Pro plan and Growave $274 on its Growth plan. Gameball charges by rewarded customers and SC Loyalty by loyalty members.
  • VIP tiers: OneLoyalty keeps them for its $199 Premium plan. Every alternative here includes them on the plan it charges at 2,000 orders, or on its first paid plan for Gameball and SC Loyalty.
  • Paid memberships: OneLoyalty offers them on its $199 Premium plan, Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan and Otter Loyalty on both plans.
  • A/B testing: I didn't find A/B testing in any of the 8 apps.
  • Free plans: OneLoyalty, Gameball and Otter Loyalty stop at 100, Love Loyalty at 150 and BLOY, Growave, CWILL Loyalty and SC Loyalty at 200.

I also found these differences in how the apps work:

  • Reports: Growave, CWILL Loyalty and Otter Loyalty show analytics on every plan, BLOY adds them from its $10 Launch plan and OneLoyalty adds AI analytics from its $49 Growth plan.
  • AI features: Love Loyalty suggests a loyalty programme for your store with AI on its $79 Growth plan, BLOY drafts rewards and tiers with AI onboarding and Growave works with Shopify Sidekick. I didn't find AI in the others below $999.
  • Setup: the apps took me between 15 and 20 minutes each. Feature-rich apps sit at the top of that range, so setup time shouldn't decide the choice alone.
  • Design: Love Loyalty and BLOY looked native on my test store. Gameball, Otter Loyalty, Growave, CWILL Loyalty and SC Loyalty use widgets, like OneLoyalty. Gameball and SC Loyalty didn't match my theme's fonts.
  • Speed: the total number of apps on your store matters more than any single one.

What are the best OneLoyalty alternatives?

Love Loyalty is my top pick for OneLoyalty stores that don't rely on games. For Shopify stores, I'd choose its $79 Growth plan, which includes wallet passes, referrals and B2B loyalty for up to 2,000 orders a month. For Shopify Plus brands, I'd move to its $399 Plus plan for everything in Growth with unlimited orders.

Gameball comes next for stores that chose OneLoyalty for its games. The other 5 suit stores that want a native look and a free move, one app for loyalty and reviews, many languages, every feature on every plan and a long trial. But the order-based ones cost more than Love Loyalty. At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs $79, while Otter Loyalty costs $100, BLOY $109, CWILL Loyalty $169 and Growave $274. Gameball charges by rewarded customers and SC Loyalty by loyalty members instead of orders.

1. Love Loyalty: Best for an all-in-one native loyalty app with fixed pricing

Love Loyalty, a OneLoyalty alternative for Shopify

Love Loyalty is an all-in-one native loyalty app for Shopify and Shopify Plus brands. It offers points, VIP tiers, referrals and paid memberships in one app, at a published monthly price. I'd choose it when OneLoyalty's $199 Premium plan is all that stands between you and VIP tiers.

Why I like this app: What I noticed first was the cart. Customers on my test store spent their points as a discount in the cart itself, with no pop-up widget to click through. So they see their reward right when they're about to pay.

It also felt the most at home in my theme. Points showed on the product page, the loyalty page sat inside my theme and every placement used my fonts and colours, so I didn't touch any CSS. OneLoyalty's widget was hard to bring in line with my store, while Love Loyalty looked like part of it from the start.

Setup took me 15 minutes, the fastest of the 7.

Compared with OneLoyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty costs $79/month on its Growth plan and offers a points programme, VIP tiers, POS, bonus campaigns, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes. OneLoyalty's Professional plan costs $174 at that volume and still leaves out VIP tiers and paid memberships, which need its $199 Premium plan. So moving lowers your bill by $95 a month.

Above 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty costs $399/month on its Plus plan and offers everything in Growth, API access and unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume. OneLoyalty caps the bill on each plan, but its Enterprise plan still costs $499 at 10,000 orders.

But you'd give up OneLoyalty's games and its built-in loyalty emails. Check which games your customers play before you move.

Features:

  • Points for actions such as birthdays, profile completion and social follows, on the $79 Growth plan
  • VIP tiers that upgrade customers automatically on spend or points, on the $79 Growth plan
  • B2B loyalty with separate earning and redemption rules per customer segment, on the $79 Growth plan
  • A points programme, referrals and 1-click cart redemption on the free plan
  • POS, a loyalty page, 20+ placements and points expiry on the $12 Professional plan
  • Klaviyo, Judge.me, Shopify Flow and 30+ other integrations on the $12 Professional plan
  • Paid memberships, wallet passes, bonus campaigns and AI programme suggestions on the $79 Growth plan
  • Unlimited orders, checkout extensions and API access on the $399 Plus plan

Pricing: Love Loyalty charges by monthly orders:

  • Free: 150 orders a month
  • Professional: $12/month, 500 orders
  • Growth: $79/month, up to 2,000 orders
  • Plus: $399/month, unlimited orders
  • Trial: 14 days on paid plans

Reviews: Love Loyalty has 5.0 stars from 428 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise support and cart redemption, and support comes up in 46% of them, mostly for fast live chat.

Best for: Shopify stores that want points, VIP tiers, paid memberships and POS in one native app on the $79 Growth plan, and Shopify Plus brands that want unlimited orders on the $399 Plus plan.

I wouldn't choose it if: Your customers come back for OneLoyalty's games, because Love Loyalty doesn't include games or gamified campaigns. Gameball offers spin the wheel and streaks.

The Love Loyalty review goes through every plan and what merchants say.

See Love Loyalty on the Shopify App Store

2. Gameball: Best for keeping games at the centre of the programme

Gameball, a OneLoyalty alternative for Shopify

Gameball is a gamified loyalty platform. Choose it when your customers use OneLoyalty's games most.

Why I like this app: Games run through the whole app. The $34 Starter plan includes 5 VIP tiers, points expiry and the spin wheel, and POS works on every plan. Setup took me 18 minutes, mostly configuring the games and VIP tiers.

Compared with OneLoyalty: Gameball charges by customers who earn rewards each month, not by orders. Its $34 Starter plan offers points, games, 5 VIP tiers, points expiry and POS for up to 300 rewarded customers, and its $159 Pro plan raises that to 1,000. OneLoyalty's Professional plan costs $174 at 2,000 orders, so Gameball costs less while fewer than 1,000 customers earn rewards each month. On my test store, its widget font didn't match my theme, because the font only changes on the $159 Pro plan. You'd give up OneLoyalty's spending caps.

Features:

  • Streaks, spin the wheel and time-limited campaigns on the $34 Starter plan
  • Leaderboards and unlimited challenges on the $999 Guru plan
  • Up to 5 VIP tiers on the $34 Starter plan
  • Shopify POS on every plan
  • Klaviyo, Judge.me, Attentive, Omnisend and Recharge

Pricing: Gameball charges by monthly rewarded customers:

  • Free: 100 rewarded customers
  • Starter: $34/month, 300 rewarded customers
  • Pro: $159/month, 1,000 rewarded customers
  • Guru: $999/month, 10,000 rewarded customers
  • Trial: 7 days on Starter and Pro

Reviews: Gameball has 4.7 stars from 149 reviews on the Shopify App Store. In September 2025, Quest Corner called the $159 Pro plan "super cher". In October 2025, Petfast.shop said domain verification kept failing, with no reply.

Best for: Stores whose customers respond to challenges, streaks and leaderboards.

I wouldn't choose it if: You need setup help you can count on. Of the 8 reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 4 are about support. BLOY offers 24/7 human support on every plan, including Free.

Want more detail first? Read the Gameball review.

See Gameball on the Shopify App Store

3. BLOY: Best for a native look and a free move from OneLoyalty

BLOY, a OneLoyalty alternative for Shopify

BLOY is a points, VIP and referral app whose team handles migrations. I'd choose it when OneLoyalty's widget never looked right on your store.

Why I like this app: It looked native on my test store. Members earned and redeemed on product pages, in the cart and in customer accounts, and the result matched my theme's fonts. Setup took me 17 minutes, mostly checking what AI onboarding drafted.

Compared with OneLoyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, BLOY costs $109/month on its Growth plan and offers points, referrals, POS, VIP tiers, cart redemption and 20 languages. OneLoyalty's Professional plan costs $174 at that volume, so BLOY lowers your bill by $65 a month. On my test store, it looked native and matched my fonts. Its team also moves points balances, VIP tiers and customer history for free, on any plan. You'd give up the games, the spending caps and paid memberships.

Features:

  • Fixed overage rates shown up front, with no automatic upgrade
  • Referrals, points expiration and Shopify POS on the $10 Launch plan
  • VIP tiers, cart redemption and 20 languages on the $49 Growth plan
  • A 2x points order booster on the $49 Growth plan
  • AI onboarding that suggests rewards, tiers and branding
  • Integrations with Klaviyo, Judge.me, Omnisend and Gorgias

Pricing: BLOY charges by all Shopify orders:

  • Free: 200 orders a month
  • Launch: $10/month, 500 orders, then $15 per 100
  • Growth: $49/month, 1,500 orders, then $12 per 100
  • Unlimited: $129/month, 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100
  • Trial: 14 days on paid plans

Reviews: BLOY has 5.0 stars from 845 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise quick help with migrations. In March 2026, Bilge Brew found that points can't be applied at checkout without Shopify Plus, and BLOY replied.

Best for: Stores that want loyalty to sit inside the theme and their points history moved at no cost.

I wouldn't choose it if: You want to sell paid memberships, because I didn't find them on BLOY's plans. Otter Loyalty includes memberships on both of its plans.

My BLOY review covers its setup, support and verdict.

See BLOY on the Shopify App Store

4. Growave: Best for replacing loyalty, reviews and wishlist apps with one

Growave, a OneLoyalty alternative for Shopify

Growave sells loyalty, reviews and wishlists as one app. Choose it when you pay for separate review and wishlist apps.

Why I like this app: Its $15 Entry plan combines points, referrals, photo reviews, a wishlist and POS. Its Growth plan (from $199/month) adds VIP tiers, store credit, wallet passes and AI review summaries.

Compared with OneLoyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, Growave costs $274/month on its Growth plan and offers points, referrals, VIP tiers, photo and video reviews, a wishlist and wallet passes. OneLoyalty's Professional plan costs $174 at that volume, so moving to Growave raises your bill by $100 a month, though it can replace your reviews and wishlist apps. On my test store, the loyalty and wishlist widgets needed adjusting to sit well with my theme, which fits reviewers' reports of conflicts with cart drawers. You'd give up the games, paid memberships and a cap on your bill.

Features:

  • Punch card progress and boost campaigns on the $199 Growth plan
  • Points, referrals and on-site nudges on the $15 Entry plan
  • VIP tiers with tier-specific birthday rewards on the $199 Growth plan
  • Photo reviews and a wishlist on the $15 Entry plan
  • Klaviyo, Attentive, Postscript, Recharge and Gorgias

Pricing: Growave charges by monthly orders:

  • Free: 200 orders a month
  • Entry: $15/month, 500 orders, then $20 per 100
  • Growth: $199/month, 1,500 orders, then $15 per 100
  • Plus: $499/month, 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100
  • Unlimited: $999/month, unlimited orders
  • Trial: 14 days on Entry, Growth and Plus

Reviews: Growave has 4.8 stars from 1,287 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Reviewers praise replacing several apps. In September 2026, Gkomunika said Growave charges "way too much", and Growave replied.

Best for: Stores that pay for separate loyalty, review and wishlist apps and want one subscription.

I wouldn't choose it if: Price rises are why you're leaving, because reviewers describe Growave rises in 2023 and 2025. Love Loyalty offers VIP tiers on its $79 Growth plan for up to 2,000 orders.

See my full Growave review for its pros, cons and pricing.

See Growave on the Shopify App Store

5. CWILL Loyalty: Best for stores selling in many languages

CWILL Loyalty, a OneLoyalty alternative for Shopify

CWILL Loyalty & Referrals is a points, VIP and referral app. I'd choose it when you need more languages than OneLoyalty's 8.

Why I like this app: It offers 20 storefront languages, from Czech to Turkish. The free plan includes points, referrals, review rewards and 24/7 support for 200 orders. Setup took me 17 minutes, with VIP and the language settings added after the basics.

Compared with OneLoyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, CWILL Loyalty costs $169/month on its Pro plan and offers points, referrals, POS, VIP tiers, points expiry and 20 languages. OneLoyalty's Professional plan costs $174 at that volume, so your bill stays about the same, and you gain the VIP tiers OneLoyalty keeps for its $199 Premium plan. On my test store, it showed as a widget, and I used the custom CSS that comes with every plan to line it up with my store. You'd give up the games and spending caps.

Features:

  • A loyalty page, pop-ups and Shopify POS on the $19 Essential plan
  • VIP tiers on the Pro plan, from $69/month
  • Referrals and review-based rewards on the free plan
  • Analytics on every plan
  • Integrations with Judge.me, Klaviyo, Omnisend and PageFly

I didn't find AI features in its loyalty plans.

Pricing: CWILL Loyalty charges by monthly orders:

  • Free: 200 orders a month
  • Essential: $19/month for 200 orders or $29/month for 500, then $20 per 100
  • Pro: $69 (500 orders), $99 (1,000), $169 (2,000) or $229 (3,000) a month, then $15 per 100
  • Enterprise: custom quote
  • Trial: 14 days on paid plans

Reviews: CWILL Loyalty has 4.9 stars from 800 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Reviewers praise its translations. In January 2026, wimsical wardrobe said it couldn't use most functions in its region, and CWILL replied to clarify the plans.

Best for: Stores selling in several languages that want POS from $19 and VIP tiers from $69.

I wouldn't choose it if: You sell more than 3,000 orders a month, because above that every store needs a custom quote. Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan includes unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume.

For its plans and merchant feedback in full, read my CWILL Loyalty review.

See CWILL Loyalty on the Shopify App Store

6. Otter Loyalty: Best for memberships and VIP tiers on every plan

Otter Loyalty, a OneLoyalty alternative for Shopify

Otter Loyalty, formerly Super Rewards, includes every feature on both of its plans. Choose it when OneLoyalty's move to paid tiers took away features you used.

Why I like this app: Nothing sits behind a higher plan. VIP tiers, memberships, bonus events and points on product pages all come with the free Starter plan. Its widget and rewards page fit my store and matched my fonts. Setup took me 16 minutes.

Compared with OneLoyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, Otter Loyalty costs $100/month on its Scaler plan and offers points, referrals, VIP tiers and paid memberships. OneLoyalty's Professional plan costs $174 at that volume, so Otter lowers your bill by $74 a month and adds the memberships OneLoyalty keeps for its $199 Premium plan. On my test store, it used a widget, like OneLoyalty, but it matched my fonts. You'd give up the games, the spending caps and POS, and support is by email only, with a reply within 1 business day.

Features:

  • No features held back for the $15 Scaler plan
  • Points, referrals, VIP tiers and memberships on the free Starter plan
  • Data export, reports and an activity timeline
  • Bonus events and points on product pages
  • Integrations with Klaviyo and Judge.me

I didn't find any AI features in it.

Pricing: Otter Loyalty charges by monthly orders, with overage on both plans:

  • Starter: free, 100 orders a month, then $10 per 100
  • Scaler: $15/month, 300 orders, then $5 per 100
  • Trial: none, but Starter needs no card

Reviews: Otter Loyalty has 4.6 stars from 22 reviews on the Shopify App Store, and the newest dates from May 2025. In October 2024, Fashion Hub Club said the app sent 20 emails in 10 minutes, and the new owners replied.

Best for: Online stores that want paid memberships and VIP tiers without moving to a higher plan.

I wouldn't choose it if: You also sell at a shop counter, because Otter has no POS. CWILL Loyalty includes POS from its $19 Essential plan.

See Otter Loyalty on the Shopify App Store

7. SC Loyalty Rewards: Best for a 30-day trial and 3 VIP tiers at $29

SC Loyalty Rewards, a OneLoyalty alternative for Shopify

SC Loyalty Rewards is the former Loyalty Points by Bold, now run by Shop Circle. Choose it when you like OneLoyalty's spending caps and want VIP tiers for less.

Why I like this app: Every paid plan has a 30-day trial, the longest on this list. The $29 Starter plan includes 3 customer tiers, buying with points and referrals, and POS works on the free plan. Setup took me 16 minutes, mostly on points, tiers and referrals.

Compared with OneLoyalty: SC Loyalty charges by loyalty members, meaning every customer ever given points, not by orders. Its $29 Starter plan offers points, referrals, buying with points and 3 VIP tiers for up to 500 members, and its $199 Growth plan raises that to 5,000. OneLoyalty's Professional plan costs $174 at 2,000 orders, so SC Loyalty costs less while your member list stays small. On my test store, its widget sat on top of the theme and didn't match my fonts. You'd give up OneLoyalty's games.

Features:

  • 3 VIP tiers, referrals and buying with points on the $29 Starter plan
  • Unlimited VIP tiers and campaigns on the $199 Growth plan
  • Earn rules for sign-ups, purchases, social shares and birthdays
  • A 30-day free trial on each paid plan
  • Shopify POS on the free plan

I didn't find any AI features in it.

Pricing: SC Loyalty Rewards charges by loyalty members:

  • Free: up to 200 members
  • Starter: $29/month, 500 members, then $0.05 per member, capped at $499
  • Growth: $199/month, 5,000 members, then $0.03 per member, capped at $999
  • Enterprise: $499/month, 25,000 members, capped at $1,999
  • Trial: 30 days on paid plans

Reviews: SC Loyalty Rewards has 4.4 stars from 71 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Of the reviews I read where customers shared a problem, the newest came from Neha Assar Artistry in March 2025, who said customers couldn't redeem rewards. Shop Circle replied.

Best for: Stores with a small, steady member list that want tiers, a long trial and a capped bill.

I wouldn't choose it if: Your customer list is large compared with your monthly orders, because every member counts towards the bill. Otter Loyalty charges by orders instead.

The SC Loyalty Rewards review goes through every plan and what merchants say.

See SC Loyalty Rewards on the Shopify App Store

How do you choose between OneLoyalty and these alternatives?

Name the reason you're leaving, then confirm that the new app fixes it at a price you can pay. These 5 questions will shorten the list.

Start with the problem. When it's the bill, check how each app counts usage.

Then list the OneLoyalty features you use. Love Loyalty and Otter Loyalty offer paid memberships for less than OneLoyalty's $199 Premium plan, and only Gameball builds the programme around games.

Look at your theme next. Love Loyalty and BLOY sat inside my theme, while the others use widgets. Check your top two on a phone.

Then check integrations. Every app here except SC Loyalty works with Klaviyo.

Finally, read what customers shared about support in their newest reviews. In the Gameball reviews I read where customers shared a problem, half are about support, while Love Loyalty and BLOY reviewers name support agents.

Choose Love Loyalty when points and VIP tiers drive your programme rather than games. At 2,000 orders a month, it costs only $79/month on its Growth plan and offers points for purchases, birthdays and profile completion, VIP tiers that upgrade automatically, POS and paid memberships. OneLoyalty's $99 Professional plan comes to $174 at that volume. Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan suits Shopify Plus brands that want unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume.

Choose BLOY if you want your points moved for you and Gameball if games drive your programme. Stay on OneLoyalty when you use its games and emails together.

Will a OneLoyalty alternative cost you less?

Yes, with Love Loyalty, Otter Loyalty, BLOY and CWILL Loyalty. At 2,000 orders, they all cost less than OneLoyalty's Professional plan, which costs $174 at that volume. Growave costs more, unless you'd also drop a review or wishlist app.

None of the apps below includes games, and only Love Loyalty and Otter Loyalty include paid memberships.

Say you process 2,000 orders a month. OneLoyalty costs $174/month on its Professional plan, and VIP tiers need its $199 Premium plan. These alternatives cost:

  • Love Loyalty: $79/month on its Growth plan
  • Otter Loyalty: $100/month on its Scaler plan
  • BLOY: $109/month on its Growth plan
  • CWILL Loyalty: $169/month on its Pro plan
  • Growave: $274/month on its Growth plan

Gameball and SC Loyalty don't price by orders. Gameball's $34 Starter plan includes 300 rewarded customers, and SC Loyalty's $29 Starter plan includes 500 loyalty members.

Over 2 years at that level, OneLoyalty's Professional plan costs about $4,176 on monthly billing. Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs about $1,896 over the same 2 years.

Before you compare, ask each developer what happens to your bill in your busiest month.

Does OneLoyalty make you buy a second app for its loyalty mobile app?

Yes. OneLoyalty's $199 Premium plan includes an "exclusive loyalty mobile app", but I found that it's a separate OneMobile subscription.

None of the alternatives sells one. Instead, Love Loyalty includes Apple and Google Wallet passes on its $79 Growth plan, and Growave on its Growth plan (from $199/month).

Add up what you pay OneLoyalty and OneMobile together, then compare that total with the alternative's price.

Can you keep games and gamification when you leave OneLoyalty?

Yes, with Gameball. Its spin wheel and streaks come on the $34 Starter plan, and leaderboards on the $999 Guru plan. The other apps here offer bonus campaigns, not games.

Before you leave, screenshot every game and its rewards, so you can rebuild them.

When does it make sense to stay on OneLoyalty?

I'd stay on OneLoyalty if you use its games and built-in emails together and sell under 1,000 orders a month, where its Growth plan costs $49.

In my check of the plans, it was the only app here that combines games with built-in loyalty emails. Every paid plan also caps the monthly bill, which no other order-based app here does.

As a baseline, OneLoyalty took me 18 minutes to set up, mostly on games, campaigns and emails. Its widget and pop-up games were hard to bring in line with my store.

Its $49 Growth plan includes 2,000 emails, with a 14-day trial and a 30-day refund guarantee. See OneLoyalty on the Shopify App Store.

Before you leave, check whether a smaller OneLoyalty plan includes what you need.

My full OneLoyalty review covers its plans, support and what merchants say before you decide.

How do you move from OneLoyalty to another app?

No app here offers a OneLoyalty import by name. Your customers and orders stay in Shopify, and OneLoyalty's member export carries points balances across.

I'd save these from OneLoyalty before you change anything:

  • Every earning rule, reward, VIP tier and campaign
  • Your widget, loyalty page and email designs, as screenshots
  • Member points balances and tiers, as an export

Use these steps with any of the apps:

  1. Export your members and write down every rule and reward.
  2. Install the new app on its free plan or trial, and set it up on a copy of your theme.
  3. Import your members, then check a few balances by hand.
  4. Set up the same programme you have on OneLoyalty, so you're comparing like with like, then check it on your phone.
  5. Upgrade only if it does the job, then publish the theme.
  6. Remove OneLoyalty, its app embed and any blocks it added, before your next billing date.

Love Loyalty offers free migration on its $79 Growth plan, and BLOY's team moves balances, tiers and history for free on any plan.

After you uninstall, check your Online Store pages for anything OneLoyalty added, and keep your export for a year.

What changes in unusual situations?

The main changes come at high volume and across several markets.

At 10,000 orders, OneLoyalty's Enterprise plan ($499) costs less than Premium ($899). Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan includes unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume, while BLOY and CWILL Loyalty move to custom quotes.

For several markets, CWILL Loyalty and BLOY offer 20 languages and Otter Loyalty 12, against OneLoyalty's 8.

Which OneLoyalty alternative would I start with?

I'd start with Love Loyalty, because it offers VIP tiers, paid memberships and POS for up to 2,000 orders at $79/month, where OneLoyalty needs its $199 Premium plan. For Shopify Plus brands, I'd choose its $399 Plus plan with unlimited orders. Choose Gameball when games bring your customers back, and BLOY when you want your points moved for you. Stay on OneLoyalty when you use its games and emails together.

Install your 2 finalists, set up the same programme on a copy of your theme and compare them over a week of real orders.

My guide to the best Shopify loyalty apps compares the wider category.

What do merchants often ask about OneLoyalty alternatives?

Which OneLoyalty alternative is best for VIP tiers?

Love Loyalty is the closest match, with VIP tiers and paid memberships on its $79 Growth plan for up to 2,000 orders, and unlimited orders on its $399 Plus plan. Otter Loyalty offers VIP tiers for $100 on its Scaler plan at 2,000 orders.

Is there a free alternative to OneLoyalty?

Yes. Love Loyalty's free plan includes 150 orders a month. Otter Loyalty's free Starter plan includes every feature, VIP tiers and memberships among them, for 100 orders a month.

How much does OneLoyalty cost in 2026?

OneLoyalty is free for 100 orders. Its Growth plan costs $49/month for 1,000 orders, Professional $99 for 1,500, Premium $199 for 3,000 and Enterprise $499 for 10,000+.

Extra orders cost $0.05 to $0.15 each and extra emails $1 to $3 per 100. Each plan caps the bill, from $299 on Growth to $1,999 on Enterprise, and every paid plan has a 14-day trial.

Is OneLoyalty a good app?

Yes for games and built-in emails, with a 4.5 rating from 112 reviews. But most of the reviews I read where customers shared a problem are about the 2024 move to paid plans. An alternative makes more sense when you need VIP tiers below $199.

Can you move your loyalty members from OneLoyalty to another app?

Yes. OneLoyalty includes member export, so you can take points balances to the new app. Rules, rewards and designs need rebuilding by hand.

Do OneLoyalty alternatives slow down a store?

The total number of apps on your store matters more than one app, so test any app on your own store before and after you install it.

A
Written by

Alan