SC Loyalty Review 2026: Pros, Cons, Pricing & Verdict
SC Loyalty is one of the few loyalty apps on the Shopify App Store that bills by loyalty members instead of orders, with 4.4 stars from 71 reviews. It rewards customers with points, VIP tiers and referrals, online and in store through Shopify POS. Shop Circle develops it now, and you may know it by its old name, Loyalty Points by Bold. Its free plan includes up to 200 members, and its paid plans start at $29/month, with a 30-day trial that's the longest of the loyalty apps I tested.
I installed SC Loyalty on a test store, set up a points and VIP programme and read 42 merchant reviews. Below, you'll find its pros and cons, what it costs as of November 2026 and my score out of 10.
TL;DR:
- SC Loyalty suits small stores with a short member list, because it offers 3 VIP tiers, referrals and POS for up to 500 members at $29/month.
- However, every customer who ever earned points counts towards the bill, and a store at 2,000 orders a month pays $199/month on its Growth plan.
- My score: 5.0/10.
SC Loyalty pros and cons
SC Loyalty starts VIP tiers on a low plan, at $29/month. But 15 of its 71 reviews share a problem, the highest share among the loyalty apps I tested.
Pros:
- VIP tiers from $29/month: SC Loyalty includes 3 VIP tiers on its $29 Starter plan for up to 500 members, so you can reward repeat buyers from launch.
- Shopify POS on every plan, including the free plan: customers can earn and redeem points in your shop as well as online.
- A 30-day trial on every paid plan: you have a full month to test the programme on your store before the first bill.
- A cap on every paid plan: SC Loyalty stops charging at $499/month on its $29 Starter plan and at $999/month on its $199 Growth plan, so a big month can't push the bill past those figures.
Cons:
- Every member counts: SC Loyalty bills by loyalty members, and that includes customers who earned points once and never ordered again.
- Unlimited VIP tiers from $199/month: the $29 Starter plan stops at 3 VIP tiers, and a store at 2,000 orders a month pays $199/month on its Growth plan.
- A widget that didn't match my theme: in my test, the fonts stayed SC Loyalty's own, and uploading your logo waits for the $199 Growth plan.
- Translations that need paid work: when I checked, a full translation of the programme costs extra, and one reviewer found VIP tier text stuck in English.
SC Loyalty pricing: what will you pay as your orders grow?
At 2,000 orders a month, SC Loyalty costs $199/month on its Growth plan with VIP tiers. That's about $4,776 over 2 years.
SC Loyalty charges by loyalty members, not orders. In my comparisons, I count 1 loyalty member per monthly order, so the table below matches each plan's member limit to the same number of orders.
When I compared its pricing plans at 5 order volumes, this is what SC Loyalty costs a month:
| Orders a month | SC Loyalty |
|---|---|
| 500 | $29 on its Starter plan |
| 1,000 | $54 on its Starter plan |
| 2,000 | $199 on its Growth plan |
| 5,000 | $199 on its Growth plan |
| Unlimited orders | $499 on its Enterprise plan for 25,000 members, then $0.02 per extra member, up to $1,999 |
Prices as of November 2026. Developers change them, so check the app before you choose.
SC Loyalty has a free plan for up to 200 members. It offers points, 3 rewards, 1 active campaign and POS, but no VIP tiers or referrals. Past 200 members, you have to upgrade.
The $29 Starter plan includes 500 members, then adds $0.05 for each extra member, up to $499/month. The $199 Growth plan includes 5,000 members, then adds $0.03 per member, up to $999/month. The $499 Enterprise plan includes 25,000 members, then adds $0.02 per member, up to $1,999/month, and SC Loyalty has no higher plan. In my comparisons, I count a plan's overage for up to 1,000 extra orders, so above 1,500 orders I compare SC Loyalty on its Growth plan.
Say you stay at 2,000 orders a month. Over 2 years, SC Loyalty costs about $4,776 on monthly billing. Your real member count matters more than that figure, though, because customers who earned points once still count. So look at how many customers already hold points before you pick a plan.
SC Loyalty bills every 30 days and doesn't offer yearly prices. Each paid plan has a 30-day trial.
My take: SC Loyalty is fair up to 1,000 orders, but $199/month at 2,000 orders is a steep step, because a growing store can pass 1,500 members well before it needs anything on the $199 Growth plan.
SC Loyalty features: what does it offer?
SC Loyalty includes 3 VIP tiers, referrals and buy with points on its $29 Starter plan, and it keeps unlimited VIP tiers and unlimited campaigns for its $199 Growth plan. I set up a points and VIP programme, then checked which plan each feature needs.
This is the plan and price where each feature starts:
- Points: on every plan, including the free plan
- VIP tiers: 3 on its $29 Starter plan, unlimited on its $199 Growth plan
- Referrals: on its $29 Starter plan
- POS: on every plan, including the free plan
- Bonus campaigns: 1 active campaign on every plan, including the free plan, 2 on its $29 Starter plan and unlimited on its $199 Growth plan
- Buy with points: on its $29 Starter plan
- Custom rewards: 1 on its $29 Starter plan, 2 on its $199 Growth plan and unlimited on its $499 Enterprise plan
- Custom logo: on its $199 Growth plan
Customers can earn points for signing up, buying, sharing on social media and their birthday. Rewards include money off, free shipping and POS rewards, and SC Loyalty creates each one as a Shopify discount code.
The jump from the $29 Starter plan to the $199 Growth plan is mostly about limits. The $29 plan allows 6 rewards, 2 active campaigns and 3 VIP tiers, while the $199 plan removes those limits and adds your own logo. So a store that only needs a simple programme with 3 VIP tiers can stay on the $29 plan for longer.
My take: SC Loyalty offers the core of a points and VIP programme for $29/month, but its Starter limits are tight, so a store that wants more campaigns or VIP tiers pays $199/month.
SC Loyalty integrations: does it work with your other apps?
SC Loyalty connects mostly to Shopify's own tools: Shopify POS on every plan, including the free plan, and Shopify Flow from its $29 Starter plan. I checked each integration in its settings on my test store.
These are the main tools it connects to:
- Email: its own email templates, which you can edit, from its $29 Starter plan
- Shopify POS: on every plan, including the free plan
- Shopify Flow: from its $29 Starter plan
- Customer tags: works with apps that read Shopify customer tags
The customer tags link is the most useful one for a store with other apps. An email or helpdesk app that reads Shopify customer tags can pick up who's in your programme.
My take: SC Loyalty fits a store that works mainly inside Shopify, because POS and Flow come early, but check your email and reviews apps with its team before you install it.
SC Loyalty AI features: what does AI do?
I didn't find any AI features in SC Loyalty's plans. I checked each plan and SC Loyalty's settings on my test store.
My take: AI shouldn't decide your choice here, because SC Loyalty's case rests on VIP tiers at $29/month and POS on every plan.
SC Loyalty design: how does it look on your store?
SC Loyalty showed its programme in a widget over my store's pages, and it didn't match my theme's fonts. I installed it on my test theme and didn't add any CSS.
The widget is a single app embed that you switch on in the theme editor. It's the main way customers meet the programme, and the customer account page isn't where SC Loyalty shows points. You can change the widget's colours and icons, but uploading your own logo waits for the $199 Growth plan.

On mobile, the widget needed resizing before it sat well on my test store. A reviewer raised the same thing in 2018. In 2020, Premier ETAGE also said VIP tier text stayed in English after they translated the programme.
My take: SC Loyalty's widget works, but it looked like a separate app on my store, so plan time to adjust it for mobile.
SC Loyalty setup: how long does it take?
SC Loyalty took me 16 minutes, from install to a live points and VIP programme. I timed it on my test store.
Turning on the widget took one step in the theme editor. Most of the time went on points, the 3 VIP tiers and referrals, then resizing the widget so it fit on a phone screen.
Before you move an existing programme across, ask SC Loyalty's team how it imports points balances, because my test store had no programme to move.
My take: 16 minutes is quick for a points and VIP programme, so setup won't hold you back.
SC Loyalty customer support: how fast does it help?
Of the 15 reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 4 mention support or a bug that stayed unfixed. I read every review where customers shared a problem, from 2017 to March 2025, and didn't contact SC Loyalty's support myself.
The most recent praise is about speed. In March 2026, RCCS Store said the team offers live help with no AI bot first. SC Loyalty also keeps a help centre with setup guides.
The complaints are about follow-through. In March 2025, Neha Assar Artistry said customers couldn't redeem rewards and that SC Loyalty cancelled a support meeting at the last minute. Between 2021 and 2023, Eyefood Factory reviewed the app from 3 of its stores, and SC Loyalty's team told them a known bug affected many stores.
My take: Support looks better in recent reviews, but the redemption problem in 2025 matters, because a programme customers can't redeem costs you their trust.
SC Loyalty reviews: what do merchants say?
SC Loyalty has 4.4 stars from 71 reviews on the Shopify App Store, and 15 of them share a problem. I read the 20 newest 5-star reviews, all 7 four-star reviews and every review where customers shared a problem.
Most of those 15 reviews date from 2017 to 2023, when Bold still owned the app. The newest is from March 2025, so the complaints have slowed since Shop Circle took over.
Of the 15 reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 2 mention how SC Loyalty counts members. In August 2018, Ultimate Modelling Products said it counted 6,500 members when only 2,000 had ordered recently, and SC Loyalty replied. In 2017, Idea Chic said code left behind after uninstalling broke their wholesale pricing.
My take: Recent reviewers are happier than older ones, but 15 of 71 is a high share, so test the redemption flow on your own store first.
Is there a cheaper alternative to SC Loyalty?
Yes, Love Loyalty is a cheaper alternative to SC Loyalty. It offers points, VIP tiers, referrals and POS for up to 2,000 orders for only $79/month, while SC Loyalty costs $199/month at 2,000 orders on its Growth plan.
When I compared their pricing plans with points and VIP tiers at the same order volumes, Love Loyalty cost less at 2,000 orders, and SC Loyalty cost less at 1,000 and 5,000:
- 1,000 orders: SC Loyalty costs less, $54/month on its Starter plan against $79/month on Love Loyalty. Love Loyalty's $79 plan includes 2,000 orders, plus paid memberships, B2B loyalty and Apple and Google Wallet passes.
- 2,000 orders: $79/month on Love Loyalty, against $199/month on SC Loyalty's Growth plan
- 5,000 orders: SC Loyalty costs less, $199/month on its Growth plan against $399/month on Love Loyalty. Love Loyalty's $399 plan includes unlimited orders, checkout extensions for Shopify Plus stores, API access, founder-led onboarding and performance audits.
Love Loyalty charges by orders, while SC Loyalty counts every loyalty member, including customers who never order again. So a long list of one-time buyers doesn't raise your Love Loyalty bill.
With Love Loyalty, customers can redeem earned loyalty points directly in the cart, while SC Loyalty shows its programme in a widget over your store's pages. On my test store, I redeemed points in Love Loyalty's cart in 2 steps, with no pop-up, and the programme picked up my theme's fonts and colours.
Love Loyalty's live chat answered within minutes in my test. That matters here, because the most recent SC Loyalty review where a customer shared a problem is about rewards customers couldn't redeem and a cancelled support meeting.
I list more options in Best SC Loyalty alternatives.
SC Loyalty verdict: is it worth it in 2026?
My score: 5.0/10
SC Loyalty is worth it for small stores with a short member list, because it offers 3 VIP tiers, referrals and POS for $29/month, with a 30-day trial. The main drawback is that every member counts towards the bill, so a store at 2,000 orders a month pays $199/month.
Choose SC Loyalty if:
- You have under 500 loyalty members and want VIP tiers for $29/month.
- You sell in person and want Shopify POS on the free plan.
- You want a full month to test a programme before paying.
Skip SC Loyalty if:
- Your customer list is much longer than your monthly orders.
- You want the loyalty widget to match your theme's fonts without CSS.
- You sell in several languages and want the programme fully translated.
- You want more than 3 VIP tiers without paying $199/month.
The numbers that decide it are $29/month for 500 members, $199/month at 2,000 orders and the 30-day trial. Install SC Loyalty on its trial, set up your programme on a copy of your theme and check it on your phone.
See SC Loyalty on the Shopify App Store.
What do merchants often ask about SC Loyalty?
How much does SC Loyalty cost?
SC Loyalty's first paid plan costs $29/month for 500 members. At 2,000 orders a month, it costs $199/month on its Growth plan, counting 1 member per order. Each paid plan has a 30-day trial.
Is SC Loyalty free?
Yes, SC Loyalty has a free plan for up to 200 members. It offers points, 3 rewards, 1 active campaign and POS, but no VIP tiers or referrals. Past 200 members, you have to upgrade.
Is SC Loyalty good for a small store?
Yes, while your member list stays short. At 500 orders a month, the $29 Starter plan offers points, 3 VIP tiers, referrals and POS. Check how many customers already have points, because each one counts as a member.
Does SC Loyalty offer VIP tiers?
Yes, from its $29 Starter plan, which includes 3 VIP tiers. Unlimited VIP tiers start on the $199 Growth plan.
Does SC Loyalty work with Shopify POS?
Yes, on every plan, including the free plan. Customers can earn and redeem points in your shop as well as online.
Will SC Loyalty slow down your store?
SC Loyalty shouldn't slow down your store on its own, because its widget is a single app embed. I don't give speed scores, because they depend on your theme and your other apps. The total number of apps on your store matters more than any one loyalty app, so test any app on your own store before and after you install it.
Which other loyalty app articles should you read?
These articles compare SC Loyalty with the rest of the category: