Skip to content

Joy Loyalty vs OneLoyalty: Which loyalty app is better?

I installed Joy and OneLoyalty on the same test store. Below, you'll find what each one costs as of November 2026, how they differ and which one I'd pick at each store size.

I have also compared a 3rd app along with Joy and OneLoyalty, Love Loyalty, which came out as the best loyalty app for Shopify in my research of 23 loyalty apps.

TL;DR:

  • Pick Joy when your customers shop in Spanish, French, Japanese or another of its 8 storefront languages, or when you use Omnisend, Loox or Chatty. It offers VIP tiers, POS, paid memberships and wallet passes on its $129 Advanced plan, $70 less than OneLoyalty's VIP plan at 2,000 orders.
  • Pick OneLoyalty when you want built-in email sends and games such as spin-the-wheel in your loyalty app: $49/month includes up to 1,000 orders. However, its VIP tiers and paid memberships start on the $199 Premium plan, and its widget fonts didn't match my theme.
  • Pick Love Loyalty when you want a native all-in-one loyalty app with points, VIP tiers, referrals, paid memberships and POS together, offered for up to 2,000 orders for only $79/month and for unlimited orders for only $399/month.

The quick verdict:

  • Do you want VIP tiers and POS on a $129 plan, with automatic translation and Omnisend, Loox and Chatty? Choose Joy.
  • Do you want emails and games inside your loyalty app? Choose OneLoyalty.
  • Do you want VIP tiers, paid memberships and POS in one plan for $79/month? Choose Love Loyalty.

How I compared Joy and OneLoyalty

I ran every app through the same checks, so each section below compares like with like:

  • Test store: one Shopify test store and one theme, with no custom CSS in Joy or OneLoyalty
  • Programme: the same points, VIP tiers and referral setup in Joy and OneLoyalty
  • Prices: each app's plans at 500, 1,000, 2,000 and 5,000 orders a month and unlimited orders, on monthly billing, as of November 2026
  • Reviews: every review where customers shared a problem with Joy (31) and OneLoyalty (11), the 20 newest 5-star reviews of each, OneLoyalty's 2 four-star reviews, and the 427 Love Loyalty reviews
  • What decided most sections: the plan each app needs for VIP tiers and POS, and what each one adds around points, such as emails, games and languages

Joy vs OneLoyalty pricing: what will you pay as your orders grow?

Joy costs less than OneLoyalty at 500 and 2,000 orders, OneLoyalty costs less at 1,000, and Love Loyalty costs less than both except at 1,000 orders, where OneLoyalty's $49 plan costs $30 less but leaves out VIP tiers. At 2,000 orders a month, Joy's $129 Advanced plan comes to about $3,096 over 2 years, while OneLoyalty's $199 Premium plan comes to about $4,776, and both include VIP tiers.

When I compared their pricing plans at 5 order volumes, this is what each app costs a month:

Orders a month Joy OneLoyalty Love Loyalty
500 $29 on its Essential plan, without VIP tiers $49 on its Growth plan, without VIP tiers $12 on its Professional plan, without VIP tiers
1,000 $104 on its Essential plan, without VIP tiers $49 on its Growth plan, without VIP tiers $79 on its Growth plan
2,000 $129 on its Advanced plan $199 on its Premium plan $79 on its Growth plan
5,000 $499 on its Ultimate plan A custom quote on its Enterprise plan $399 on its Plus plan
Unlimited orders A custom quote on its Custom plan A custom quote on its Enterprise plan $399 on its Plus plan

Prices as of November 2026. Developers change them, so check each app before you choose.

Joy's $29 Essential plan includes 500 orders, then adds $15 for every 100, so 1,000 orders cost $104/month. Its VIP tiers start on the $129 Advanced plan, which includes 2,000 orders, then adds $10 for every 100. Its $499 Ultimate plan includes 7,000 orders, then adds $5 for every 100, and every Shopify Plus brand gets a custom quote on its Custom plan.

OneLoyalty counts orders and its built-in emails together. Its $49 Growth plan includes 1,000 orders and 2,000 emails, then adds $0.15 per extra order, up to a $299 cap. Its $199 Premium plan includes VIP tiers, 3,000 orders and 10,000 emails, then adds $0.10 per extra order, up to a $999 cap. Extra emails are billed on top.

At 1,000 orders, OneLoyalty's $49 plan costs $55 less than Joy's $104 plan, but neither includes VIP tiers. Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan costs $25 less than Joy's and $30 more than OneLoyalty's, and it includes VIP tiers, paid memberships, B2B loyalty and Apple and Google Wallet passes for up to 2,000 orders, then adds $15 for every 100.

Say you stay at 2,000 orders. Over 2 years, Love Loyalty costs about $1,896, Joy about $3,096 and OneLoyalty about $4,776. Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan offers unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume. Neither Joy nor OneLoyalty lists a yearly discount.

Winner: Love Loyalty, because it costs less than both at 500, 2,000 and 5,000 orders, with VIP tiers from $79 at 1,000 and 2,000 orders against Joy's $129 and OneLoyalty's $199 at 2,000. At 1,000 orders OneLoyalty's $49 plan costs $30 less, but it leaves out VIP tiers. Joy costs $70 less than OneLoyalty at 2,000.

Quick comparison of Joy and OneLoyalty

Joy's main strength is language and connected apps, OneLoyalty's is emails and games, and Love Loyalty's is what its lower plans include.

This is how Joy, OneLoyalty and Love Loyalty compare at a glance:

Joy OneLoyalty Love Loyalty
Best for Stores selling in several languages Stores wanting emails and games in the loyalty app Shopify stores wanting VIP tiers and memberships on one plan
Price at 2,000 orders $129 on its Advanced plan $199 on its Premium plan $79 on its Growth plan
VIP tiers from $129 Advanced plan $199 Premium plan $79 Growth plan
Main on-site element Loyalty widget and nudge pop-ups, every plan Widget, with pop-up games from $49 Growth plan Points in the cart, from $12 Professional plan
Shopify POS From $129 Advanced plan From $49 Growth plan From $12 Professional plan
Paid memberships From $129 Advanced plan From $199 Premium plan From $79 Growth plan
Wallet passes From $129 Advanced plan Virtual loyalty card, from $99 Professional plan From $79 Growth plan
Storefront languages 8 8 English only
Other platforms None named None named Shopify only
Migration Free, by its team, from other apps Member import and export Free, from $79 Growth plan
Setup time in my test 20 minutes 18 minutes 15 minutes
Shopify App Store rating 4.9 from 1,789 reviews 4.5 from 112 reviews 5.0 from 428 reviews
Free trial 14 days on $29 and $129 plans, 30 days on $499 plan 14 days on paid plans 14 days on paid plans

Joy's strengths:

  • VIP tiers, POS, paid memberships and wallet passes on one $129 plan, while OneLoyalty's VIP tiers and paid memberships start at $199.
  • Automatic translation from $129, and Omnisend, Loox and Chatty integrations from $29.
  • A widget that matched my theme, and 24/7 live chat on every plan.

OneLoyalty's strengths:

  • Built-in email sends: 2,000 a month on its $49 Growth plan and 10,000 on its $199 Premium plan, so you can email members without a separate email app.
  • Games such as spin-the-wheel on its $49 Growth plan.
  • POS from $49/month, against $129 on Joy.

Love Loyalty's strengths:

  • Paid memberships, B2B loyalty and wallet passes from $79/month, against $129 on Joy and $199 for OneLoyalty's paid memberships.
  • POS and redemption in the cart from $12/month, against $49 for OneLoyalty's POS and $129 for Joy's POS and cart-drawer redemption.
  • Points at checkout on its $79 Growth plan for any Shopify store, while Joy needs its $499 Ultimate plan and a Shopify Plus store.

Joy vs OneLoyalty features: which one offers more?

Joy offers more at its $129 plan, OneLoyalty adds emails and games from $49, and Love Loyalty includes VIP tiers and paid memberships on a lower plan than both. I set up the same points and VIP programme in Joy and OneLoyalty, then checked which plan each feature needs in all three apps.

This is the plan and price where each feature starts:

  • Referrals: Joy on its $29 Essential plan with up to 100 referrals, OneLoyalty on its $49 Growth plan, Love Loyalty on its $12 Professional plan
  • POS: Joy on its $129 Advanced plan, OneLoyalty on its $49 Growth plan, Love Loyalty on its $12 Professional plan
  • Points expiry: Joy on its $29 Essential plan, OneLoyalty on its $99 Professional plan, Love Loyalty on its $12 Professional plan
  • VIP tiers: Joy on its $129 Advanced plan, OneLoyalty on its $199 Premium plan, Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan
  • Paid memberships: Joy on its $129 Advanced plan, OneLoyalty on its $199 Premium plan, Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan
  • B2B loyalty: Joy on its $129 Advanced plan, Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan, and I didn't find it in OneLoyalty's plans
  • Games and built-in email sends: OneLoyalty on its $49 Growth plan, Love Loyalty not offered

Joy's $129 Advanced plan also rewards Instagram comments automatically and adds a rule engine for bonuses. Of the three, only OneLoyalty names games such as spin-the-wheel and its own email sends in its plans, both from its $49 Growth plan.

On AI, Joy's copilot starts on its $29 Essential plan and drafts a programme from your description, and Love Loyalty's Growth plan suggests one. OneLoyalty's AI analytics start on its $49 Growth plan, but they need order history, which my test store didn't have.

Winner: Love Loyalty for loyalty, because its $79 Growth plan includes VIP tiers, paid memberships and B2B loyalty, with POS and points expiry from $12. Joy needs its $129 plan for the same tiers and POS, and OneLoyalty its $199 plan and has no B2B loyalty I could find. OneLoyalty adds built-in emails and games from $49.

Joy vs OneLoyalty platforms and languages: where can you use each one?

Neither app has a clear lead on platforms, and both offer 8 languages. Love Loyalty is the narrowest of the three here, because it's for Shopify and Shopify Plus stores and its storefront is English only.

The Joy and OneLoyalty pages I read name no platform other than Shopify. Joy's $499 Ultimate plan adds headless support for Hydrogen and Next.js.

Joy offers 8 storefront languages: English, Spanish, Italian, French, Japanese, German, Indonesian and Chinese (Simplified). Manual translation starts on its $29 Essential plan, and its $129 Advanced plan translates automatically. OneLoyalty offers 8 as well: English, French, Japanese, Spanish, German, Chinese, Turkish and Brazilian Portuguese. Love Loyalty shows English only. In October 2025, BOUTIQUE SOVIST said Joy's French translation was poor, and Joy had fixed it by 2 November.

Neither language gap matters for a store that sells in English only. Only Joy offers Italian or Indonesian, and only OneLoyalty Turkish or Brazilian Portuguese.

Winner: Neither for platforms, because the pages I read name no platform other than Shopify for any of the three. Joy for languages, narrowly, because it and OneLoyalty both offer 8, only Joy translates automatically, from $129, and Love Loyalty shows English only.

Joy vs OneLoyalty integrations: which one works with your other apps?

Joy connects to more of the tools merchants use, and OneLoyalty's difference is that it sends loyalty emails itself. I checked the integrations in each app's settings.

These are the tools each app connects to:

  • Email and SMS: Joy works with Klaviyo and Omnisend, OneLoyalty sends its own emails, Love Loyalty works with Klaviyo
  • Reviews: Joy works with Judge.me and Loox, OneLoyalty with Judge.me and Yotpo, Love Loyalty with Judge.me and other review apps
  • Live chat: Joy works with Chatty
  • Subscriptions: Joy and Love Loyalty work with Recharge
  • Shopify Flow and customer accounts: all three
  • Shopify POS: Joy from $129, OneLoyalty from $49, Love Loyalty from $12

Joy's 30+ integrations start on its $29 Essential plan, and its unlimited integrations and REST API on its $499 Ultimate plan. OneLoyalty sends 2,000 emails a month on its $49 Growth plan, 5,000 on its $99 Professional plan and 10,000 on its $199 Premium plan, which also adds API access. Love Loyalty offers Klaviyo, Shopify Flow and 30+ other integrations from its $12 Professional plan.

Winner: Joy, because it connects to Omnisend, Judge.me, Loox and Chatty from its $29 plan, while Love Loyalty's 30+ integrations start at $12 but leave out Omnisend, Loox and Chatty. Choose OneLoyalty when you have no email app yet, because it sends its own emails.

Joy vs OneLoyalty design: how does each one look on your store?

Joy matched my theme without changes, and OneLoyalty needed more work than I'd want. I installed both apps on the same theme, added no CSS and looked at the product page, cart, loyalty page and customer account.

Joy showed its programme through a loyalty widget and on-site nudge pop-ups on every plan, and the widget fit my theme without changes. Its loyalty page and custom CSS start on the $29 Essential plan. Redemption in the cart drawer and the Loyalty Hub in customer accounts start on the $129 Advanced plan.

Joy loyalty app for Shopify

OneLoyalty showed a loyalty page and a widget, with pop-up games such as spin-the-wheel on top. The widget's text and look were hard to bring in line with my store, and its fonts didn't match my theme.

OneLoyalty loyalty app for Shopify

Love Loyalty takes a different approach from both widgets: customers can redeem earned loyalty points directly in the cart, with no pop-up. Points also showed on the product page, and every placement picked up my fonts and colours without CSS.

Love Loyalty loyalty app for Shopify

In the reviews I read, Mamma Latte said in March 2025 that Joy's widget doesn't always load. Cantabria Labs said in October 2024 that changing OneLoyalty's widget text needed a $399 plan at the time, and NBM said in June 2025 that the app added a page to their store, without approval. Of the 427 Love Loyalty reviews I read, 36 mention the cart.

Winner: Joy and Love Loyalty both matched my theme with no CSS, and Love Loyalty's placements start at $12 against Joy's loyalty page at $29. OneLoyalty's text and fonts were hard to match.

Joy vs OneLoyalty setup: how long does each one take?

Love Loyalty took me 15 minutes, OneLoyalty 18 and Joy 20. I timed each app from install to a working points and VIP programme.

In Joy, VIP and B2B tiers, the rule engine, wallet passes and paid memberships all sit on the $129 Advanced plan, and setting up each one took most of the time. In OneLoyalty, the games, campaigns and built-in emails took most of the time after the basic points went live. In Love Loyalty, most of it went on its 20+ placements and VIP tiers.

Winner: Love Loyalty, because it took me 15 minutes against OneLoyalty's 18 and Joy's 20. A few minutes shouldn't decide the choice.

Joy vs OneLoyalty customer support: who helps you faster?

OneLoyalty replied to more of its problem reviews, while Joy and Love Loyalty help faster on any plan because their live chat is on every plan. I read every review where customers shared a problem with either app.

Joy offers 24/7 live chat on every plan, a dedicated account manager from its $129 Advanced plan and priority support with an SLA on its $499 Ultimate plan. In September 2025, Forbidden13 said they bought a plan on chat's advice, then heard they needed one 10 times the price. Of the 31 Joy reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 10 mention support, and Joy replied to 19 of the 31, usually within 1 to 2 days.

OneLoyalty offers priority support from its $49 Growth plan, and its custom-quote Enterprise plan adds a dedicated success manager. Of the 11 OneLoyalty reviews I read where customers shared a problem, it replied to 10, each time with a named person.

Love Loyalty offers live chat on every plan. Of the 427 reviews I read, 198 mention support, almost all as praise, and Avant Skincare said chat replies come within minutes.

Winner: OneLoyalty, because it replied to 10 of its 11 problem reviews, each time with a named person, against Joy's 19 of 31. Joy and Love Loyalty both offer live chat on every plan, from $29 and $12, and Joy's account manager starts on its $129 plan.

Joy vs OneLoyalty reviews: what do merchants say?

Joy has 4.9 stars from 1,789 reviews on the Shopify App Store, OneLoyalty has 4.5 from 112 and Love Loyalty has 5.0 from 428. Beyond the support reviews, I looked at what recent reviewers praise and what problems repeat.

Recent Joy reviewers praise its support and setup. Of the 31 reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 4 mention price, and 4 describe the app changing store data at scale after an update or import. In April 2024, EcigZoo said an update awarded 1.2 million points for 19,866 old orders.

Recent OneLoyalty reviewers praise an easy setup and fast help. Of the 11 reviews I read where customers shared a problem, 7 are about pricing changes, mostly from October to December 2024, when the free app moved to paid plans. In December 2025, Flowers Gold Coast called the old monthly active users charge "predatory". It now bills by orders and emails.

In the Love Loyalty reviews I read, I found 1 where a customer shared a problem: in June 2026, Ten Twelve said referrals didn't tell new customers from existing ones.

Winner: Joy and Love Loyalty, because Joy's 4.9 from 1,789 reviews and Love Loyalty's 5.0 from 428, with 1 sharing a problem, are 0.1 apart, which is too small to separate them. OneLoyalty holds 4.5 from 112.

What breaks when you switch between Joy and OneLoyalty?

Points balances move across in either direction, but VIP tiers, referral links and emails are the parts to check. Joy's team migrates points, tiers and reward history from other apps for free, and OneLoyalty offers member import and export on every plan. I didn't run a full migration on my test store, so this list comes from what each app offers.

Before you switch, check these 5 things in order:

  1. Points balances: ask the app you're leaving for a file of your members and their points. OneLoyalty's member export gives you one, while Joy lists loyalty data exports on its $499 Ultimate plan, so on a lower plan ask Joy's support.
  2. VIP tiers and paid memberships: set up the same tier names and thresholds in the new app first, and ask its team whether members keep their tier and paid status. OneLoyalty has 5 tiers and 1 secret tier.
  3. Referral links: ask the new app's team whether your existing referral links carry over.
  4. Theme blocks, widgets and added pages: remove Joy's widget and nudge pop-ups, or OneLoyalty's widget and pop-up games, and check your store's pages for any the old app added.
  5. Emails and POS: Joy's loyalty emails go through Klaviyo or Omnisend and OneLoyalty sends its own, so rebuild your points reminders in the new app, then reconnect POS before it goes live.

Joy offers a full refund in the first 30 days of a paid plan, and OneLoyalty a 30-day satisfaction guarantee on its $49 Growth plan.

Love Loyalty offers free migration from its $79 Growth plan, and 25 of the Love Loyalty reviews I read describe a switch or migration from another app. Keep the old app installed until a few members' balances check out in the new one.

Winner: Joy and Love Loyalty both migrate for free, Joy's team moving tiers and reward history as well as balances and Love Loyalty from its $79 Growth plan, where 25 reviews I read describe a switch. OneLoyalty leaves the file work to you.

Joy vs OneLoyalty: which one should you pick at your store size?

I matched the plan each app charges at 4 store sizes, so each pick is on the same order volume. Love Loyalty is my pick for a new store and a growing brand, Joy and Love Loyalty share the scaling stage, and OneLoyalty is my pick for a Shopify Plus store. Joy makes more sense when you want a widget that matched my theme, automatic translation or Omnisend, Loox and Chatty, and OneLoyalty when you want built-in emails and games.

Which plan fits a store that just launched?

Joy's $29 Essential plan:

  • Monthly cost: $29/month
  • Orders included: 500
  • Above the limit: $15 per 100 orders
  • Must-have features: points, without VIP tiers
  • Support: 24/7 live chat

OneLoyalty's $49 Growth plan:

  • Monthly cost: $49/month
  • Orders included: 1,000
  • Above the limit: $0.15 per order, capped at $299/month
  • Must-have features: points, without VIP tiers
  • Support: priority support

Love Loyalty's $12 Professional plan:

  • Monthly cost: $12/month
  • Orders included: 500
  • Above the limit: no overage, so you upgrade to the Growth plan
  • Must-have features: points, without VIP tiers
  • Support: live chat

My pick: Love Loyalty, because its $12 plan includes POS and redemption in the cart, which Joy keeps for its $129 plan, and costs $17 less than Joy's $29 and $37 less than OneLoyalty's $49. OneLoyalty's plan makes more sense when you have no email app yet, because it includes email sends and games.

Which plan fits a growing brand?

Joy's $129 Advanced plan:

  • Monthly cost: $129/month
  • Orders included: 2,000
  • Above the limit: $10 per 100 orders
  • Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
  • Support: 24/7 live chat and a dedicated account manager

OneLoyalty's $199 Premium plan:

  • Monthly cost: $199/month
  • Orders included: 3,000
  • Above the limit: $0.10 per order, capped at $999/month
  • Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
  • Support: priority support

Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan:

  • Monthly cost: $79/month
  • Orders included: 2,000
  • Above the limit: $15 per 100 orders
  • Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
  • Support: live chat and free migration

My pick: Love Loyalty, because its $79 plan includes VIP tiers, B2B loyalty, paid memberships, wallet passes and POS for $50 less than Joy's $129 and $120 less than OneLoyalty's $199. You'd give up OneLoyalty's 10,000 email sends and API access, and Joy's plan adds automatic translation.

Which plan fits a scaling store?

Joy's $499 Ultimate plan:

  • Monthly cost: $499/month
  • Orders included: 7,000
  • Above the limit: $5 per 100 orders
  • Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
  • Support: 24/7 live chat, a dedicated account manager, priority support with an SLA and white-glove onboarding

OneLoyalty's Enterprise plan, a custom quote:

  • Monthly cost: a custom quote
  • Orders included: 10,000+
  • Above the limit: $0.05 per order, capped at $1,999/month
  • Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
  • Support: priority support and a dedicated success manager

Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan:

  • Monthly cost: $399/month
  • Orders included: unlimited
  • Above the limit: no limit, so the price doesn't change
  • Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
  • Support: live chat, founder-led onboarding and performance audits

My pick: Joy and Love Loyalty. Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan offers unlimited orders, checkout extensions and API access at a fixed price, $100 less each month than Joy's $499, while Joy's Ultimate plan adds priority support with an SLA and white-glove onboarding. OneLoyalty's price depends on your quote, and it makes more sense when you want 20,000 email sends and a dedicated success manager.

Which plan fits a Shopify Plus store?

Joy's Custom plan, a custom quote:

  • Monthly cost: a custom quote
  • Orders included: set in your quote
  • Above the limit: set in your quote
  • Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
  • Support: set in your quote

OneLoyalty's Enterprise plan, a custom quote:

  • Monthly cost: a custom quote
  • Orders included: 10,000+
  • Above the limit: $0.05 per order, capped at $1,999/month
  • Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
  • Support: priority support and a dedicated success manager

Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan:

  • Monthly cost: $399/month
  • Orders included: unlimited
  • Above the limit: no limit, so the price doesn't change
  • Must-have features: points and VIP tiers
  • Support: live chat, founder-led onboarding and performance audits

My pick: OneLoyalty, because its Enterprise plan names a dedicated success manager, multi-level referral commission and custom games. Love Loyalty makes more sense for Shopify Plus brands that sell in English and want its $399 Plus plan with unlimited orders, checkout extensions and API access at a fixed price, and Joy when you use Omnisend, Loox or Chatty, or need a headless storefront.

Joy offers a 14-day trial on its $29 and $129 plans and 30 days on its $499 plan. The other two offer 14 days on paid plans.

Joy vs OneLoyalty: key takeaways at a glance

Joy costs less than OneLoyalty at 500 and 2,000 orders and OneLoyalty costs less at 1,000, and Love Loyalty costs less than both except at 1,000. Two jobs the rest of this article doesn't settle:

  • For points expiry: Joy includes it on its $29 Essential plan, OneLoyalty on its $99 Professional plan and Love Loyalty on its $12 Professional plan.
  • For wallet passes: Joy offers Apple and Google Wallet passes on its $129 Advanced plan and Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan, while OneLoyalty offers a virtual loyalty card on its $99 Professional plan.

The short verdict

I'd pick Love Loyalty for a Shopify store that sells in English, because it offers VIP tiers, paid memberships and POS together for $79/month. Joy makes more sense when you want VIP tiers, POS and paid memberships on a $129 plan with 24/7 live chat on every plan, and OneLoyalty when you want emails and games inside the app.

Joy

What I liked:

  • 8 storefront languages, with automatic translation on its $129 Advanced plan
  • Omnisend, Loox and Chatty integrations from its $29 Essential plan
  • Widget matched my theme without changes, and 24/7 live chat on every plan

What to know:

  • VIP tiers, POS, paid memberships and wallet passes only on its $129 Advanced plan
  • Referrals capped at 100 on its $29 Essential plan
  • 4 of the 31 problem reviews I read describe the app changing store data at scale

Pick Joy if:

  • You sell to customers who shop in Spanish, French, Japanese or Joy's other languages.
  • You use Omnisend, Loox or Chatty and want your loyalty programme connected.
  • You want VIP tiers and POS on a $129 plan rather than OneLoyalty's $199 one.

OneLoyalty

What I liked:

  • 2,000 built-in email sends a month from $49/month
  • Games such as spin-the-wheel on its $49 Growth plan
  • POS from $49, and a reply to 10 of the 11 problem reviews I read

What to know:

  • VIP tiers and paid memberships only on its $199 Premium plan
  • The widget's fonts didn't match my theme in my test
  • Extra orders and emails are billed on top, up to $999/month

Pick OneLoyalty if:

  • You want to email members without paying for a separate email app.
  • You want games such as spin-the-wheel in your loyalty programme.
  • You want POS rewards at your till from $49/month.

Love Loyalty

What I liked:

  • Points, VIP tiers, referrals and POS for up to 2,000 orders for only $79/month
  • Paid memberships, B2B loyalty and wallet passes from $79/month
  • Unlimited orders on its $399 Plus plan, so the price doesn't grow with orders

What to know:

  • English storefront only, while Joy and OneLoyalty offer 8 languages
  • No Omnisend, Loox or Chatty integration, while Joy offers all three, and no built-in email sends or games, while OneLoyalty offers both

Pick Love Loyalty if:

  • You want VIP tiers, paid memberships or B2B loyalty in the same app as your points.
  • You want shoppers to use their points in the cart, with no pop-up.
  • You want POS rewards at your till from $12/month.

At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty costs $79, Joy costs $129 and OneLoyalty costs $199, all with VIP tiers. All three offer a free trial, so set up the same programme on a copy of your theme and compare them on your phone.

For more on each app, read my Joy review, OneLoyalty review and Love Loyalty review.

See Joy on the Shopify App Store, OneLoyalty on the Shopify App Store, or Love Loyalty on the Shopify App Store.

What do merchants often ask about Joy vs OneLoyalty?

Is Joy cheaper than OneLoyalty?

At some volumes. Joy costs $29/month against OneLoyalty's $49 at 500 orders, and $129 against $199 at 2,000. OneLoyalty costs $49 against Joy's $104 at 1,000, with neither including VIP tiers. At 5,000 orders, Joy costs $499 on its Ultimate plan, while OneLoyalty needs a custom quote. For unlimited orders, both need a custom quote. Love Loyalty costs $12, $79, $79, $399 and $399 at the same volumes.

Is Joy or OneLoyalty better for a small store?

Joy, for most. At 500 orders a month, it costs $29/month and OneLoyalty costs $49/month. OneLoyalty's plan adds email sends, games and POS, so it suits a small store with no email app. Love Loyalty costs $12/month and adds POS and redemption in the cart, which need Joy's $129 Advanced plan, so it makes more sense than either at this size.

Do Joy and OneLoyalty both offer VIP tiers?

Yes. Joy includes them from its $129 Advanced plan. OneLoyalty includes 5 VIP tiers and 1 secret tier on its $199 Premium plan. Love Loyalty includes them from its $79 Growth plan, for up to 2,000 orders.

Do Joy and OneLoyalty offer paid memberships?

Yes. Joy offers them from its $129 Advanced plan and OneLoyalty from its $199 Premium plan. Love Loyalty offers them from its $79 Growth plan, and it also offers B2B loyalty and Apple and Google Wallet passes there.

Is Joy or OneLoyalty better for Shopify Plus?

Both price Shopify Plus by quote: Joy on its Custom plan and OneLoyalty on its Enterprise plan, which names a dedicated success manager and custom game development, so OneLoyalty makes more sense when you want that support. Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan offers unlimited orders and checkout extensions at a fixed price.

Which has better support, Joy or OneLoyalty?

OneLoyalty, on replies: it replied to 10 of the 11 problem reviews I read, and Joy to 19 of 31. Joy offers 24/7 live chat on every plan and Love Loyalty offers live chat on every plan, while OneLoyalty offers priority support from $49.

Do Joy and OneLoyalty work with Shopify POS?

Yes, but on different plans. OneLoyalty includes POS from its $49 Growth plan, Joy from its $129 Advanced plan, and Love Loyalty from its $12 Professional plan.

Is Love Loyalty a better fit than Joy or OneLoyalty?

For a Shopify store that sells in English, yes. It offers VIP tiers, paid memberships and POS for up to 2,000 orders for $79/month. Its storefront is English only, so Joy or OneLoyalty make more sense when your customers shop in several languages.

Can you use Joy and OneLoyalty at the same time?

You can install both, but customers would see two programmes and two points balances. Keep one live at a time.

Will Joy or OneLoyalty slow down your store?

I don't give speed scores, because they depend on your theme and your other apps. Mamma Latte said in March 2025 that Joy's widget doesn't always load, and The Foalyard said in 2024 that OneLoyalty's stopped loading after a few days, which is a different problem from speed. Joy pushes loyalty data to Shopify metafields from its $29 Essential plan, and Love Loyalty stores it there too. Test any app on your own store before and after you install it.

Which other loyalty app comparisons should you read?

These articles compare Joy and OneLoyalty with the rest of the category:

A
Written by

Alan