Best Appstle Loyalty alternatives reviewed in 2027
Short answer: When you want paid memberships and wallet passes in your loyalty app, choose Love Loyalty, because it offers a points programme, VIP tiers, POS, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes for up to 2,000 orders at $79/month, and unlimited orders for $399/month. Stay on Appstle when points and VIP tiers are all you need.
Appstle Loyalty offers VIP tiers on its $30 Business plan, and merchants who left reviews praise its 24/7 live chat. But in the reviews I read where customers shared a problem, they describe bugs that come back and gaps in subscription and VIP logic.
So I installed 7 Appstle Loyalty alternatives on a test store. Below, you'll find what each one is built for, what it costs as of November 2026 and what you'd give up by moving.
Why do merchants look for an Appstle Loyalty alternative?
From what customers shared in the reviews I read, most merchants leave Appstle over bugs that come back after a fix. Gaps in subscription and VIP logic and clashes with the theme come up too.
Appstle's support replies fast, but support came up in 14 of the 19 reviews I read where customers shared a problem, often because a fix didn't hold. In August 2025, NH Stoffe said Appstle fixed the same error more than 10 times and it kept coming back. In my test, Love Loyalty's live chat answered within minutes, and support comes up in 46% of its reviews, mostly as praise.
In July 2026, Solli's Hundebedarf found that subscribers can't redeem points on subscription orders, and in October 2026, Maison GLOWLY said VIP tiers have no rolling window. I couldn't confirm a rolling VIP window in any alternative, so ask before you move.
In 2024, Press Vinyl Cafe found about 800 lines of code added to every page. In June 2025, Appstle asked We Print Miniatures to remove its own CSS because of clashing IDs, and on my test store, Appstle's CSS clashed with my theme too.
These come from 19 of Appstle's 1,482 reviews, so most merchants don't report them.
Which Appstle Loyalty alternatives made my shortlist?
I selected apps that do the same job as Appstle, with a rating of 4.4 or higher and merchant reviews from 2026. These 7 alternatives made my shortlist:
- Love Loyalty: an all-in-one native loyalty app with fixed pricing
- BON: one flat price with unlimited orders
- BLOY: free migration and developer tools at $129
- Joy: memberships and B2B tiers for Recharge stores
- CWILL: multi-language loyalty that works with Seal Subscriptions
- Otter: every feature on both plans, including the free one
- SC Loyalty: pricing by loyalty members instead of orders
I've put each app's rating, starting price and how it charges in this table, with Appstle first as the baseline:
| App | Rating | Starting price | Charges by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appstle Loyalty | 5.0 from 1,482 reviews | Free, then $10/month | Order caps, with overage from $100 |
| Love Loyalty | 5.0 from 428 reviews | Free, then $12/month | Monthly orders |
| BON | 5.0 from 1,987 reviews | Free, then $15/month | Features, with order caps and no overage |
| BLOY | 5.0 from 845 reviews | Free, then $10/month | All Shopify orders, with overage per 100 |
| Joy | 4.9 from 1,789 reviews | Free, then $29/month | Monthly orders, with overage per 100 |
| CWILL | 4.9 from 800 reviews | Free, then $19/month | Monthly orders on a slider, with overage on its $19 Essential plan |
| Otter | 4.6 from 22 reviews | Free, then $15/month | Monthly orders, with overage per 100 |
| SC Loyalty | 4.4 from 71 reviews | Free, then $29/month | Loyalty members, with a spending cap |
Prices as of November 2026.
When recurring bugs or support are your reason for leaving, compare Love Loyalty, BON and BLOY first.
How did I review these Appstle Loyalty alternatives?
I installed each app on a test store, then went through every plan and what customers shared in their newest reviews. I used Appstle as the baseline for each comparison.
I looked at these details for each app:
- VIP and memberships: which plan adds VIP tiers, paid memberships and B2B rewards
- In-store: which plan adds Shopify POS and wallet passes
- Subscriptions: which subscription apps it works with
- AI features: what AI does in each app
- Setup: how long each app took me to get a points programme live
- Design: how it looked on my test store and whether it matched my theme
- Pricing: what each app costs at 2,000 orders a month and what happens at the plan limit
- Reviews: what customers shared in their newest reviews, including about support
- Moving: what each developer offers to bring your points across
Love Loyalty comes first because it offers VIP tiers, POS, paid memberships, B2B loyalty and wallet passes for up to 2,000 orders at $79/month. Its Plus plan includes unlimited orders for $399. The order of the other 6 isn't a ranking.
I don't give speed scores, because they depend on your theme and your other apps. Your own store is the better test, and all 7 apps have a free plan or trial.
What did I find when I compared them with Appstle Loyalty?
These alternatives fall into 2 groups. Love Loyalty, BON, BLOY, Otter and SC Loyalty focus on the core loyalty experience: points, VIP tiers, referrals and rewards. Joy and CWILL spread across other features, such as social rewards, receipt scanning and rewards tied to CWILL's own reviews app.
I liked the first group most. You aren't paying for social or review tools that many stores already run in other apps. I've also found that when an app splits its work across all of those, the loyalty programme is the part that gets compromised. On my test store, Love Loyalty and BLOY, both from the first group, looked native, while Joy and CWILL used widgets and CWILL needed custom CSS.
I found 3 main differences from Appstle. The apps differ on which ones they include, so check which you need before you compare prices:
- How the bill grows: Appstle's $30 Business plan stops at 2,000 orders, so above that you move to its $100 Business Premium plan for 5,000, then $0.015 per order. Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan includes up to 2,000 orders, and its $399 Plus plan includes unlimited orders. BON's $129 Growth plan also includes unlimited orders, while the others charge per order or member, or move you to a custom quote.
- Price at 2,000 orders: Appstle costs $30 on its Business plan. Love Loyalty costs $79 on Growth, Otter $100 on Scaler, BLOY $109 on Growth, BON $129 on Growth, Joy $129 on Advanced and CWILL $169 on Pro. SC Loyalty charges by loyalty members instead, from $29 for 500 members on its Starter plan.
- Paid memberships: Appstle sends them to its separate membership app. Love Loyalty includes them on its $79 Growth plan, Joy on its $129 Advanced plan and Otter on both plans.
I also found these differences in how the apps work:
- AI features: Appstle has none. Love Loyalty suggests a loyalty programme for your store with AI on its $79 Growth plan. BON, BLOY and Joy add AI for setup or suggestions, while CWILL, Otter and SC Loyalty have none.
- Setup: each app took me between 15 and 20 minutes, against 18 for Appstle. Love Loyalty was the fastest at 15 minutes and Joy took 20. Apps with more features took longer, so setup time shouldn't decide the choice on its own.
- Design: Love Loyalty and BLOY looked native on my test store, while the other 5 used widgets. Love Loyalty, BLOY, Joy and Otter matched my fonts, BON and CWILL needed changes and SC Loyalty didn't match.
What are the best Appstle Loyalty alternatives?
Love Loyalty is my top pick for Appstle stores that want more than points and VIP tiers. For Shopify stores, I'd choose its $79 Growth plan, which adds bonus campaigns, B2B loyalty and paid memberships for up to 2,000 orders a month. For Shopify Plus brands, I'd pick its $399 Plus plan, which includes everything in Growth with unlimited orders.
Joy comes next for Recharge stores that want paid memberships and B2B tiers. The other 5 suit a flat price as you grow (BON), a done-for-you migration (BLOY), several languages (CWILL), every feature on one plan (Otter) and few loyalty members (SC Loyalty). At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs $79, while Otter costs $100, BLOY $109, BON and Joy $129 and CWILL $169. SC Loyalty charges by loyalty members instead of orders. Appstle's $30 Business plan costs less than all of them, so you'd move for memberships, wallet passes or fewer bugs rather than a lower bill.
1. Love Loyalty: Best for an all-in-one native loyalty app with fixed pricing

Love Loyalty is an all-in-one native loyalty app for Shopify and Shopify Plus brands. It offers points, VIP tiers, referrals and paid memberships in one app, at a published monthly price. I'd choose it when you want paid memberships and B2B rewards in your loyalty app, instead of a second Appstle app.
Why I like this app: Cart redemption was the feature I'd point to first. On my test store, customers spent points in the cart in 2 steps, and no pop-up widget opened along the way. That means the reward shows up right where shoppers decide to pay.
The look on my store came close behind. Points appeared on the product page and the loyalty page sat inside my theme, using my fonts and colours with no CSS. Appstle's CSS clashed with the same theme, so this is the difference you'd notice first.
Setup took me 15 minutes, the fastest of the 7.
Compared with Appstle: At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty costs $79/month on its Growth plan and offers a points programme, VIP tiers, POS, bonus campaigns, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes. Appstle's Business plan costs $30 at that volume and offers VIP tiers and POS, but it sends paid memberships to a separate app and doesn't offer wallet passes. So Love Loyalty costs $49 a month more, and that buys memberships and wallet passes in the same app.
Above 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty costs $399/month on its Plus plan and offers everything in Growth, API access and unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume. Appstle's $100 Business Premium plan includes 5,000 orders, so Appstle still costs less at that volume.
But you'd give up Appstle's lower price and its native link with Appstle Subscriptions and Appstle Membership. When VIP tiers are all you use, Appstle costs less.
Features:
- Paid memberships (1.8% fee), with perks you set for members, on the $79 Growth plan
- Apple and Google Wallet passes that show each customer's points balance and VIP tier, on the $79 Growth plan
- Shopify POS earning and redemption, with staff enrolment through a small widget, on the $12 Professional plan
- Loyalty data stored in Shopify metafields, so you can see it in your Shopify admin
- Points, referrals and cart redemption on the free plan
- A loyalty page, 20+ placements and points expiry on the $12 Professional plan
- Integrations with Klaviyo, Shopify Flow and 30+ other apps on the $12 Professional plan
- VIP tiers, B2B loyalty, rewards for activities, bonus campaigns and AI programme suggestions on the $79 Growth plan
- API access, checkout extensions and unlimited orders on the $399 Plus plan
Pricing: Love Loyalty charges by monthly orders:
- Free: 150 orders a month
- Professional: $12/month, 500 orders
- Growth: $79/month, up to 2,000 orders
- Plus: $399/month, unlimited orders
- Trial: 14 days
Reviews: Love Loyalty has 5.0 stars from 428 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise support and cart redemption.
Best for: Shopify stores that want points, VIP tiers, paid memberships and B2B loyalty in one native app on the $79 Growth plan, and Shopify Plus brands that want unlimited orders on the $399 Plus plan.
I wouldn't choose it if: You want every feature on your first plan. Love Loyalty adds VIP tiers, paid memberships and B2B programmes on its $79 Growth plan, while Otter includes every feature on every plan, the free one included.
The Love Loyalty review goes through every plan and what merchants say.
See Love Loyalty on the Shopify App Store
2. BON: Best for one flat price above 5,000 orders

BON charges by features, not by orders. Choose it when you're past 5,000 orders.
Why I like this app: Its replies impressed me most. BON answered all 22 reviews I read where customers shared a problem, and its $129 Growth plan includes unlimited orders. Setup took me 17 minutes.
Compared with Appstle: At 2,000 orders a month, BON costs $129/month on its Growth plan and offers VIP and B2B tiers, POS and an AI setup assistant, with unlimited orders. Appstle's Business plan costs $30 at that volume, so moving to BON raises your bill by $99 a month. Above 5,000 orders, Appstle moves you to its $100 Business Premium plan, which costs $175 at 10,000, while BON stays at $129. On my test store, BON used a floating loyalty button and referral pop-up, and its fonts needed changes. You'd give up Appstle's native pages and its link with Appstle Subscriptions.
Features:
- An AI setup assistant that suggests a widget theme on every plan
- Custom CSS and VIP tiers on the $129 Growth plan
- Shopify POS with a customer QR code on the $29 Basic plan
- Checkout redemption for Shopify Plus stores on the free plan
- Integrations with Klaviyo, Judge.me, PageFly and Shopify Flow
Pricing: BON charges by features:
- Free: 150 orders
- Starter: $15/month, 300 orders
- Basic: $29/month, 500 orders
- Growth: $129/month, unlimited orders
- Plus: custom quote, with API, SDK and Hydrogen
- Trial: 7 days, once per store
Reviews: BON has 5.0 stars from 1,987 reviews on the Shopify App Store. In February 2024, William Glen said Amazon orders count toward the order limit.
Best for: High-volume stores that want VIP and B2B tiers at a fixed monthly price.
I wouldn't choose it if: You're under 2,000 orders and want VIP tiers for less. BON's Growth plan costs $129. BLOY's Growth plan offers VIP tiers at $109 for 2,000 orders.
Want more detail first? Read the BON review.
See BON on the Shopify App Store
3. BLOY: Best for free migration and developer tools at $129

BLOY is a loyalty app with AI onboarding and API access on its Unlimited plan. I'd choose it when you need API access or headless support without Appstle's $300 Enterprise plan.
Why I like this app: The $129 Unlimited plan stood out for developers, with API access and headless support. BLOY's team also moves points, VIP tiers and customer history for free, on any plan. Setup took me 17 minutes. On my test store, members earned and redeemed on product pages, in the cart and in customer accounts, and it matched my fonts.
Compared with Appstle: At 2,000 orders a month, BLOY costs $109/month on its Growth plan and offers points, referrals, POS, VIP tiers, weekly reports and a multi-language storefront. Appstle's Business plan costs $30 at that volume, so moving to BLOY raises your bill by $79 a month. For developers, BLOY includes API access on its $129 Unlimited plan, against $300 on Appstle's Enterprise plan. On my test store, both looked native, but BLOY matched my fonts where Appstle's CSS clashed. You'd give up Appstle's link with Appstle Subscriptions and Appstle Membership.
Features:
- VIP tiers with entry rewards and custom perks on the $49 Growth plan
- Points, referrals and Shopify POS from the $10 Launch plan
- Weekly reports and a multi-language storefront on the $49 Growth plan
- Free migration of points, VIP tiers and customer history on any plan
- AI onboarding that drafts rewards, tiers and branding from your store data
- Integrations with Gorgias, Judge.me, Klaviyo, Mailchimp and Omnisend
Pricing: BLOY charges by all Shopify orders:
- Free: 200 orders, with no referral programme
- Launch: $10/month, 500 orders, then $15 per 100
- Growth: $49/month, 1,500 orders, then $12 per 100
- Unlimited: $129/month, 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100
- Custom: quote, for larger stores
- Trial: 14 days
Reviews: BLOY has 5.0 stars from 845 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise quick setup, but in March 2026, Bilge Brew said BLOY asked for a review in return for free-tier access.
Best for: Stores with a developer that want API access and a done-for-you migration.
I wouldn't choose it if: Your store goes past 4,500 orders a month. Every BLOY plan then becomes a custom quote. BON stays at $129 with unlimited orders.
My BLOY review covers its setup, support and verdict.
See BLOY on the Shopify App Store
4. Joy: Best for Recharge stores that want memberships and B2B tiers

Joy is a loyalty platform from Avada that works with Recharge Subscriptions. I'd choose it when you want paid memberships and wholesale tiers in the same app as your points.
Why I like this app: Its $129 Advanced plan impressed me most, with VIP and B2B tiers, paid memberships and wallet passes in the same plan. On my test store, the loyalty widget fit my theme and matched my fonts. Setup took me 20 minutes, because each Advanced module needed its own pass.
Compared with Appstle: At 2,000 orders a month, Joy costs $129/month on its Advanced plan and offers VIP and B2B tiers, paid memberships, POS and wallet passes. Appstle's Business plan costs $30 at that volume, so moving to Joy raises your bill by $99 a month, although you could drop Appstle's separate membership app. On my test store, Joy's widget matched my fonts. You'd give up Appstle's native pages, because Joy carries the programme in a widget.
Features:
- Points, referrals with fraud prevention and a loyalty widget on the free plan
- A loyalty page, points expiry and the AI copilot on the $29 Essential plan
- VIP and B2B tiers with a rule engine on the $129 Advanced plan
- Paid memberships and POS on the $129 Advanced plan
- Recharge, Klaviyo, Judge.me, Omnisend and Shopify Flow
Pricing: Joy charges by monthly orders:
- Starter: free, 250 orders
- Essential: $29/month, 500 orders, then $15 per 100
- Advanced: $129/month, 2,000 orders, then $10 per 100
- Ultimate: $499/month, 7,000 orders, then $5 per 100
- Trial: 14 days on the $29 Essential and $129 Advanced plans, 30 days on the $499 Ultimate plan
Reviews: Joy has 4.9 stars from 1,789 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews like how the widgets fit their themes and carts. In March 2025, Mamma Latte said the widget doesn't always load.
Best for: Subscription stores on Recharge that want paid memberships and B2B tiers alongside points.
I wouldn't choose it if: You want in-store loyalty on a small plan. Joy keeps POS on its $129 Advanced plan. BLOY includes POS from its $10 Launch plan.
See my full Joy review for its pros, cons and pricing.
See Joy on the Shopify App Store
5. CWILL: Best for multi-language stores on Seal Subscriptions

CWILL Loyalty & Referrals, once called Loloyal, comes from a vendor that also sells a reviews app. Choose it when you sell in several languages or run Seal Subscriptions.
Why I like this app: The language support stood out. CWILL names 20 languages, and its $19/month Essential plan includes multi-language support and Shopify POS. It also works with Seal Subscriptions. Setup took me 17 minutes.
Compared with Appstle: At 2,000 orders a month, CWILL costs $169/month on its Pro plan and offers VIP tiers, receipt scanning, POS, multi-language support and a customer account extension. Appstle's Business plan costs $30 at that volume, so moving to CWILL raises your bill by $139 a month. On my test store, CWILL used a loyalty widget where Appstle's pages looked native, and I used its custom CSS to line it up with my theme. You'd give up Appstle's white-glove migration, because CWILL's loyalty data moves by hand unless its team helps.
Features:
- Custom CSS on the free plan
- Theme and style customisation on the $19 Essential plan
- VIP tiers and receipt scanning on the Pro plan, from $69/month
- Points, referrals and rewards for reviews on the free plan
- Seal Subscriptions, Judge.me, PageFly and Klaviyo
I didn't find any AI features in its loyalty plans.
Pricing: CWILL charges by monthly orders on a slider:
- Free: 200 orders
- Essential: $19/month for 200 orders or $29/month for 500, then $20 per 100
- Pro: $69/month for 500 orders, $169/month for 2,000 and $229/month for 3,000
- Enterprise: custom quote, required above 3,000 orders
- Trial: 14 days
Reviews: CWILL has 4.9 stars from 800 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise setup help and translations. In November 2025, Dope Skin Co said it took 2 days to get answers, and CWILL replied.
Best for: Stores that sell in several languages or already use Seal Subscriptions or CWILL Product Reviews.
I wouldn't choose it if: You plan to sell paid memberships. CWILL doesn't include them on any plan. Joy includes them on its $129 Advanced plan.
For its plans and merchant feedback in full, read my CWILL review.
See CWILL on the Shopify App Store
6. Otter: Best for every feature on both plans

Otter Loyalty offers every feature on both of its plans. I'd choose it when you sell online only and want memberships without a second app.
Why I like this app: Otter doesn't split features by plan. VIP tiers, paid memberships and bonus events all come with the free Starter plan. On my test store, its widget and rewards page matched my fonts. Setup took me 16 minutes.
Compared with Appstle: At 2,000 orders a month, Otter costs $100/month on its Scaler plan and offers points, referrals, VIP tiers, paid memberships and bonus events. Appstle's Business plan costs $30 at that volume, so moving to Otter raises your bill by $70 a month, although you could drop Appstle's separate membership app. On my test store, its widget and rewards page matched my fonts. You'd give up Shopify POS and Appstle's 24/7 live chat, because Otter answers by email within 1 business day.
Features:
- Memberships, VIP tiers and bonus events on both plans
- Points for purchases, sign-ups, birthdays and product reviews
- Rewards as discounts, gift cards, free shipping or free products
- A rewards page and points on product pages
- Klaviyo and Judge.me integrations
I didn't find any AI features in it.
Pricing: Otter charges by monthly orders, with overage on both plans:
- Starter: free, 100 orders, then $10 per 100
- Scaler: $15/month, 300 orders, then $5 per 100
- Trial: none, but Starter is free
Reviews: Otter has 4.6 stars from 22 reviews on the Shopify App Store. In October 2024, Fashion Hub Club said the app sent 20 emails in 10 minutes, and the new owners replied.
Best for: Online-only stores that want VIP tiers and paid memberships without comparing plan tables.
I wouldn't choose it if: You sell in person. Otter has no POS feature. CWILL includes Shopify POS from its $19 Essential plan.
See Otter on the Shopify App Store
7. SC Loyalty: Best for stores with few loyalty members and many orders

SC Loyalty, formerly Loyalty Points by Bold, now belongs to Shop Circle. I'd choose it when you have many orders but a small group of loyalty members, because it charges by members.
Why I like this app: Its billing model is the main difference. SC Loyalty counts loyalty members, not orders, and every paid plan has a spending cap. The free plan includes Shopify POS, and the $29 Starter plan adds 3 customer tiers and referrals. Setup took me 16 minutes, mostly on points, tiers and referrals.
Compared with Appstle: SC Loyalty charges by loyalty members, not orders. Its $29 Starter plan offers 3 customer tiers, referrals and POS for up to 500 members, then $0.05 per member, capped at $499. Appstle's Business plan costs $30 at 2,000 orders, so SC Loyalty only costs about the same while few customers join. On my test store, its widget sat on top of the theme and didn't match my fonts. You'd give up Appstle's native pages and its link with Appstle Subscriptions.
Features:
- Points for sign-ups, purchases, social shares and birthdays
- 3 customer tiers, referrals and buy with points on the $29 Starter plan
- Unlimited rewards, campaigns and customer tiers on the $199 Growth plan
- Unlimited custom rewards on the $499 Enterprise plan
- Shopify POS integration on the free plan
- Works with Shopify Flow and apps that use customer tags
I didn't find any AI features in it.
Pricing: SC Loyalty charges by loyalty members:
- Free: 200 members
- Starter: $29/month, 500 members, then $0.05 per member, capped at $499
- Growth: $199/month, 5,000 members, then $0.03 per member, capped at $999
- Enterprise: $499/month, 25,000 members, then $0.02 per member, capped at $1,999
- Trial: 30 days
Reviews: SC Loyalty has 4.4 stars from 71 reviews on the Shopify App Store, the lowest rating on this list. In March 2025, Neha Assar Artistry said customers couldn't redeem rewards.
Best for: Stores with many orders and a small group of loyalty members.
I wouldn't choose it if: You have a large customer base already earning points. Every member who joins adds to SC Loyalty's bill. BON's Growth plan costs $129 whatever your volume.
The SC Loyalty review goes through every plan and what merchants say.
See SC Loyalty on the Shopify App Store
How do you choose between Appstle Loyalty and these alternatives?
Name the reason you're leaving, then confirm that the new app fixes it at a price you can pay. These 4 questions help.
Start with the problem that's making you leave. When it's subscription or VIP logic, ask the developer to show you the exact rule before you install.
Next, list the Appstle features you use. A subscription app points to Joy for Recharge or CWILL for Seal, and paid memberships point to Love Loyalty, Joy or Otter.
Then check whether it matches your theme without code. Love Loyalty, BLOY, Joy and Otter matched my fonts with no CSS.
Finally, read what recent reviews say about support. In the reviews I read, BON answered every customer who shared a problem.
Choose Love Loyalty when you've outgrown points and VIP tiers on Appstle. At 2,000 orders a month, it costs $79/month on its Growth plan and offers POS earning and redemption, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes that show each customer's points balance and VIP tier. That's more than Appstle's $30 Business plan, so you're paying for memberships and wallet passes. For a bill that stays flat however many orders you take, choose its $399 Plus plan with unlimited orders.
Choose BON to keep a flat price as you grow. Stay on Appstle when price matters most and its subscription order points work for you.
Will an Appstle Loyalty alternative cost you less?
No at 2,000 orders. When I priced each app at that volume, Appstle's Business plan cost $30, and every order-based alternative cost more. SC Loyalty charges by loyalty members instead.
Say your store takes 2,000 orders a month. Appstle costs $30/month on its Business plan. These alternatives cost:
- Love Loyalty: $79/month on Growth
- Otter: $100/month on Scaler
- BLOY: $109/month on Growth
- BON: $129/month on Growth
- Joy: $129/month on Advanced
- CWILL: $169/month on Pro
SC Loyalty's $29 Starter plan includes 500 members, then $0.05 each, so its price depends on how many customers join.
Over 2 years at that level, Appstle costs about $720, and Love Loyalty about $1,896.
The answer changes at high volume. At 10,000 orders, Appstle's Business Premium plan costs $175, while BON's Growth plan still costs $129. Ask each developer which orders or members count.
Does Appstle make you buy a second app for paid memberships?
Yes. Appstle sends membership and wholesale tiers to its separate Appstle Membership app. When I checked the plans, Love Loyalty, Joy and Otter included paid memberships in the same subscription.
Love Loyalty includes them on its $79 Growth plan, with a 1.8% fee. Joy includes them on its $129 Advanced plan, and Otter on both plans, including the free one.
Add up what you pay Appstle across every app you've installed from it, then compare that total with the alternative's price.
Can you keep VIP tiers at around $30 when you leave Appstle?
Only partly. At 2,000 orders, SC Loyalty's $29 Starter plan comes closest, but it charges by members and stops at 3 tiers. Among order-based plans with VIP tiers, I found Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan the lowest.
At lower volumes, the gap closes. Otter includes VIP tiers on its free plan for 100 orders and on its $15 Scaler plan for 300.
Before you leave, write down each tier's threshold, perks and renewal period.
When does it make sense to stay on Appstle Loyalty?
I'd stay on Appstle if you're under 5,000 orders, price matters most and you use Appstle Subscriptions without the redemption gap.
Appstle has the Built for Shopify badge. In 2024, City Survivor chose it as the only loyalty app that gives points on subscription orders. Every plan includes 24/7 live chat and data exports.
As my baseline, Appstle took me 18 minutes to set up. Its pages looked native, but its CSS clashed with my theme.
Appstle is free for 250 orders, and paid plans have a 14-day trial. See Appstle Loyalty on the Shopify App Store.
Before you leave, ask Appstle's support whether your bug has a fix date, because no app here matches its price.
How do you move from Appstle Loyalty to another app?
BLOY's team handles migration for free on any plan, and Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan includes it. Otter imports customer data, and CWILL's team helps with complex moves. Customers and orders stay in Shopify, but balances and tiers live in Appstle.
I'd save these from Appstle before you change anything:
- Every earning rule, reward, VIP tier and referral setting
- Each customer's points balance, tier and store credit, using Appstle's data export
- Your loyalty page, widget and emails, as screenshots
- Any links between Appstle Loyalty and Appstle Subscriptions or Membership
Use these steps with any of the apps:
- Export your points balances and write down your programme settings.
- Install the new app on its free plan or trial, and set it up on a copy of your theme.
- Import balances and tiers, then check a few customers by hand.
- Set up the same earning rules and rewards you had on Appstle, then check it on your phone.
- Upgrade only if it does the job, then publish the theme.
- Remove Appstle, its app embed and any page builder blocks, before your next billing date.
Setup took me between 15 and 20 minutes per app, before any import.
After you uninstall, check your theme for leftover Appstle code and CSS. Keep your Appstle export for at least one billing cycle.
What changes in unusual situations?
When I priced 10,000 orders, Appstle's Business Premium plan cost $175. BON's Growth plan costs $129 at any volume, and Love Loyalty's Plus plan costs $399 with unlimited orders. Otter's Scaler plan costs about $500, while CWILL and BLOY move you to a custom quote.
For B2B, Love Loyalty includes B2B loyalty on its $79 Growth plan, and BON and Joy include B2B tiers on their $129 plans. Appstle sends wholesale tiers to its membership app.
Which Appstle Loyalty alternative would I start with?
I'd start with Love Loyalty, because it offers VIP tiers, POS, paid memberships and B2B loyalty for up to 2,000 orders at $79/month, and unlimited orders on its $399 Plus plan. Choose BON past 5,000 orders when you want B2B tiers at a flat $129. Choose Joy when you run Recharge and want memberships in the loyalty app. Stay on Appstle when price matters most and its subscription points work for you.
Install your 2 finalists, set up the same programme on a copy of your theme and compare them before you move customers.
My guide to the best Shopify loyalty apps compares the wider category.
What do merchants often ask about Appstle Loyalty alternatives?
Which Appstle Loyalty alternative is best for paid memberships?
Love Loyalty is the closest match, with paid memberships, B2B loyalty and wallet passes on its $79 Growth plan for up to 2,000 orders. Its $399 Plus plan adds unlimited orders.
Is there a free alternative to Appstle Loyalty?
Yes. Love Loyalty's free plan includes 150 orders a month. Otter's free Starter plan includes VIP tiers and paid memberships for 100 orders, then $10 per 100. Joy is free for 250 orders, and BLOY for 200.
How much does Appstle Loyalty cost in 2026?
Appstle is free for 250 orders. Starter costs $10/month, Business $30, Business Premium $100 and Enterprise $300.
Is Appstle Loyalty a good app?
Yes, with 5.0 stars from 1,482 reviews. An alternative makes more sense when you hit recurring bugs or need memberships in the loyalty app.
Can you move your points from Appstle Loyalty to another app?
Yes. Appstle includes data exports on every plan, and BLOY moves points and tiers for free. Your customers and orders stay in Shopify.
Do Appstle Loyalty alternatives slow down a store?
Any loyalty app adds code, but the total number of apps matters more than any single one. Test any app on your own store before and after you install it.

