Best Essent Loyalty alternatives reviewed in 2027
Short answer: It depends on why you're leaving Essent Loyalty. When you want paid memberships or wallet passes, choose Love Loyalty, because it offers a points programme, VIP tiers, POS, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes for up to 2,000 orders at $79/month, the same price as Essent, and unlimited orders for $399/month. Stay on Essent Loyalty when you take 2,000 to 5,000 orders a month and want the bill to stay at $79.
Essent Loyalty keeps the bill simple. Its Growth plan costs $79/month for up to 5,000 orders, and its free plan includes a VIP tier. But it doesn't offer paid memberships or multi-currency loyalty, and it doesn't state what its Growth plan costs above 5,000 orders.
So I installed 7 Essent Loyalty alternatives on a test store. Below, you'll find what each one is built for, what it costs as of November 2026 and what you'd give up by moving.
Why do merchants look for an Essent Loyalty alternative?
From what customers shared in the reviews I read, few merchants have a problem with Essent. The ones who do point to missing features and one problem with editing blocks. When I checked its plans, I also found the price above 5,000 orders wasn't stated.
Missing features came up most. In January 2026, Myeomi said it has no multi-currency loyalty. When I went through its plans, I didn't find paid memberships, B2B loyalty or wallet passes either. Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan offers all three, and Otter offers memberships on both of its plans.
I'd also check the price at high volume. Essent's $79 Growth plan includes up to 5,000 orders, and the price above that isn't stated. Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan and BON's $129 Growth plan both include unlimited orders.
Day-to-day control came up once. In September 2025, Loki & Me said block changes didn't update until they re-added the block, and Essent replied 10 days later.
These come from 3 of the 496 reviews Essent has, so most merchants don't report them.
Which Essent Loyalty alternatives made my shortlist?
I picked apps that do the same job as Essent Loyalty, rated 4.4 to 5.0. These 7 alternatives made my shortlist:
- Love Loyalty: an all-in-one native loyalty app with fixed pricing
- CWILL: review rewards on every plan and receipt scanning on its Pro plan ($69 to $229/month)
- BLOY: free migration by its own team and 20 languages
- Otter: VIP tiers and memberships free, online only
- SC Loyalty: POS on the free plan and a 30-day trial
- S Loyalty: a plain points programme with pay-with-points rewards
- BON: VIP tiers and unlimited orders for $129/month
I've put each app's rating, starting price and how it charges in this table, with Essent Loyalty first as the baseline:
| App | Rating | Starting price | Charges by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Essent Loyalty | 5.0 from 496 reviews | Free, then $10/month | Loyalty orders, moving up a plan at each cap |
| Love Loyalty | 5.0 from 428 reviews | Free, then $12/month | Monthly orders |
| CWILL | 4.9 from 800 reviews | Free, then $19/month | Orders, with overage |
| BLOY | 5.0 from 845 reviews | Free, then $10/month | All Shopify orders, with overage |
| Otter | 4.6 from 22 reviews | Free, then $15/month | Orders, with overage on both plans |
| SC Loyalty | 4.4 from 71 reviews | Free, then $29/month | Loyalty members, with capped overage |
| S Loyalty | 4.4 from 235 reviews | Free, then $19.99/month | Order bands, averaged over 12 months |
| BON | 5.0 from 1,987 reviews | Free, then $15/month | Features, with unlimited orders on its $129 Growth plan |
Prices as of November 2026.
When missing features are your reason for leaving, compare Love Loyalty and Otter first.
How did I review these Essent Loyalty alternatives?
I installed each app on a test store, then went through every plan and what customers shared in their newest reviews. I used Essent Loyalty as the baseline for each comparison.
I looked at these details for each app:
- Points and redemption: where customers redeem
- VIP tiers and Shopify POS: which plan includes them
- AI features: what AI does in each app
- Integrations: Klaviyo, Judge.me, Shopify Flow and similar tools
- Setup: how long each app took me to get a points programme live
- Design: how it looked on my test store and whether it matched my theme
- Speed: what one more app adds to a store that already has 10 to 15 of them
- Pricing: how each app charges, its plan limits and overage
- Reviews: what customers shared in their newest reviews, including about support
- Moving: what you can bring across from Essent Loyalty
Love Loyalty comes first because it offers VIP tiers, POS, bonus campaigns and paid memberships for up to 2,000 orders at $79/month. Its Plus plan includes unlimited orders for $399. The order of the other 6 isn't a ranking.
I don't give speed scores, because they depend on your theme and your other apps. Your own store is the better test, and all 7 apps have a free plan or trial.
What did I find when I compared them with Essent Loyalty?
These alternatives fall into 2 groups. Love Loyalty, BLOY, Otter, SC Loyalty and BON focus on the core loyalty experience: points, VIP tiers, referrals and rewards in one app. CWILL and S Loyalty spread the job across other apps: CWILL ties its rewards to its own product reviews and helpdesk apps, and S Loyalty hands referrals to ReferralCandy.
I liked the first group most. You aren't paying for a reviews or referral app on top, or for tools you already run elsewhere. I've also found that when a loyalty programme depends on other apps to work, it's the part that gets compromised. On my test store, ReferralCandy added its own install and settings to S Loyalty, while Love Loyalty had points, VIP tiers and referrals live in 15 minutes.
I found 4 main differences from Essent Loyalty. The apps differ on which ones they include, so check which you need before you compare prices:
- How the bill grows: Essent stops at $79/month up to 5,000 orders. Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan includes up to 2,000 orders, and its $399 Plus plan includes unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume. BON's $129 Growth plan includes unlimited orders too, while BLOY moves to a custom quote above 4,500 orders.
- Price at 2,000 orders a month: Essent charges $79 on its Growth plan. Love Loyalty charges the same $79 on Growth, Otter $100 on Scaler, BLOY $109 on Growth, BON $129 on Growth and CWILL $169 on Pro. S Loyalty needs a custom quote from $199.99, and SC Loyalty charges by members instead, from $29 for 500 on its Starter plan.
- Shopify POS: Essent includes it from $10/month. SC Loyalty includes it free, BLOY from $10/month, Love Loyalty's Professional plan from $12 and BON from $29. Otter and S Loyalty have none.
- Free plans: Essent's includes 250 orders and one VIP tier, and pauses at the cap. BLOY's includes 200 orders, Love Loyalty's and BON's 150, and Otter's 100 with every feature.
I also found these differences in how the apps work:
- AI features: Essent has none. Love Loyalty has an AI programme suggestion on its $79 Growth plan, BLOY AI onboarding and BON an AI setup assistant. The others have none.
- Setup: the apps took me 15 to 17 minutes each, against 16 for Essent, so setup time shouldn't decide the choice.
- Design: Love Loyalty and BLOY looked native on my test store, like Essent, while CWILL, Otter, SC Loyalty, S Loyalty and BON used widgets. Love Loyalty, BLOY and Otter matched my fonts. CWILL, S Loyalty and BON needed changes, while SC Loyalty didn't match.
- Speed: the total number of apps matters more than one more widget.
What are the best Essent Loyalty alternatives?
Love Loyalty is my top pick for Essent Loyalty stores that want paid memberships or wallet passes at the same price. For Shopify stores, I'd choose its $79 Growth plan, which includes paid memberships, wallet passes and B2B loyalty for up to 2,000 orders a month. For Shopify Plus brands, its $399 Plus plan offers everything in Growth with unlimited orders.
BLOY comes next for stores that want their points moved for them at no cost. The other 5 suit stores that want review rewards (CWILL), free memberships online (Otter), POS on a free plan (SC Loyalty), a plain points programme (S Loyalty) and a flat price above 5,000 orders (BON). At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs $79, the same as Essent's Growth plan, while Otter costs $100, BLOY $109, BON $129, CWILL $169 and S Loyalty a custom quote from $199.99. SC Loyalty charges by loyalty members instead of orders.
1. Love Loyalty: Best for an all-in-one native loyalty app with fixed pricing

Love Loyalty is an all-in-one native loyalty app for Shopify and Shopify Plus brands. It offers points, VIP tiers, referrals and paid memberships in one app, at a published monthly price. I'd choose it when you want paid memberships, B2B loyalty or wallet passes, which Essent doesn't offer.
Why I like this app: Redeeming points in the cart impressed me most. Customers spent their points there in 2 steps, without opening a pop-up widget, much as they did on Essent. That keeps the reward in front of them at the moment they pay.
It also looked the most native of any app in my test, Essent included. Points showed on the product page, the loyalty page sat inside my theme and every placement used my theme's fonts and colours. So I didn't write any CSS, and the programme looked like part of my store from the start.
Setup took me 15 minutes, the fastest of the apps I tested, against 16 for Essent.
Compared with Essent Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty costs $79/month on its Growth plan and offers a points programme, VIP tiers, POS, bonus campaigns, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes. Essent's Growth plan costs the same $79 at that volume, so your bill doesn't change, but you add paid memberships, B2B programmes and wallet passes.
Above 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty costs $399/month on its Plus plan and offers everything in Growth, API access and unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume. Essent's $79 Growth plan includes up to 5,000 orders, so Essent costs less between 2,000 and 5,000 orders, and above that it doesn't state a price.
But you'd give up Essent's 5,000 orders at $79 and its free VIP tier. Check your monthly orders before you move.
Features:
- Paid memberships, with perks you set for members, on the $79 Growth plan
- Apple and Google Wallet passes that show each customer's points balance and VIP tier, on the $79 Growth plan
- B2B loyalty with separate earning and redemption rules per customer segment, on the $79 Growth plan
- Points, referrals and cart redemption on the free plan
- POS, a loyalty page, 20+ placements and points expiry on the $12 Professional plan
- Integrations with Klaviyo, Recharge, Shopify Flow and 30+ other apps on the $12 Professional plan
- VIP tiers, rewards for activities, bonus campaigns and AI programme suggestions on the $79 Growth plan
- Checkout extensions, API access and unlimited orders on the $399 Plus plan
Pricing: Love Loyalty charges by monthly orders:
- Free: 150 orders a month
- Professional: $12/month, 500 orders
- Growth: $79/month, up to 2,000 orders
- Plus: $399/month, unlimited orders
- Trial: 14 days
Reviews: Love Loyalty has 5.0 stars from 428 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise fast live chat and smooth moves from Smile.
Best for: Shopify stores that want paid memberships, B2B programmes and wallet passes in one native app on the $79 Growth plan, and Shopify Plus brands that want unlimited orders on the $399 Plus plan.
I wouldn't choose it if: You want every feature on your first plan. Love Loyalty adds VIP tiers, paid memberships and B2B programmes on its $79 Growth plan, while Otter includes every feature on every plan.
For its plans and merchant feedback in full, read my Love Loyalty review.
See Love Loyalty on the Shopify App Store
2. CWILL: Best for review rewards and receipt scanning

CWILL Loyalty & Referrals, first called Loloyal, comes from a vendor that also sells product reviews. Choose it when you want review rewards.
Why I like this app: Review rewards stood out. Every plan, including Free, rewards customers for reviews and connects to CWILL Product Reviews. Its Pro plan ($69 to $229/month) adds receipt scanning. Setup took me 17 minutes.
Compared with Essent Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, CWILL costs $169/month on its Pro plan and offers VIP tiers, review rewards, receipt scanning, POS and a customer account extension. Essent's Growth plan costs $79 at that volume, so moving to CWILL raises your bill by $90 a month. On my test store, CWILL used a loyalty widget, where Essent looked native, and I used the custom CSS that comes with every plan to line it up with my store. You'd give up Essent's free VIP tier and its 5,000 orders at $79.
Features:
- Receipt scanning on the Pro plan, from $69/month
- Rewards for custom actions and API access on the Enterprise plan, a custom quote
- Points and reward expiry on the Pro plan, from $69/month
- Product and shipping rewards on the $19 Essential plan
- More than 10 ways to earn points on the free plan
- Klaviyo and Omnisend integrations on the Pro plan, from $69/month
I didn't find any AI features in its loyalty plans.
Pricing: CWILL charges by monthly orders on a slider:
- Free: 200 orders a month
- Essential: $19/month for 200 orders or $29/month for 500, then $20 per 100 orders
- Pro: $69/month for 500 orders, $169/month for 2,000 and $229/month for 3,000
- Enterprise: custom quote, required above 3,000 orders
- Trial: 14 days
Reviews: CWILL has 4.9 stars from 800 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise setup help and translations. wimsical wardrobe (2 stars, January 2026) says most functions were locked for them, and CWILL replied.
Best for: Stores already on CWILL Product Reviews.
I wouldn't choose it if: You sell more than 3,000 orders a month. CWILL needs a custom quote there, while BON's Growth plan stays at $129/month with unlimited orders.
The CWILL review goes through every plan and what merchants say.
See CWILL on the Shopify App Store
3. BLOY: Best for free migration in 20 languages

BLOY is a loyalty app whose team moves your programme across for you. I'd choose it when you want to leave Essent without rebuilding balances by hand.
Why I like this app: Free migration stood out. BLOY's team moves points, VIP tiers and customer history at no cost, on any plan. Setup took me 17 minutes, mostly spent checking what AI onboarding drafted from my store data. The result looked native and matched my fonts, as Essent did.
Compared with Essent Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, BLOY costs $109/month on its Growth plan and offers VIP tiers, points on product and cart pages, POS, 20+ languages and free migration. Essent's Growth plan costs $79 at that volume, so moving to BLOY raises your bill by $30 a month, and above 4,500 orders BLOY moves you to a custom quote. On my test store, BLOY looked native and matched my fonts, as Essent did. You'd give up Essent's free VIP tier, and you can't remove the watermark on BLOY's free plan.
Features:
- Product, cart and post-purchase points on the $49 Growth plan
- Limited-time offers and a 2x points order booster on the $49 Growth plan
- API access and headless support on the $129 Unlimited plan
- Shopify POS and Shopify Flow on the $10 Launch plan
- AI onboarding that builds rewards, tiers and branding from store data
- Judge.me, Klaviyo and Omnisend
Pricing: BLOY charges by all Shopify orders:
- Free: 200 orders a month
- Launch: $10/month, 500 orders, then $15 per 100 orders
- Growth: $49/month, 1,500 orders, then $12 per 100 orders
- Unlimited: $129/month, 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100 orders
- Trial: 14 days
Reviews: BLOY has 5.0 stars from 845 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise migrations. HADASITY (4 stars, January 2026) hit some problems moving in but praised the support.
Best for: Stores that want their Essent balances and tiers moved for them, in the same languages.
I wouldn't choose it if: You want paid memberships. I didn't find them on BLOY's plans, while Otter includes them on both of its plans.
Want more detail first? Read the BLOY review.
See BLOY on the Shopify App Store
4. Otter: Best for free memberships, online only

Otter Loyalty offers every feature on both of its plans. Choose it when you sell online only and want VIP tiers and memberships on a free plan.
Why I like this app: Otter doesn't split features by plan, so VIP tiers and memberships come with the free Starter plan. Setup took me 16 minutes, the same as Essent. Its widget and rewards page fit my store and matched my fonts.
Compared with Essent Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, Otter costs $100/month on its Scaler plan and offers points, referrals, VIP tiers, memberships and points on product pages. Essent's Growth plan costs $79 at that volume, so moving to Otter raises your bill by $21 a month. On my test store, Otter used a widget with nudges, where Essent looked native. You'd give up POS, Shopify Flow and live support.
Features:
- VIP tiers with custom perks on the free Starter plan
- Memberships and two-sided referrals at no monthly fee on the free Starter plan
- Points on product pages, a rewards page and automated emails
- Reports and customer profiles with data export
- Points expiry with product and customer eligibility rules
I didn't find any AI features in it.
Pricing: Otter charges by monthly orders, with overage on both plans:
- Starter: free, 100 orders a month, then $10 per 100 orders
- Scaler: $15/month, 300 orders, then $5 per 100 orders
- Trial: none listed, but Starter needs no card
Reviews: Otter has 4.6 stars from 22 reviews on the Shopify App Store, and the newest dates from May 2025. Fashion Hub Club (1 star, October 2024) says the app sent 20 emails in 10 minutes, and the new owners replied.
Best for: Online stores under 300 orders a month that want memberships and VIP tiers without a paid plan.
I wouldn't choose it if: You take payments at a till. Otter has no POS, while SC Loyalty includes POS on its free plan.
See Otter on the Shopify App Store
5. SC Loyalty: Best for POS on a free plan

SC Loyalty Rewards, once called Loyalty Points by Bold, includes POS on its free plan. I'd choose it when you sell in person and don't want a paid plan yet.
Why I like this app: POS on the free plan stood out. SC Loyalty's Free plan includes 200 members and POS, and every paid plan has a 30-day trial, the longest in this list. Setup took me 16 minutes, the same as Essent.
Compared with Essent Loyalty: SC Loyalty charges by loyalty members, not orders. Its $29 Starter plan offers buy-with-points, referrals and 3 customer tiers for 500 members, then $0.05 per extra member. Essent's Growth plan costs $79 at 2,000 orders, so SC Loyalty costs less only while you have fewer than about 1,500 members. On my test store, its widget sat on top of the theme and didn't match my store, where Essent looked native. You'd give up Essent's unlimited VIP tiers, because SC Loyalty's Starter plan stops at 3 customer tiers.
Features:
- POS integration, 3 rewards and 1 active campaign on the free plan
- Buy with points, referrals and 3 customer tiers from the $29 Starter plan
- Shopify Flow, custom emails and branding on the $29 Starter plan
- Unlimited customer tiers and a custom logo upload on the $199 Growth plan
- 30-day free trial on every paid plan
I didn't find any AI features in it.
Pricing: SC Loyalty charges by loyalty members, with capped overage:
- Free: up to 200 members
- Starter: $29/month, 500 members, then $0.05 per member, capped at $499
- Growth: $199/month, 5,000 members, then $0.03 per member, capped at $999
- Enterprise: $499/month, 25,000 members, then $0.02 per member, capped at $1,999
- Trial: 30 days
Reviews: SC Loyalty has 4.4 stars from 71 reviews on the Shopify App Store. RCCS Store (5 stars, March 2026) praises live help. Neha Assar Artistry (1 star, March 2025) says customers couldn't redeem rewards.
Best for: Stores with a small, loyal customer base and a till that want POS loyalty without a paid plan.
I wouldn't choose it if: Your customer list is large compared with your orders. Member-based pricing counts every customer you give points to, so BON, whose $129 Growth plan includes unlimited orders, is easier to predict.
My SC Loyalty review covers its setup, support and verdict.
See SC Loyalty on the Shopify App Store
6. S Loyalty: Best for pay-with-points and nothing more

S Loyalty is a points app with pay-with-points rewards and no VIP tiers. Choose it when you want a points programme with pay-with-points rewards and no extras.
Why I like this app: Its reward types include the basics. Customers can pay with points, get free shipping or take a fixed or percentage discount. Setup took me 16 minutes.
Compared with Essent Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, S Loyalty moves you to its Higher Volume plan, a custom quote from $199.99/month, and offers pay-with-points, free shipping and discount rewards with bonus point campaigns. Essent's Growth plan costs $79 at that volume, so moving to S Loyalty raises your bill by at least $120 a month. On my test store, it showed a rewards tab, where Essent looked native, and ReferralCandy added its own install and settings. You'd give up VIP tiers, POS and built-in referrals, because S Loyalty has none of them.
Features:
- Pay with Points, fixed and percentage discounts and free shipping on paid plans
- Welcome bonus and points expiry on the $19.99 Basic plan
- Embedded widget and Signature theme on the $39.99 Standard plan
- Customer exclusion for wholesale groups on the $69.99 Pro plan
- Works with Langify, Weglot and ReferralCandy
I didn't find any AI features in it.
Pricing: S Loyalty charges by order bands, using your average over the last 12 months:
- Free: 100 orders a month, 3 fixed-amount rewards
- Basic: $19.99/month, 50 orders
- Standard: $39.99/month, 200 orders
- Pro: $69.99/month, 350 orders
- Premium: $119.99/month, up to 1,000 orders
- Higher Volume: custom quote, from $199.99/month, above 1,000 orders
- Trial: 14 days
Reviews: S Loyalty has 4.4 stars from 235 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Long-term users who left reviews praise its stability. Karen's Botanicals (1 star, November 2026) says they couldn't get help moving their programme from BigCommerce to Shopify.
Best for: Stores that only want points for purchases and pay-with-points rewards.
I wouldn't choose it if: VIP tiers matter to you. S Loyalty has none, while CWILL offers them on its Pro plan from $69/month.
See S Loyalty on the Shopify App Store
7. BON: Best for a published flat price above 5,000 orders

BON is a loyalty app that charges by features, not by orders. Choose it when you expect to outgrow the 5,000 orders on Essent's $79 Growth plan.
Why I like this app: The pricing impressed me most. BON's Growth plan costs $129/month with unlimited orders, so 10,000 orders cost the same as 2,000. Setup took me 17 minutes, most of it spent reviewing what the AI setup assistant suggested.
Compared with Essent Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, BON costs $129/month on its Growth plan and offers VIP and B2B tiers, points on product pages, POS and unlimited orders. Essent's Growth plan costs $79 at that volume, so moving to BON raises your bill by $50 a month. Above 5,000 orders, Essent doesn't publish a price, while BON stays at $129. On my test store, BON used a floating loyalty button, where Essent looked native, and the fonts needed changes. You'd give up Essent's free VIP tier and its 5,000 orders at $79.
Features:
- B2B tiers for wholesale customers on the $129 Growth plan
- One flat price with no order limit on the $129 Growth plan
- API access, an SDK and Hydrogen support on the Plus plan, a custom quote
- Shopify POS and 250+ displayed languages on the $29 Basic plan
- AI suggestions for your points strategy and widget theme on every plan
Pricing: BON charges by features:
- Free: 150 orders a month
- Starter: $15/month, 300 orders
- Basic: $29/month, 500 orders
- Growth: $129/month, unlimited orders
- Trial: 7 days, once per store
Reviews: BON has 5.0 stars from 1,987 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise fast support. Trail Threads Co. (1 star, July 2024) says the widget blocked the mobile checkout button, and BON replied.
Best for: Stores heading past 5,000 orders a month that want a known loyalty bill.
I wouldn't choose it if: You want to test a paid plan for longer. BON gives one 7-day trial per store, while SC Loyalty gives 30 days on every paid plan.
See my full BON review for its pros, cons and pricing.
See BON on the Shopify App Store
How do you choose between Essent Loyalty and these alternatives?
Name the reason you're leaving, then confirm that the new app fixes it at a price you can pay. These 5 questions will shorten the list.
Start with the gap that made you look. Paid memberships point to Love Loyalty or Otter, and an unstated price above 5,000 orders points to BON.
Then list the Essent features you use. BLOY matches its 20 languages and its POS from $10/month.
Next, check each app against your theme. Essent looked native and matched my fonts on my test store. Love Loyalty and BLOY did the same, while SC Loyalty didn't match.
Look at the rest of your store too. A till rules out Otter and S Loyalty.
Finally, read the last 3 months of reviews for support. In the recent reviews I read, merchants praise support at Love Loyalty, BLOY and BON.
Choose Love Loyalty when you want paid memberships or wallet passes without paying more than you do on Essent. At 2,000 orders a month, it costs $79/month on its Growth plan, the same as Essent's $79 Growth plan, and offers paid memberships whose benefits apply to the same order, Apple and Google Wallet passes, VIP tiers and POS. Shopify Plus brands that want the price to stay put as orders grow can choose its $399 Plus plan with unlimited orders.
Choose BLOY when you want your points moved for you. Choose BON when you expect to pass 5,000 orders. Stay on Essent when you're between 1,500 and 5,000 orders and want the bill to stay at $79.
Will an Essent Loyalty alternative cost you less?
No. When I priced each app at 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty cost the same as Essent's $79 Growth plan and every other alternative cost more.
Essent counts only loyalty orders and has no overage, so its 2,000 orders may be fewer than 2,000 store orders on other apps.
Say your store takes 2,000 orders a month. Essent costs $79/month on its Growth plan. These alternatives cost:
- Love Loyalty: $79/month on its Growth plan
- Otter: $100/month on its Scaler plan ($15 plus overage)
- BLOY: $109/month on its Growth plan ($49 plus overage)
- BON: $129/month on its Growth plan
- CWILL: $169/month on its Pro plan
- S Loyalty: a custom quote on its Higher Volume plan, from $199.99/month
SC Loyalty charges by loyalty members instead. Its $29 Starter plan includes 500 members, and its $199 Growth plan 5,000.
Over 2 years at that level, Essent and Love Loyalty each cost about $1,896 on monthly billing. Otter, the next lowest, costs about $2,400.
At 5,000 orders, nothing here beats Essent's $79/month. BON's Growth plan costs $129/month there, Love Loyalty's Plus plan $399 with unlimited orders, and the rest cost more or need a quote. Above 5,000 orders, Essent doesn't publish a price, while BON stays at $129/month.
Can you keep a free VIP tier when you leave Essent Loyalty?
Yes, with Otter, which includes VIP tiers free up to 100 orders a month.
On the other apps, VIP tiers need a paid plan. At 2,000 orders a month, that's $79/month on Love Loyalty's Growth plan, $109/month on BLOY's Growth plan and $169/month on CWILL's Pro plan.
Before you leave, write down each tier's threshold and perks.
When does it make sense to stay on Essent Loyalty?
I'd stay on Essent Loyalty if you're between 1,500 and 5,000 orders a month and want the bill to stop at $79.
Essent has 5.0 stars from 496 reviews and a Built for Shopify badge. Setup took me 16 minutes on my test store. Points sat on product cards, customers redeemed in one click in the cart and the styling matched my theme.
At the low end, its Starter plan costs $10/month with POS, and every paid plan has a 14-day trial. See Essent Loyalty on the Shopify App Store.
Before you leave, check whether you'll pass 5,000 orders soon.
How do you move from Essent Loyalty to another app?
No app on this list advertises a direct Essent import. BLOY's team migrates points, tiers and history free on any plan, and Love Loyalty offers free migration on its $79 Growth plan. Your customers, orders and any native store credit stay in Shopify.
I'd save these from Essent before you change anything:
- Every earning rule, reward and VIP tier
- Your widget, loyalty page and account block styling, as screenshots
- Point balances and tiers, as a CSV export
- Klaviyo and Omnisend flows that use Essent data
Use these steps with any of the apps:
- Export your points balances and write down your setup.
- Install the new app on its free plan or trial, and set it up on a copy of your theme.
- Import balances, then check a few customer accounts by hand.
- Set up the same rewards and tiers you have on Essent, so you're comparing like with like, then check them on your phone.
- Upgrade only if it does the job, then publish the theme.
- Remove Essent, its app embed and any theme blocks, before your next billing date.
Essent uses Shopify's own store credit, so check customer balances in Shopify after the move.
After you uninstall, check your theme for leftover Essent blocks, and keep your export for at least a year.
What changes in unusual situations?
Seasonal volume and B2B change the answer most.
Seasonal peaks favour Essent up to 5,000 orders. Above that, BON's $129 Growth plan and Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan both include unlimited orders, while BLOY needs a custom quote above 4,500 orders.
B2B stores should look at Love Loyalty, which includes B2B loyalty on its $79 Growth plan, or BON, whose $129 Growth plan adds B2B tiers.
Which Essent Loyalty alternative would I start with?
I'd start with Love Loyalty, because its $79 Growth plan offers VIP tiers, paid memberships, B2B loyalty and wallet passes for up to 2,000 orders, at the same price as Essent's Growth plan. For Shopify Plus brands, I'd choose its $399 Plus plan with unlimited orders. Choose BLOY when you want your points moved for you, and BON when you expect to pass 5,000 orders. Stay on Essent if you're between 1,500 and 5,000 orders.
Install 2 finalists and set up the same rewards on a copy of your theme.
My guide to the best Shopify loyalty apps compares the wider category.
What do merchants often ask about Essent Loyalty alternatives?
Which Essent Loyalty alternative is best for paid memberships?
Love Loyalty is the closest match, with paid memberships on its $79 Growth plan for up to 2,000 orders, and unlimited orders on its $399 Plus plan. Otter includes them on both plans, at $100/month on its Scaler plan for 2,000 orders, but it has no POS.
Is there a free alternative to Essent Loyalty?
Yes. Love Loyalty's free plan includes 150 orders a month. Otter's includes 100 orders with every feature, VIP tiers included, and BLOY's 200.
How much does Essent Loyalty cost in 2026?
Essent is free for 250 orders a month. Its Starter plan costs $10/month, its Essential plan $24/month and its Growth plan $79/month for up to 5,000 orders.
Is Essent Loyalty a good app?
Yes. It has 5.0 stars from 496 reviews and the lowest price at 5,000 orders on this list. But an alternative makes more sense when you need paid memberships or multi-currency.
Can you move your points from Essent Loyalty to another app?
Yes. Export balances as a CSV, then import them. BLOY offers free migration on every plan, and Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan.
Do Essent Loyalty alternatives slow down a store?
The total number of apps matters more than one widget. So test any app on your own store before and after you install it.

