Skip to content

Best Otter Loyalty alternatives reviewed in 2027

Short answer: It depends on why you're leaving Otter Loyalty. When pricing is the problem, choose Love Loyalty, because it offers a points programme, VIP tiers, POS, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes for up to 2,000 orders at $79/month, and unlimited orders for $399/month. Stay on Otter Loyalty when you sell online only and want VIP tiers and memberships on a free plan.

Otter Loyalty includes every feature, VIP tiers and memberships among them, on every plan, and its Scaler plan costs $15 a month for 300 orders. But it has no POS, support is by email only and new owners took it over in May 2025, so its 22 reviews say little about the app today.

So I installed 7 Otter Loyalty alternatives on a test store. Below, you'll find what each one is built for, what it costs as of November 2026 and what you'd give up by moving.

Why do merchants look for an Otter Loyalty alternative?

From my review of its plans, most merchants outgrow Otter Loyalty because it has no POS. I found no POS feature in the app, and no Shopify Flow or API either. So stores that also sell in person can't reward customers at the till. Every alternative I tested except S Loyalty works with Shopify POS.

From what customers shared in the reviews I read, support is the next worry. In October 2024, Fashion Hub Club said the app sent its customers 20 emails in 10 minutes and it couldn't stop them. The new owners replied in August 2025 with a support email. When I checked, Otter offered weekday email support only, while Love Loyalty, CWILL Loyalty and BON offer live chat.

I also found the record thin. Its newest review dates from May 2025, when new owners bought the app, so I couldn't tell much about how the app works today.

I found the support problem in 1 of the 22 reviews Otter Loyalty had in November 2026, so most merchants don't report it.

Which Otter Loyalty alternatives made my shortlist?

I picked apps with points, referrals and rewards that fix at least one reason merchants leave Otter. These 7 alternatives made my shortlist:

I've put each app's rating, starting price and how it charges in this table, with Otter Loyalty first as the baseline:

App Rating Starting price Charges by
Otter Loyalty 4.6 from 22 reviews Free, then $15/month Orders, with overage on both plans
Love Loyalty 5.0 from 428 reviews Free, then $12/month Monthly orders
CWILL Loyalty 4.9 from 800 reviews Free, then $19/month Orders
BLOY 5.0 from 845 reviews Free, then $10/month Orders
S Loyalty 4.4 from 235 reviews Free, then $19.99/month Order bands, averaged over 12 months
SC Loyalty Rewards 4.4 from 71 reviews Free, then $29/month Loyalty members
BON Loyalty 5.0 from 1,987 reviews Free, then $15/month Plans with order caps, unlimited on the $129 Growth plan
OneLoyalty 4.5 from 112 reviews Free, then $49/month Orders plus built-in emails, with a spending cap

Prices as of November 2026.

For POS at the lowest price, compare SC Loyalty Rewards, BLOY, Love Loyalty and CWILL Loyalty first.

How did I review these Otter Loyalty alternatives?

I installed each app on a test store, then went through every plan and what customers shared in their newest reviews. I used Otter Loyalty as the baseline for each comparison.

I looked at these details for each app:

  • POS: which plan includes Shopify POS
  • VIP tiers and memberships: which plan includes them
  • Support: which channels each app offers and when
  • Testing: whether it includes A/B testing
  • AI features: what AI does in each app
  • Integrations: which email, review and subscription apps it works with
  • Setup: how long each app took me to get a loyalty programme live
  • Design: how it looked on my test store and whether it matched my theme
  • Speed: what one more app adds to a store that already has 10 to 15 of them, as many stores do
  • Pricing: how each app charges, its plan limits and what each plan includes
  • Reviews: what customers shared in their newest reviews, including about support
  • Moving: what you can bring across from Otter Loyalty

Love Loyalty comes first because it offers a points programme, VIP tiers, POS, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes for up to 2,000 orders at $79/month. Its $399 Plus plan includes unlimited orders. The order of the other 6 isn't a ranking.

I don't give speed scores, because they depend on your theme and your other apps. Your own store is the better test, and all 7 apps have a free plan or trial.

What did I find when I compared them with Otter Loyalty?

These alternatives fall into 2 groups. Love Loyalty, CWILL Loyalty, BLOY, S Loyalty and SC Loyalty Rewards focus on the core loyalty experience: points, VIP tiers, referrals and rewards. OneLoyalty and BON spread across other features, such as games, pop-ups and built-in email marketing.

I liked the first group most. You aren't paying for games, pop-ups or email tools that many stores already run in other apps. I've also found that when an app splits its work across all of those, the loyalty programme is the part that gets compromised. Love Loyalty and BLOY were the two apps that looked native on my test store, while OneLoyalty's pop-up games didn't match my fonts and BON's floating button needed changes to match my theme.

I found 5 main differences from Otter Loyalty. The apps differ on which ones they include, so check which you need before you compare prices:

  • How the bill grows: Otter charges $5 to $10 per 100 extra orders with no cap. Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan includes up to 2,000 orders, and its $399 Plus plan includes unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume. BON's $129 Growth plan includes unlimited orders, OneLoyalty caps every paid plan, S Loyalty uses fixed bands and SC Loyalty counts members.
  • Price at 2,000 orders: Otter costs $100 on its Scaler plan. Love Loyalty costs $79 on its Growth plan, BLOY $109 on its Growth plan, BON $129 on its Growth plan, CWILL Loyalty $169 on its Pro plan and OneLoyalty $174 on its Professional plan. S Loyalty moves to its Higher Volume plan, a custom quote from $199.99, and SC Loyalty charges by loyalty members.
  • POS: Otter has none. SC Loyalty includes it free, BLOY from $10, Love Loyalty from $12, CWILL Loyalty from $19, BON from $29 and OneLoyalty from $49.
  • A/B testing: I didn't find A/B testing in any of the 8 apps.
  • Free plans: Otter, S Loyalty and OneLoyalty stop at 100 orders, Love Loyalty and BON at 150 and BLOY, CWILL Loyalty and SC Loyalty at 200.

I also found these differences in how the apps work:

  • Reports: Otter and CWILL Loyalty include reports free, BLOY adds them from $10 and BON from $29.
  • AI features: Love Loyalty suggests a loyalty programme for your store with AI on its $79 Growth plan. BLOY uses AI onboarding, BON's setup assistant suggests a points strategy and OneLoyalty adds AI analytics on its $49 Growth plan. I didn't find AI in the others.
  • Setup: the alternatives took me 15 to 18 minutes, against Otter's 16. Love Loyalty was fastest at 15, and feature-rich apps sat at the top of that range.
  • Design: Love Loyalty and BLOY looked native on my test store. CWILL Loyalty, BON, OneLoyalty, S Loyalty and SC Loyalty use widgets, like Otter. OneLoyalty and SC Loyalty didn't match my theme's fonts.
  • Speed: the total number of apps on your store matters more than any single one.

What are the best Otter Loyalty alternatives?

Love Loyalty is my top pick for Otter Loyalty stores that sell in person as well as online. For Shopify stores, I'd choose its $79 Growth plan, which includes POS, paid memberships and 1-click cart redemption for up to 2,000 orders a month. For Shopify Plus brands, I'd choose its $399 Plus plan, which offers everything in Growth with unlimited orders.

CWILL Loyalty comes next for live chat at any hour and POS from $19. The other 5 suit stores that want free migration (BLOY), a simple long-running app (S Loyalty), POS on a free plan (SC Loyalty Rewards), one price at any volume (BON) and games with a capped bill (OneLoyalty). But the order-based ones all cost more. At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty's Growth plan costs $79, while BLOY costs $109, BON $129, CWILL Loyalty $169, OneLoyalty $174 and S Loyalty a custom quote from $199.99. SC Loyalty Rewards charges by loyalty members instead of orders.

1. Love Loyalty: Best for an all-in-one native loyalty app with fixed pricing

Love Loyalty, an Otter Loyalty alternative for Shopify

Love Loyalty is an all-in-one native loyalty app for Shopify and Shopify Plus brands. It offers points, VIP tiers, referrals and paid memberships in one app, at a published monthly price. I'd choose it when you sell in store and Otter can't follow customers to the till.

Why I like this app: Redeeming in the cart stood out first. On my test store, customers spent their points directly in the cart, with no pop-up widget to open. So the reward stays in view at the moment they decide to buy.

It was also the most native app in my test. Points appeared on the product page, and the loyalty page sat inside my theme. Each placement took on my theme's fonts and colours without any CSS, so the programme reads as part of your store from launch.

Setup took me 15 minutes, the fastest of the apps I tested.

Compared with Otter Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty costs $79/month on its Growth plan and offers a points programme, VIP tiers, POS, bonus campaigns, paid memberships and Apple and Google Wallet passes. Otter's Scaler plan costs $100 at that volume, so moving lowers your bill by $21 a month and adds the POS Otter doesn't have.

Above 2,000 orders a month, Love Loyalty costs $399/month on its Plus plan and offers everything in Growth, API access and unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume. Otter keeps adding $5 per 100 orders with no cap, so it stays cheaper than the $399 Plus plan below 8,000 orders and reaches $500 at 10,000.

But you'd give up VIP tiers and memberships on a free plan. Otter includes every feature on every plan, while Love Loyalty keeps both for its $79 Growth plan.

Features:

  • Shopify POS earning and redemption, with staff enrolment through a small widget, on the $12 Professional plan
  • Paid memberships, with perks you set for members, on the $79 Growth plan
  • Points, referrals and cart redemption on the free plan
  • A loyalty page, 20+ placements and points expiry on the $12 Professional plan
  • Integrations with Klaviyo, Recharge, Shopify Flow and 30+ other apps on the $12 Professional plan
  • VIP tiers, B2B loyalty, rewards for activities, wallet passes, bonus campaigns and AI programme suggestions on the $79 Growth plan
  • Checkout extensions, API access and unlimited orders on the $399 Plus plan

Pricing: Love Loyalty charges by monthly orders:

  • Free: 150 orders a month
  • Professional: $12/month, 500 orders
  • Growth: $79/month, up to 2,000 orders
  • Plus: $399/month, unlimited orders
  • Trial: 14 days

Reviews: Love Loyalty has 5.0 stars from 428 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise support and cart redemption. In October 2026, Northern Bead asked for points to apply automatically once a customer reaches a reward.

Best for: Shopify stores that sell online and in store and want points, VIP tiers, POS and paid memberships in one native app on the $79 Growth plan, and Shopify Plus brands that want unlimited orders on the $399 Plus plan.

I wouldn't choose it if: You want games in your programme. Love Loyalty doesn't include games or gamified campaigns, while OneLoyalty includes pop-up games such as spin the wheel.

See my full Love Loyalty review for its pros, cons and pricing.

See Love Loyalty on the Shopify App Store

2. CWILL Loyalty: Best for 24/7 live chat and POS from $19

CWILL Loyalty, an Otter Loyalty alternative for Shopify

CWILL Loyalty & Referrals is a points, VIP and referral app. Choose it when Otter's weekday email support leaves you waiting.

Why I like this app: Support is there around the clock. Every plan includes 24/7 live chat, email support and guided setup. The free plan adds points, referrals, review rewards and custom CSS for 200 orders. Setup took me 17 minutes.

Compared with Otter Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, CWILL Loyalty costs $169/month on its Pro plan and offers points, referrals, review rewards, POS, VIP tiers, points expiry and 20 storefront languages. Otter's Scaler plan costs $100 at that volume, so moving to CWILL Loyalty raises your bill by $69 a month. On my test store, it showed as a widget, and I used custom CSS to line it up with my theme. You'd give up memberships, and VIP tiers on a free plan.

Features:

  • Shopify POS on the $19 Essential plan
  • Shopify Flow on every plan
  • API and webhooks on the Enterprise plan, a custom quote
  • Live chat and email support around the clock on every plan
  • VIP tiers, points expiry and smart tags on the Pro plan, from $69/month
  • Judge.me, Klaviyo, Omnisend and Seal Subscriptions

I didn't find AI features in its loyalty plans.

Pricing: CWILL Loyalty charges by monthly orders:

  • Free: 200 orders
  • Essential: $19/month for 200 orders or $29/month for 500, then $20 per 100
  • Pro: $69 (500 orders), $99 (1,000), $169 (2,000) or $229 (3,000) a month, then $15 per 100
  • Enterprise: custom quote
  • Trial: 14 days on paid plans

Reviews: CWILL Loyalty has 4.9 stars from 800 reviews on the Shopify App Store, and it replied to all 15 reviews I read where customers shared a problem. Reviewers praise its translations. wimsical wardrobe (January 2026) says it couldn't use most functions in its region, and CWILL replied to clarify the plans.

Best for: Stores that want help at any hour and a programme in their customers' languages.

I wouldn't choose it if: You expect more than 3,000 orders a month, because every store above that needs a custom quote. BON's $129 Growth plan includes unlimited orders.

For its plans and merchant feedback in full, read my CWILL Loyalty review.

See CWILL Loyalty on the Shopify App Store

3. BLOY: Best for free, done-for-you migration

BLOY, an Otter Loyalty alternative for Shopify

BLOY is a loyalty app from a Singapore team. I'd choose it when you want someone else to move your Otter data.

Why I like this app: Its team moves points, VIP tiers and customer history from your current app for free, on any plan. On my test store, members earned and redeemed on product pages, in the cart and in customer accounts, rather than through a pop-up alone. AI onboarding took branding from my store, and the result matched my fonts and looked clean.

Compared with Otter Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, BLOY costs $109/month on its Growth plan and offers points, VIP tiers with entry rewards and custom perks, POS and Shopify Flow. Otter's Scaler plan costs $100 at that volume, so your bill rises by $9 a month. On my test store, BLOY looked native, and setup took me 17 minutes. You'd give up memberships and a free referral programme, and BLOY's free plan watermark can't be removed.

Features:

  • Earning and redeeming in store with Shopify POS from the $10 Launch plan
  • Shopify Flow and every app integration on the $10 Launch plan
  • API access and headless support for Hydrogen on the $129 Unlimited plan
  • 24/7 human support on the free plan
  • VIP tiers with entry rewards on the $49 Growth plan
  • Klaviyo, Judge.me, Gorgias and Mailchimp

Pricing: BLOY charges by monthly orders:

  • Free: 200 orders
  • Launch: $10/month, 500 orders, then $15 per 100
  • Growth: $49/month, 1,500 orders, then $12 per 100
  • Unlimited: $129/month, 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100
  • Trial: 14 days on paid plans

Reviews: BLOY has 5.0 stars from 845 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Reviewers praise quick support. But Still I Run (August 2026) wrote "every time I requested help, they asked me to leave a review".

Best for: Stores that want POS and Flow from $10 and a team to handle the move.

I wouldn't choose it if: You sell Otter's memberships today, because I didn't find paid memberships on BLOY's plans. OneLoyalty includes them on its $199 Premium plan.

The BLOY review goes through every plan and what merchants say.

See BLOY on the Shopify App Store

4. S Loyalty: Best for a simple points programme with a long record

S Loyalty, an Otter Loyalty alternative for Shopify

S Loyalty is a points app from a Hong Kong team, with 14 years on the App Store. Choose it when plain points, pay with points and bonus campaigns are all you need.

Why I like this app: The free plan includes 3 rewards, a birthday bonus and colour theming for 100 orders. Paid plans add points expiry and 2x or 3x bonus campaigns. Points and rewards were simple to set up, and the whole programme took me 16 minutes.

Compared with Otter Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, S Loyalty moves to its Higher Volume plan, a custom quote from $199.99, and offers points, pay with points, 20+ rewards, bonus campaigns and free interface design. Otter's Scaler plan costs $100 at that volume, so moving at least doubles your bill. On my test store, it showed as a rewards tab, with the embedded widget on the $39.99 Standard plan and S Loyalty branding until the $119.99 Premium plan. You'd give up VIP tiers, memberships and built-in referrals, because S Loyalty sends referrals to ReferralCandy, a separate app.

Features:

  • 3 fixed-amount rewards, a birthday bonus and colour theming on the free plan
  • Welcome bonuses and 2x or 3x points campaigns on the $19.99 Basic plan
  • Holiday bonuses, special points events and thank-you messages
  • Up to 20 rewards on the $119.99 Premium plan
  • ReferralCandy for referrals, with Langify and Weglot for translation

I didn't find any AI features in it.

Pricing: S Loyalty charges by monthly orders, averaged over 12 months:

  • Free: 100 orders
  • Basic: $19.99/month, 50 orders
  • Standard: $39.99/month, 200 orders
  • Pro: $69.99/month, 350 orders
  • Premium: $119.99/month, 1,000 orders
  • Higher Volume: custom quote, from $199.99/month, above 1,000 orders
  • Trial: 14 days on paid plans

Reviews: S Loyalty has 4.4 stars from 235 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Longer-term users praise stable performance. GREAT DOG CO. (May 2026) wrote "Shopify needs to remove this app" after 3 unanswered contacts in a week.

Best for: Stores that want a basic points programme with pay with points and seasonal bonuses.

I wouldn't choose it if: You use Otter's VIP tiers or referrals, because S Loyalty has neither. CWILL Loyalty includes referrals on every plan and VIP tiers from its $69 Pro plan.

See S Loyalty on the Shopify App Store

5. SC Loyalty Rewards: Best for POS on a free plan

SC Loyalty Rewards, an Otter Loyalty alternative for Shopify

SC Loyalty Rewards is the former Loyalty Points by Bold, now run by Shop Circle. Choose it when you want in-store points without paying for a plan.

Why I like this app: Shopify POS works on the free plan, for up to 200 members. The $29 Starter plan adds 3 customer tiers, referrals and Shopify Flow, and every paid plan has a 30-day trial. Setup took me 16 minutes, mostly on points, tiers and referrals.

Compared with Otter Loyalty: SC Loyalty Rewards charges by loyalty members, not orders. Its $29 Starter plan offers points, 3 customer tiers, referrals, POS and Shopify Flow for 500 members, then $0.05 per extra member, capped at $499. Otter's Scaler plan costs $100 at 2,000 orders, so SC Loyalty costs less while you have fewer than about 1,900 members, but every customer who joins counts. On my test store, its widget sat on top of the theme and didn't match my fonts, where Otter's did. You'd give up memberships.

Features:

  • In-store points through Shopify POS on the free plan
  • Referrals and 3 customer tiers on the $29 Starter plan
  • Unlimited rewards and active campaigns on the $199 Growth plan
  • Points for signing up, buying, sharing on social media and birthdays
  • Money-off and free-shipping reward coupons
  • Branded widgets, icons and emails

I didn't find any AI features in it.

Pricing: SC Loyalty Rewards charges by loyalty members:

  • Free: up to 200 members
  • Starter: $29/month, 500 members, then $0.05 per member, capped at $499
  • Growth: $199/month, 5,000 members, then $0.03 per member, capped at $999
  • Enterprise: $499/month, 25,000 members, capped at $1,999
  • Trial: 30 days on paid plans

Reviews: SC Loyalty Rewards has 4.4 stars from 71 reviews on the Shopify App Store. In the newest review I read where a customer shared a problem, Neha Assar Artistry (March 2025) said customers couldn't redeem rewards. Shop Circle replied.

Best for: Small shops with a short customer list that want POS points for free.

I wouldn't choose it if: Your customer list is much larger than your monthly orders, because every member counts. BLOY charges by orders.

Want more detail first? Read the SC Loyalty Rewards review.

See SC Loyalty Rewards on the Shopify App Store

6. BON Loyalty: Best for a bill that stops at $129

BON Loyalty, an Otter Loyalty alternative for Shopify

BON Loyalty is a points, VIP and referral app with flat plans and no overage. I'd choose it when Otter's per-order charges keep climbing as you grow.

Why I like this app: Its $129 Growth plan includes unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume. That plan also includes VIP tiers, B2B tiers, points on product pages and custom CSS. Setup took me 17 minutes.

Compared with Otter Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, BON costs $129/month on its Growth plan and offers VIP tiers, B2B tiers, POS, points on product pages and unlimited orders. Otter's Scaler plan costs $100 at that volume, so your bill rises by $29 a month, but at 5,000 orders Otter reaches $250 while BON stays at $129. On my test store, it showed as a floating loyalty button and needed changes to match my theme. You'd give up memberships, and VIP tiers on a free plan.

Features:

  • In-store rewards through Shopify POS on the $29 Basic plan
  • Shopify Flow and unlimited integrations on the $29 Basic plan
  • API access and an SDK on the Plus plan, a custom quote
  • 24/7 chat and email support from the free plan
  • VIP tiers plus B2B tiers on the $129 Growth plan

Pricing: BON charges by plan, with order caps below the $129 Growth plan:

  • Free: 150 orders a month
  • Starter: $15/month, 300 orders
  • Basic: $29/month, 500 orders
  • Growth: $129/month, unlimited orders
  • Plus: custom quote
  • Trial: 7 days, one per store

Reviews: BON has 5.0 stars from 1,987 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Merchants who left reviews praise its 24/7 chat. William Glen (February 2024) says Amazon orders count towards the order limit, and BON replied.

Best for: Growing stores that want VIP tiers at one price, whatever their order count.

I wouldn't choose it if: You want POS on a small plan, because BON starts it on Basic at $29. SC Loyalty Rewards includes POS on its free plan.

My BON Loyalty review covers its setup, support and verdict.

See BON Loyalty on the Shopify App Store

7. OneLoyalty: Best for games and a capped monthly bill

OneLoyalty, an Otter Loyalty alternative for Shopify

OneLoyalty combines points, games and built-in loyalty emails. Choose it when you want spin-the-wheel games and a bill with a ceiling.

Why I like this app: Every paid plan caps the bill. The $49 Growth plan stops at $299, the $99 Professional plan at $499, the $199 Premium plan at $999 and the $499 Enterprise plan at $1,999. The $49 Growth plan also adds games, campaigns, 2,000 built-in email sends and POS. Setup took me 18 minutes.

Compared with Otter Loyalty: At 2,000 orders a month, OneLoyalty costs $174/month on its Professional plan and offers points, referrals, games, campaigns, POS, points expiry and AI analytics. Otter's Scaler plan costs $100 at that volume, so your bill rises by $74 a month, though OneLoyalty caps it at $499 where Otter's overage has no cap. On my test store, its widget and pop-up games didn't match my fonts, where Otter's widget did. You'd give up VIP tiers and memberships, which OneLoyalty keeps for its $199 Premium plan.

Features:

  • Points for purchases and basic reward redemption on the free plan
  • Games such as spin the wheel and 2 active campaigns on the $49 Growth plan
  • A virtual loyalty card and exclusive products on the $99 Professional plan
  • VIP tiers, a secret tier and paid memberships on the $199 Premium plan
  • Judge.me, Yotpo and Shopify Flow integrations

Pricing: OneLoyalty charges by orders and built-in emails, with a cap:

  • Free: 100 orders and 100 emails a month
  • Growth: $49/month, 1,000 orders, then $0.15 per order and $3 per 100 extra emails, capped at $299
  • Professional: $99/month, 1,500 orders, then $0.15 per order, capped at $499
  • Premium: $199/month, 3,000 orders, then $0.10 per order, capped at $999
  • Enterprise: $499/month, 10,000+ orders, then $0.05 per order, capped at $1,999
  • Trial: 14 days, with a 30-day guarantee on the $49 Growth plan

Reviews: OneLoyalty has 4.5 stars from 112 reviews on the Shopify App Store. NBM (June 2025) says the app added a page offering a $20 app-download discount without approval, and the OneMobile team replied.

Best for: Stores that want games in their programme and a known maximum bill.

I wouldn't choose it if: You want VIP tiers without a $199 plan. Love Loyalty offers them on its $79 Growth plan for up to 2,000 orders.

See my full OneLoyalty review for its pros, cons and pricing.

See OneLoyalty on the Shopify App Store

How do you choose between Otter Loyalty and these alternatives?

Name the reason you're leaving, then confirm that the new app fixes it at a price you can pay. These 5 questions will shorten the list.

Start with the problem. For most Otter users, it's POS or support. Check the plan you'd need at your order volume.

Then list the Otter features you use. Otter includes VIP tiers and memberships on every plan. Love Loyalty offers paid memberships on its $79 Growth plan for up to 2,000 orders, and OneLoyalty on its $199 Premium plan.

Look at your theme next. Love Loyalty and BLOY sat inside my theme and matched its fonts. Check your top two on a phone.

Then check integrations. Otter works with Klaviyo and Judge.me only, and every alternative except S Loyalty, SC Loyalty and OneLoyalty works with Klaviyo.

Finally, read recent reviews about support. In the newest S Loyalty reviews I read, customers shared contacts that went unanswered.

Choose Love Loyalty when your loyalty programme needs to work at your shop counter too. At 2,000 orders a month, it costs only $79/month on its Growth plan and offers POS enrolment through a staff widget that switches benefits on in your shop straight away, points, VIP tiers and wallet passes. Otter Loyalty's $15 Scaler plan comes to $100 at that volume. For Shopify Plus brands, Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan offers unlimited orders, so the price doesn't grow with order volume.

Choose CWILL Loyalty for 24/7 live chat in 20 languages, and BON for one price at any volume. Stay on Otter Loyalty when you sell online only and want VIP tiers and memberships on its free plan or its $15 Scaler plan.

Will an Otter Loyalty alternative cost you less?

Only Love Loyalty does at 2,000 orders. Otter costs $100/month on its Scaler plan there, and Love Loyalty costs $79/month on its Growth plan. BLOY, BON, CWILL Loyalty and OneLoyalty cost more, and S Loyalty moves to a custom quote.

Otter charges $5 per 100 orders above 300 on its Scaler plan, with no cap. Most alternatives here charge by orders too, BON's $129 Growth plan includes unlimited orders and SC Loyalty charges by loyalty members. When I priced them, Love Loyalty's $79 Growth plan and OneLoyalty's $199 Premium plan were the only plans that keep Otter's paid memberships.

Say you process 2,000 orders a month. Otter costs $100/month on its Scaler plan. These alternatives cost:

  • Love Loyalty: $79/month on its Growth plan
  • BLOY: $109/month on its Growth plan
  • BON: $129/month on its Growth plan
  • CWILL Loyalty: $169/month on its Pro plan
  • OneLoyalty: $174/month on its Professional plan
  • S Loyalty: a custom quote from $199.99/month on its Higher Volume plan

SC Loyalty prices by loyalty members, so its Starter plan costs $29 for 500 members, then $0.05 per extra member, capped at $499.

At 5,000 orders, Otter reaches $250 and BON costs less at $129 on its Growth plan. Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan includes unlimited orders, so it overtakes Otter only above about 8,000 orders.

Over 2 years at 2,000 orders, Otter costs about $2,400 on monthly billing, and Love Loyalty about $1,896.

Before you compare, ask each developer what happens in a month when you pass your limit.

Can you keep every feature on a free plan when you leave Otter Loyalty?

No. Otter is the only app here with every feature on every plan, including VIP tiers and memberships on its free plan.

The closest free plans each offer part of it. CWILL Loyalty includes points, referrals and review rewards for 200 orders, and SC Loyalty includes POS for 200 members.

Before you leave, note each VIP tier's rules and perks, so you can rebuild them.

When does it make sense to stay on Otter Loyalty?

I'd stay on Otter Loyalty if you sell online only and use its VIP tiers or memberships on fewer than 300 orders a month.

Every feature comes on every plan, including VIP tiers, memberships and reports.

As a baseline, Otter took me 16 minutes to set up. It shows as a widget with a rewards page and product-page rewards, and it matched my store.

Its Starter plan is free for 100 orders, and its Scaler plan costs $15 for 300, with no trial. See Otter Loyalty on the Shopify App Store.

How do you move from Otter Loyalty to another app?

No app here offers an Otter import by name. But Otter includes data export on every plan, and your customers and orders stay in Shopify.

I'd save these from Otter Loyalty before you change anything:

  • Every earning rule, reward, VIP tier and membership perk
  • Your widget, rewards page and email designs, as screenshots
  • Points balances and tiers, as a data export

Use these steps with any of the apps:

  1. Export your data and write down every rule and reward.
  2. Install the new app on its free plan or trial, and set it up on a copy of your theme.
  3. Import your balances, then check a few customers by hand.
  4. Set up the same programme you have on Otter, so you're comparing like with like, then check it on your phone.
  5. Upgrade only if it does the job, then publish the theme.
  6. Turn off Otter's automated emails, then remove the app and its embed before your next billing date.

BLOY migrates data for you on any plan, and Love Loyalty on its $79 Growth plan.

After you uninstall, send a test order and check that no Otter emails go out. Keep your export for a year.

What changes in unusual situations?

The main changes come at high volume and across several languages.

At 10,000 orders, Otter costs $500 on its Scaler plan, because its overage has no cap. Love Loyalty's $399 Plus plan includes unlimited orders, so it doesn't charge by order volume, and BON's $129 Growth plan includes unlimited orders too.

For several languages, CWILL Loyalty, BLOY and SC Loyalty offer 20, Otter 12 and OneLoyalty 8.

Which Otter Loyalty alternative would I start with?

I'd start with Love Loyalty. For Shopify stores, its $79 Growth plan offers POS, VIP tiers, bonus campaigns and paid memberships for up to 2,000 orders a month, and for Shopify Plus brands, its $399 Plus plan adds unlimited orders. Choose CWILL Loyalty when you want live chat at any hour, and BON when you want a price that stays flat as you grow. Stay on Otter when you sell online only and want VIP tiers and memberships on a free plan.

Install your 2 finalists, set up the same programme on a copy of your theme and compare them over a week of real orders.

My guide to the best Shopify loyalty apps compares the wider category.

What do merchants often ask about Otter Loyalty alternatives?

Which Otter Loyalty alternative is best for POS?

Love Loyalty is the closest match. Its $79 Growth plan offers POS, VIP tiers and paid memberships for up to 2,000 orders, and its $399 Plus plan adds unlimited orders for Shopify Plus brands. SC Loyalty includes POS on its free plan.

Is there a free alternative to Otter Loyalty?

Yes. Love Loyalty's free plan includes 150 orders a month. SC Loyalty includes POS on its free plan for 200 members, and CWILL Loyalty includes points, referrals and 24/7 live chat free for 200 orders.

How much does Otter Loyalty cost in 2026?

Otter Loyalty's Starter plan is free for 100 orders, then $10 per 100 extra orders. Its Scaler plan costs $15/month for 300 orders, then $5 per 100.

Is Otter Loyalty a good app?

Yes for small online stores, rated 4.6 from 22 reviews. But it has no POS, so an alternative makes more sense when you sell in store.

Can you move your points balances from Otter Loyalty to another app?

Yes. Otter includes data export on every plan, and BLOY migrates data for you. Rules, rewards and designs need rebuilding.

Do Otter Loyalty alternatives slow down a store?

The total number of apps on your store matters more than one app, so test any app on your own store before and after you install it.

A
Written by

Alan